ACC 640 Final Project Guidelines And Rubric Overview

ACC 640 Final Project Guidelines and Rubric Overview The Final Project

The final project for this course involves creating an audit report with supporting memos. As auditing is a crucial skill in accounting and business, it prepares you to handle compliance, federal, IRS, internal, governmental, or revenue audits that you or your organization may face. You will evaluate financial statements, analyze risks, perform tests on business transactions, and communicate audit results professionally. The project comprises three milestones, each submitted at different course modules, culminating in a comprehensive final report due in Module Nine.

The core elements of the project include analyzing risk factors across financial statements, developing audit strategies, designing audit programs and sampling plans, and drafting memos to executive management. You will assume the role of internal auditor for a publicly traded company, specifically selecting from Walmart, Target, Sears, Kroger, or Amazon. You are expected to obtain the last two years' financial statements and a recent audit report. Your analysis will focus on preparing for an upcoming revenue audit and identifying internal business risks to mitigate potential issues.

In the Procedures and Field Work section, you will describe how to conduct the audit, including analytical procedures to investigate transactions, especially high-risk cash and revenue transactions, and demonstrate how to communicate findings visually through charts or supporting documentation. You will also design tests to evaluate the assertions related to these high-risk transactions.

In the Risk Factors section, you will analyze the income statement, balance sheet, and cash and revenue components for potential risks and compliance with GAAP or IFRS standards. Additionally, you will examine internal controls over cash and revenue, compare this data to industry or historical benchmarks, and identify risks. Based on this information, you will develop a sampling program for audit testing and select suitable procedures aligned with identified risks.

In the Memos section, you will draft summaries for senior management, including a memo to the CFO outlining the audit process, potential areas requiring additional audit procedures, and risk mitigation recommendations. As the CFO, you will then prepare a memo for the Board of Directors discussing likely findings, responses, and implementation strategies for risk mitigation based on the external audit results. The complete report, including memos, must span 8–10 pages, formatted with double spacing, 12-point Times New Roman font, and one-inch margins.

Paper For Above instruction

Audit reports are vital tools for maintaining transparency, ensuring compliance, and improving internal controls within organizations. Conducting a thorough internal audit focused on revenue, cash flow, and related business transactions involves a systematic approach that includes detailed procedures, thoughtful risk analysis, and clear communication with stakeholders. This paper explores these phases in the context of preparing for an internal revenue audit at a major publicly traded company, such as Walmart, Target, Sears, Kroger, or Amazon.

Procedures and Field Work

The audit process begins with planning and conducting analytical procedures to identify anomalies and investigate significant business transactions. To review transactions effectively, I would start by reviewing the company's general ledger, verifying journal entries, invoices, and supporting documentation for revenue recognition. Methods such as ratio analysis—comparing revenue figures to past periods or industry benchmarks—and trend analysis would be central. These procedures help detect inconsistencies or unusual fluctuations indicating potential misstatements or fraud.

The plan to utilize these procedures involves targeted sampling of transactions, especially those at high risk of misstatement, such as large or unusual sales, transactions near the end of reporting periods, or revenue recognized before delivery of goods or services. These analytical procedures could be complemented by substantive tests and walkthroughs to understand transaction flow and internal controls.

For reviewing high-risk cash and revenue transactions, fieldwork would include physically inspecting a sample of sales invoices, examining supporting documents, and conducting interviews with personnel involved in revenue recognition processes. Employing visualization tools such as flowcharts would help illustrate the transaction cycle, identify bottlenecks, or points where controls could be weak. Supporting documentation like transaction logs and control checklists can enhance understanding and provide audit trail clarity.

To assess assertions such as occurrence, completeness, accuracy, and rights and obligations, I would design specific tests. For example, to test occurrence, verifying whether recorded sales are supported by valid invoices and delivery documentation. To evaluate completeness, reconciling shipping logs with recorded revenue. These assertions underpin many audit procedures and are critical when evaluating high-risk transactions.

Risk Factors Analysis

Analyzing the income statement involves scrutinizing revenue figures, gross profit margins, and expense relationships to identify potential revenue recognition issues or compliance violations with GAAP/IFRS. For example, unusually high revenue growth compared to industry averages might signal premature revenue recognition or aggressive accounting policies.

