A University Consortium Dedicated To Developing The Theory ✓ Solved
A university consortium dedicated to developing the theory and practic
A university consortium dedicated to developing the theory and practic of negotiation and dispute resolution. Harvard | MIT | Tufts PON054 Bakra Beverage Confidential Instructions for BebsiCo’s Director of Middle East Operations You are the Director of Middle East Operations for BebsiCo, a multi-billion-dollar beverage company with a number of food and merchandise subsidiaries, and one of the world’s two largest beverage producers. You have been with BebsiCo for three months, and your principal responsibility is negotiating beverage distribution agreements between BebsiCo and its distributors in the Middle East. So far, things have been going well, but your upcoming negotiation will be your most important assignment to date.
You will be meeting with the Sales Director of Bakra Beverage, a soft drink (flavored soda) distributor in the Middle Eastern country of Kumar. Your goal is to ensure that your boss, the Vice President for Distribution, is pleased with the outcome. Recent political upheaval in Kumar has drastically changed the market landscape: four years ago, Kumar was prosperous with an educated middle class and a thriving tourist industry, but it then fell under an oppressive fundamentalist regime that expelled Western companies, severely damaging BebsiCo’s ability to operate there, except for a limited distribution arrangement in the Kumari province of Melhand.
Recently, political stability has returned after an uprising that ousted the fundamentalist government, and Kumar is showing signs of economic recovery. BebsiCo now aims to re-enter the market quickly before competing firms, particularly Loca Cola, can establish a foothold. Currently, Kumar has three beverage distributors: Kabir Cola, Bakra Beverage, and Jayyid Juices. Kabir Cola, the largest, has historically been profitable and reliable, but it has recently decided to cease operations in Kumar following the conviction of its CEO for corporate fraud—a move that signals instability and risks tarnishing its reputation, akin to Enron. BebsiCo needs to sign a new distribution deal promptly to avoid losing out to competitors.
Bakra Beverage, although currently troubled financially, has expressed interest in handling Kumar’s distribution. The company previously distributed BebsiCo’s products in Kumar, earning $3.3 million annually five years ago, although its recent operations have been limited. BebsiCo is prepared to offer Bakra up to $6.75 million for a contract if necessary but prefers to negotiate a reasonable fee—aiming around $4.5 million, in line with past agreements, while being willing to go higher if needed. BebsiCo is also considering the alternative of working with Jayyid Juices, which has poor distribution performance in Kumar and charges about $5 million in fees.
BebsiCo’s objectives include maximizing market penetration, reaching at least 70% of Kumar’s retail outlets annually, and elevating its image in the Middle East as a supporter of developing economies and humane labor practices. The company’s critical concern is launching its soft drink line in Kumar swiftly to preempt Loca Cola’s entry and capitalize on the market’s recovery potential.
Given the political and economic instability, distribution costs have increased, and the risk of unreliable partners is significant. BebsiCo wants to avoid public disclosures of unusually high fees to maintain future negotiation leverage. The company’s target is to secure a distribution partner that can reliably reach the majority of the market, operate effectively in a complex environment, and uphold its corporate social responsibility commitments.
Your task is to prepare for a negotiation with Bakra’s Sales Director, aiming to secure a distribution agreement at a fair price that maximizes BebsiCo’s market potential while avoiding excessive costs and protecting its strategic interests in Kumar.
Sample Paper For Above instruction
Introduction
Negotiating distribution agreements in emerging markets involves complex considerations that encompass economic, political, logistical, and ethical factors. In the context of BebsiCo's recent re-entry into the Kumar market, strategic negotiations with potential distributors are critical to ensure swift market penetration, competitive advantage, and alignment with corporate values. This paper explores effective negotiation strategies, analyzing the specific circumstances faced by BebsiCo and its potential partners, with a focus on Bakra Beverage. The discussion balances the need for competitive pricing, reliability, and corporate social responsibility, providing a comprehensive approach to achieving mutually beneficial agreement outcomes.
