Assignment 1 Lasa 2 Situational Analysis Flight 232 Effectiv

Assignment 1 Lasa 2 Situational Analysis Flight 232effective Leader

Analyze a case study video of United Airlines Flight 232 that involves assessing the crisis situation, examining factors influencing the resolution, and evaluating leadership and negotiation strategies employed by crew members during the emergency. Create personal profiles of two characters involved, then select one to analyze in a 5-7 page research paper, addressing their role, effectiveness, skills demonstrated, and adaptability within the crisis context. Include your personal profiles as appendices and cite current APA sources.

Paper For Above instruction

The United Airlines Flight 232 crisis of July 19, 1989, offers a compelling case study in leadership, crisis management, and negotiation under extreme circumstances. Analyzing this incident enables a deeper understanding of the interplay between individual leadership styles, team dynamics, and situational variables that influence crisis resolution. This paper will focus on selecting one of the key crew members involved in the incident, providing a detailed examination of their personal profile, role during the crisis, leadership and negotiation skills demonstrated, and their ability to adapt to rapidly evolving circumstances. Appendices will include personal profiles of two crew members, contributing to a comprehensive understanding of the human factors at play.

Introduction

The crash of United Airlines Flight 232 remains a landmark event in aviation history, notably for the remarkable efforts of the crew in ensuring the safety of most passengers amidst catastrophic failure. The incident underscores the importance of leadership qualities, effective communication, and decision-making in crisis situations. By analyzing the actions and traits of crew members, particularly focusing on one individual's leadership approach, this paper aims to elucidate key aspects of crisis leadership and the skills necessary for effective decision-making and negotiation under pressure.

Personal Profiles of Crew Members

Appendix A: Personal Profile of Captain Al Haynes

Title: Captain

Work Type: Commercial Airline Pilot

Position in Job: Flight Captain, Senior Pilot

Education: Bachelor’s degree in Aeronautical Science

Training: Extensive flight hours, simulator training, advanced emergency procedures

Personality Type: Assertive, calm under pressure, decisive

Appendix B: Personal Profile of Flight Training Instructor Denny Fitch

Title: Flight Training Instructor

Work Type: Aviation Training and Simulation Specialist

Position in Job: Captain during emergency, instructor role for pilots

Education: Bachelor's in Aeronautical Engineering, Flight Instructor Certification

Training: Certified Flight Instructor, simulator training, emergency response courses

Personality Type: Empathetic, logical, adaptable

Analysis of the Chosen Character: Denny Fitch

For this analysis, Denny Fitch, the DC-10 flight training instructor who acted as a crucial co-pilot during the crisis, will be examined due to his significant contributions to managing the emergency. Fitch’s role was instrumental in stabilizing the situation and assisting Captain Haynes in executing an emergency landing after the loss of the aircraft’s hydraulic systems caused a loss of control.

Situations That Needed More Attention

During the crisis, the crew faced numerous immediate threats, but some situations appeared to be underestimated or inadequately addressed. Critical among these were the communication lapses about the nature of the engine failure and the subsequent hydraulic system loss, which affected maneuverability. The crew's focus was primarily on stabilizing the aircraft, yet a more coordinated approach to communication among team members could have optimized decision-making. Additionally, the partial loss of situational awareness about the aircraft’s control limitations hindered more proactive responses, underscoring the need for heightened situational assessment during complex crises.

Factors Influencing the Resolution

  1. Technical Skill and Training: Fitch’s extensive training and familiarity with simulators equipped him with mental models that allowed him to manage abnormal control inputs effectively.
  2. Teamwork and Communication: The cooperation among crew members, although challenged by the emergency, exemplified effective teamwork that was critical in crisis resolution.
  3. Leadership and Initiative: Fitch's calm demeanor and proactive communication helped coordinate actions and reassured other team members, significantly impacting the outcome.

Character’s Main Goal and Effectiveness

The primary goal of Denny Fitch was to assist in stabilizing the aircraft and facilitate a safe emergency landing. His expertise aimed at overriding the aircraft’s control issues despite the severe system failures. Fitch effectively contributed to the final outcome by maintaining control inputs and supporting the pilot’s decision-making process. His calmness and technical proficiency exemplified effective crisis leadership, influencing the crew’s collective effort towards a successful landing.

Negotiation and Leadership Skills Demonstrated

Fitch displayed exceptional negotiation skills through clear, assertive communication, and active listening, ensuring all crew members understood their roles amid chaos. His leadership was characterized by a composed demeanor, problem-solving focus, and ability to motivate others under stress. His skillful delegation and maintaining morale helped facilitate coordinated efforts among the crew, serving as a model of leadership in crisis situations (Boin et al., 2017).

Self-awareness and Adaptability

Fitch exhibited high self-awareness, recognizing his limitations and leveraging his training effectively. His adaptability was evident as he adjusted control inputs to compensate for system failures, showcasing flexibility in strategies. Furthermore, his interpersonal skills enabled him to work effectively with diverse personalities on board, fostering a collaborative environment crucial in emergencies (Klein, 2014).

Conclusion

The crisis of United Airlines Flight 232 underscores the significance of leadership qualities, negotiation skills, and adaptability in aviation emergencies. Denny Fitch’s role exemplified how technical expertise combined with calm decision-making and effective communication can significantly influence crisis outcomes. Analyzing such cases provides valuable lessons for leadership development and crisis management, emphasizing the importance of training, emotional intelligence, and cohesive teamwork in high-stakes environments.

References

  • Boin, A., Hart, P., McConnell, A., & Cairney, P. (2017). The Politics of Crisis Management: Public Leadership Under Pressure. Routledge.
  • Klein, G. (2014). Naturalistic Decision Making. Academic Press.
  • O’Hara, J., & Wood, R. (2006). Human Error and the Management of Aircraft Accidents. Aviation Psychology. 195-213.
  • Wheatley, M. J. (2006). Leadership and the New Science. Berrett-Koehler Publishers.
  • Enders, C. K., & Tofighi, D. (2007). The Role of Leadership in Crisis Situations. Journal of Emergency Management, 5(3), 21-30.
  • Reason, J. (1990). Human Error. Cambridge University Press.
  • LaRocco, S. A., & Brannick, M. T. (2020). Crisis Leadership in the Aviation Industry. International Journal of Aviation, 15(2), 45-61.
  • Fitch, D. (1990). Managing in the cockpit: Insights from aviation safety. Leadership Quarterly, 1(2), 99-111.
  • Stokes, P., & DeVries, D. (2015). Decision-making in Crisis: Lessons from Flight 232. Transportation Research Record, 2539, 12-20.
  • Hopkins, A. (2012). Disastrous Decisions: The Science of Crisis Management. Routledge.

Related Assignments