Similarly, the balance sheet analysis includes reviewing accounts receivable aging, valuation allowances, and deferred revenue balances for signs of overstatement or understatement. Risk factors could include unconfirmed receivables, unusual fluctuations, or related-party transactions that could distort financial positions.

Internal controls over cash and revenue are evaluated by examining segregation of duties, authorization procedures, and automated control systems. Comparing these internal control metrics against industry benchmarks and historical company data helps identify deviations that could signal potential vulnerabilities. For instance, weak controls over cash collections or revenue recognition might increase the risk of misstatement or fraud.

Understanding the audit universe—the complete set of transactions and account balances subject to audit—is essential for developing a comprehensive sampling approach. I would define the universe by considering all revenue transactions over the selected period, emphasizing high-value or high-risk items. The sample size and selection method would be based on statistical models or judgmental criteria to maximize audit efficiency and effectiveness.

Based on identified risks, I would devise a sampling program that includes both statistical and judgmental sampling techniques. For high-risk transactions, a judgmental approach targeting specific transactions may be more suitable, whereas for the broader population, statistical sampling provides estimates with known confidence levels. The objective is to select representative samples that allow reliable conclusions about transaction validity and control effectiveness.

Potential audit testing procedures include confirmation of receivables, cutoff tests around period-end, and substantive analytical procedures comparing recorded revenue with cash receipts or shipment records. These procedures, when appropriately selected, effectively test the key assertions and mitigate the risk of material misstatement.

Management Memos and Strategic Recommendations

Drafting memos to management is a critical component for conveying audit findings. The CFO memo summarizes the audit process, emphasizing the testing procedures performed, areas requiring further audit work, and preliminary conclusions. Recommendations may involve implementing enhanced internal controls, increasing substantive testing in high-risk areas, or adjusting revenue recognition policies to align more closely with GAAP principles.

As the CFO, preparing a memo for the Board involves evaluating the potential findings, including identified risks, control deficiencies, or possible misstatements. The memorandum should outline the company's response strategies, such as strengthening controls, staff training, or adopting new policies to prevent future issues. Additionally, a clear plan for implementing these strategies involves timeline setting, assigning responsibilities, and establishing monitoring procedures to ensure continuous compliance and risk mitigation.

Effective communication underpins successful internal audit processes. Leveraging industry-specific language and framing issues through a risk management lens ensure that leadership understands the significance of findings and the necessity of proactive action. Ultimately, the audit report and memos serve as tools to promote corporate transparency, operational improvement, and stakeholder confidence.

Conclusion

Conducting a comprehensive internal audit in preparation for revenue-related external audits requires meticulous planning, precise execution, and strategic communication. Analytical procedures, risk analysis, internal control assessments, sampling techniques, and clear memos to management form the pillars of an effective audit process. By systematically addressing high-risk transactions and potential compliance issues, organizations can significantly reduce the likelihood of audit findings and enhance financial integrity. This proactive approach not only satisfies regulatory requirements but also fosters a culture of continuous improvement and accountability within the organization.

References

1. Arens, A. A., Elder, R. J., & Beasley, M. S. (2017). Auditing and Assurance Services (16th ed.). Pearson.
2. Cohen, J., Pant, L., & Boritz, J. (2017). Auditing: A Risk-Based Approach (10th ed.). Routledge.
3. IFAC. (2020). International Standards on Auditing (ISA) 315: Identifying and Assessing Risks of Material Misstatement. International Federation of Accountants.
4. Government Accountability Office (GAO). (2018). Generally Accepted Government Auditing Standards (GAGAS).
5. Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB). (2021). Revenue Recognition (ASC 606). Financial Accounting Standards Board.
6. International Accounting Standards Board (IASB). (2018). IFRS 15 Revenue from Contracts with Customers.
7. Mock, T. J. (2019). Internal Control and Risk Assessment in Auditing. Journal of Accountancy, 228(4), 34–39.
8. Whittington, R., & Pany, K. (2019). Principles of Auditing & Other Assurance Services (21st ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.
9. Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB). (2021). Auditing Standards.
10. Stice, J. D., Stice, E. K., & Stice, J. P. (2021). Auditor's Guide: Understanding GAAS and the International Standards. Cengage Learning.