Contextual Background
Kumar's political upheaval significantly impacted its economic stability and business environment. The ousting of the fundamentalist regime and subsequent return to stability opened opportunities for foreign companies like BebsiCo. However, the volatile political climate increases risks associated with distribution operations, necessitating careful negotiation that balances cost, reliability, and corporate responsibility. The incumbent distributors, Kabir Cola’s downfall, and Bakra’s troubled financial situation further complicate the negotiation landscape.
Analysis of Distributors
Kabir Cola was previously BebsiCo’s largest and most reliable distributor but has exited the market following legal issues. Its departure opens a window for new partnerships but also raises concerns about stability and reputation. The risk of association with a company involved in fraud is a significant factor affecting BebsiCo’s brand image.
Bakra Beverage, despite its recent financial difficulties, has historical familiarity with BebsiCo’s products and earlier distribution structures, signifying potential stability and market knowledge. The company’s willingness to renegotiate at a lower fee reflects its motivations to recover the market share lost due to financial troubles, and its prior experience in Kumar suggests a degree of operational capability.
Jayyid Juices presents a less favorable option given its poor performance and higher costs. The company’s limited experience with soft drinks and ineffective past distribution further weaken its position as a reliable partner, especially in a challenging political environment requiring operational resilience.
Negotiation Strategies
Effective negotiation with Bakra requires understanding its financial constraints, previous distribution success, and strategic motivations. The following strategies are recommended:
- Establish Trust and Reliability: Emphasize BebsiCo's commitment to long-term partnership, corporate social responsibility, and stability, which may appeal to Bakra’s desire to rebuild credibility.
- Price Anchoring: Use prior contract benchmarks as anchor points, proposing a fee around $3-4 million initially, with flexibility up to $6.75 million to accommodate unforeseen costs.
- Value-Added Incentives: Offer performance-based incentives, such as increased fees for exceeding distribution targets or expanding market coverage, which align BebsiCo’s interests with Bakra’s operational improvements.
- Risk Mitigation Measures: Include clauses that address political instability, such as flexible termination rights or contingency plans, to safeguard BebsiCo’s investments.
- Leverage Alternative Options: Signal willingness to work with other distributors like Jayyid Juices if negotiations falter but prioritize Bakra based on its previous experience and local market knowledge.
Conclusion
Successfully negotiating with Bakra requires a delicate balance between competitive pricing, reliable distribution capabilities, and adherence to corporate values. Given the recent political upheaval in Kumar and Bakra’s financial hurdles, BebsiCo must adopt a flexible yet strategic approach, emphasizing long-term partnership, risk mitigation, and value creation. Achieving an optimal agreement will enable BebsiCo to re-establish its presence swiftly in Kumar and secure a competitive advantage over rivals like Loca Cola, ensuring long-term growth and brand reputation enhancement in the Middle Eastern beverage market.
References
- Fisher, R., Ury, W. L., & Patton, B. (2011). Getting to Yes: Negotiating Agreement Without Giving In. Penguin.
- Lewicki, R. J., Saunders, D. M., & Barry, B. (2015). Negotiation. McGraw-Hill Education.
- Thompson, L. (2013). The Mind and Heart of the Negotiator. Pearson Education.
- Shell, G. R. (2006). Negotiation and Dispute Resolution. Sage Publications.
- Carnevale, P. J., & Pruitt, D. G. (1992). Negotiation in Social Conflict. Open Court Publishing.
- Salacuse, J. W. (2012). The Global Negotiator: Making, Managing and Mending Deals around the World in the Twenty-First Century. Palgrave Macmillan.
- Raiffa, H. (2002). Negotiation Analysis. Harvard University Press.
- Mnookin, R. H., & Ross, L. (1995). Negotiation in the Shadow of the Law. Stanford Law Review.
- Ury, W. (1991). Getting Past No: Negotiating in Difficult Situations. Bantam Books.
- Harvard Law School Program on Negotiation. (2015). Negotiation and Leadership. Harvard University.