Assignments 1: Build Or Buy? Due Week 4 And Worth

Assignmnetsassignment 1 To Build Or Buydue Week 4 And Worth 240 Point

Assignmnetsassignment 1 To Build Or Buydue Week 4 And Worth 240 Point

SELECT A SMALL BUSINESS YOU FREQUENT AND CREATE A STRATEGY:

Choose a small business you visit often, such as a coffee shop, bookstore, or sporting goods store. Write a 6-8 page paper that includes:

  • A brief (1-2 pages) strategy for a new business that directly competes with this small business. Explain the rationale behind this strategy in detail.
  • Determine whether it makes more sense to open this new business or to purchase the existing small business. Provide your reasoning.
  • Discuss the most appropriate ownership structure for your new business, considering your current financial situation.
  • Create a business plan for your new business, utilizing available tools and templates.
  • Include at least two credible references outside the textbook, formatted according to APA or your school’s guidelines.

Paper For Above instruction

Starting a new business to compete with an existing local small business involves strategic planning, financial analysis, and understanding market dynamics. This paper explores the development of a competitive strategy, evaluates the decision to build or buy, discusses ownership options, and outlines a comprehensive business plan grounded in sound principles and industry insights.

Developing a Competitive Business Strategy

The chosen small business is a local coffee shop that has established a loyal customer base through quality products and community engagement. To compete effectively, a new coffee brand could adopt a differentiation strategy focusing on unique offerings such as organic, fair-trade coffee, innovative brewing methods, and a compelling brand experience that emphasizes sustainability and social responsibility (Porter, 1980). This strategy aims to attract environmentally conscious consumers who seek premium products coupled with ethical business practices, thereby carving out a niche that differentiates from the incumbent.

The rationale stems from the increasing consumer demand for sustainable and ethically sourced products, as well as a desire for a distinctive ambiance and specialty beverages unavailable at the existing coffee shop (Kotler & Keller, 2016). By emphasizing high-quality, ethically sourced coffee with a modern, environmentally friendly brand image, the new business can position itself as a premium provider in the local market.

Build or Buy: Strategic Considerations

Deciding whether to build a new business or buy an existing one requires assessing factors such as startup costs, market entry risk, brand loyalty, and operational complexity. Establishing a new business (building) allows for designing the brand and operations from scratch, aligning tightly with strategic goals. However, it involves higher risk, longer time to profitability, and significant capital expenditure.

Conversely, purchasing an existing business (buying) offers immediate cash flow, existing customer base, operational infrastructure, and brand recognition. Yet, it may come with legacy issues such as existing liabilities, outdated equipment, or brand perception problems. Given the high level of customer loyalty and established location, buying an established coffee shop could be advantageous if the business is undervalued or has growth potential (Mazzarol & Soutar, 2002). Alternatively, building a new business offers the advantage of crafting an entirely fresh brand aligned with contemporary sustainability trends, though it would require a longer ramp-up period.

In conclusion, the decision hinges on financial capacity, risk appetite, and strategic alignment. If the existing business shows signs of stability and growth potential, acquisition could be prudent; otherwise, building a new, differentiated business might offer more control and innovation opportunities.

Ownership Structure Specification

Assuming a moderate initial investment and limited personal risk appetite, a Limited Liability Company (LLC) appears appropriate. An LLC provides flexibility in management, tax advantages, and limits personal liability, which is crucial for a new entrant with limited capital (U.S. Small Business Administration, 2022). This structure facilitates potential future growth, allows for investment by partners or investors, and aligns well with the entrepreneurial nature of the venture.

Business Plan Outline

The business plan for the new coffee venture encompasses several core sections:

  • Executive Summary: A high-level overview of the business concept, differentiators, and financial goals.
  • Market Analysis: Insights into local demographics, coffee consumption trends, and competitor positioning.
  • Organization & Management: LLC ownership structure, key management roles, and staffing plans.
  • Products & Services: Unique coffee blends, sustainability practices, and customer experience initiatives.
  • Marketing & Sales: Branding, promotional strategies, loyalty programs, and community engagement.
  • Financial Projections: Startup costs, revenue forecasts, profitability timeline, and break-even analysis.
  • Funding Request: If seeking investors or loans, specify funding needs and repayment plans.

Utilizing tools like the SCORE Business Plan Template (score.org), entrepreneurs can systematically develop comprehensive plans that address each aspect effectively.

Conclusion

In restoring the competitive landscape, the business must emphasize sustainable and ethical differentiation, leveraging market demand for quality and responsibility. Whether building or acquiring, strategic decision-making centered on financial viability, market opportunities, and operational control is critical. A well-crafted business plan then translates these plans into actionable steps to ensure a successful launch and sustainable growth.

References

  • Kotler, P., & Keller, K. L. (2016). Marketing management (15th ed.). Pearson Education.
  • Mazzarol, T., & Soutar, G. N. (2002). "‘It's an Ill Wind’—The influence of external environment factors on small business exit: A pilot study," Small Enterprise Research, 10(2), 46-62.
  • Porter, M. E. (1980). Competitive strategy: Techniques for analyzing industries and competitors. Free Press.
  • U.S. Small Business Administration. (2022). Choose your business structure. https://www.sba.gov
  • Porter, M. E. (2008). The five competitive forces that shape strategy. Harvard Business Review, 86(1), 78–93.
  • Clark, R., & Montanus, J. (2018). Strategic management and competitive advantage. Wiley.
  • Barney, J. B. (1991). Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage. Journal of Management, 17(1), 99–120.
  • Harvard Business Review. (2020). How to create a winning strategy. https://hbr.org
  • Business Model Canvas. (n.d.). Strategyzer. https://strategyzer.com
  • Trout, J., & Rivkin, S. (2020). Positioning: The battle for your mind. McGraw-Hill Education.

Related Assignments