Auditors Document Their Control Risk Assessments With Narrat

Auditors Document Their Control Risk Assessments With Narratives

Auditors document their control risk assessments using various methods such as narratives, flowcharts, and checklists. These tools serve to clearly describe and evaluate an organization’s internal controls related to financial reporting and compliance. Narratives provide descriptive explanations of processes, flowcharts visually depict the sequence of activities and decision points, and checklists list specific control activities to verify their presence and effectiveness.

For example, a narrative might explain how the payroll process works, detailing who approves timesheets, how data is entered, and how payroll is processed. A flowchart could illustrate the steps from employee timesheet submission to salary payment, identifying approval nodes and points where controls are tested. A checklist might include verifying whether the payroll system restricts unauthorized access and whether payroll is reviewed and approved by supervisors.

An audit program is a detailed plan that outlines the nature, timing, and extent of audit procedures to be performed. It serves as a roadmap for auditors to gather sufficient and appropriate evidence. Before the audit, the program helps in planning resource allocation and designing audit procedures. During the audit, it acts as a guide to ensure that all necessary areas are examined systematically. Afterward, it provides documentation of the procedures performed and serves as a basis for auditors’ conclusions and reporting.

Paper For Above instruction

Auditors employ various documentation tools to assess and communicate control risks within an organization, among which narratives, flowcharts, and checklists are prominently used. These tools are essential in understanding, evaluating, and testing internal controls that mitigate risks related to financial reporting, compliance, and operational efficiency. Proper documentation not only facilitates the audit process but also provides a record that supports the auditors’ conclusions and helps the organization identify areas for improvement.

Narratives in Auditing

Narratives are descriptive descriptions that explain the flow of transactions and control procedures within a process. They offer a detailed step-by-step account of how a process operates, identifying key control points and potential risks. For example, a narrative describing the revenue recognition process might explain how sales are approved, recorded, and reviewed for accuracy. Narratives are particularly useful in complex processes, providing auditors with a clear understanding of the controls in place and areas that may need further testing or inquiry.

Effective narratives include details about who performs each step, the documents involved, and how controls are enforced. They serve as a basis for risk assessment and for designing audit procedures tailored to the organization's specific control environment. Narratives can be prepared through interviews, walkthroughs, and review of process documentation, providing a comprehensive picture of internal control effectiveness.

Flowcharts in Auditing

Flowcharts visually represent the sequence of activities within a process, including decision points, subprocesses, and document flows. They help auditors quickly grasp the process structure and identify control points and potential failure points. A typical flowchart might show steps such as initiating a purchase request, vendor approval, purchase order issuance, receipt of goods, and payment processing, with arrows indicating the flow of operations.

Flowcharts are useful in identifying segregation of duties, redundant steps, or gaps in the control process. They serve as visual aids during walkthroughs, allowing both auditors and client personnel to understand the process more readily. In conjunction with narratives, flowcharts provide a comprehensive understanding that facilitates risk assessment and testing procedures.

Checklists in Auditing

Checklists are structured lists used to verify whether specific control activities are in place and functioning effectively. They include assertions such as whether authorized personnel approve transactions, whether records are maintained accurately, and whether reconciliations are performed regularly. Checklists ensure consistency in testing and reduce the risk of overlooking controls during an audit.

For instance, an audit checklist for payroll controls might include verifying whether access to payroll systems is restricted, whether changes to compensation are authorized, and if payroll reconciliations are performed. Checklists provide tangible evidence of control testing and support overall audit documentation requirements.

The Audit Program: Purpose and Lifecycle

An audit program is a detailed blueprint setting out specific audit procedures to be performed to gather evidence supporting audit objectives. It is integral to the planning, execution, and completion of an audit engagement. Before the audit work begins, the program helps define the scope and complexity of procedures necessary based on risk assessments. During the audit, it guides the auditors to systematically perform planned procedures, ensuring all relevant areas are covered comprehensively. After completion, the audit program serves as documentation of performed procedures and findings, facilitating review and quality control.

Moreover, an audit program ensures consistency and consistency in audit quality across different engagements. It also provides a benchmark for evaluating whether sufficient audit evidence has been collected to form an opinion. In practice, the program includes procedures such as substantive testing, control testing, analytical procedures, and walk-throughs tailored to the specifics of the organization and audit scope.

Case Study: REA Diagram for James Corporation

James Corporation’s expenditure cycle involves approving vendors, ordering supplies, receiving inventory, and recording transactions. Based on the description, the REA (Resources, Events, Agents) model would include the following entities:

• Vendors — attributes: vendor ID, name, classification (wholesaler or manufacturer), approval status.
• Employees — attributes: employee ID, name, role (purchase agent, clerk).
• Purchase Orders — attributes: order ID, date, vendor ID, amount.
• Inventory Items — attributes: item number, description, quantity, unit cost.
• Receiving Reports — attributes: report ID, date, quantity received.

The relationships include:

• Employees (purchase agents) create Purchase Orders to Vendors.
• Vendors supply Inventory Items, which are received via Receiving Reports.
• Inventory Items are tracked by their unique Item Numbers.

The cardinalities would indicate that:

• An employee (purchase agent) can create many purchase orders, but each purchase order is created by one employee.
• A vendor can supply many inventory items; each inventory item has one or more associated vendors depending on the context.
• Each receiving report relates to a specific purchase order and inventory items received.

This diagram captures the essential entities and relationships within James Corporation's expenditure cycle, emphasizing approval processes, inventory tracking, and the roles of employees and vendors.

Conclusion

In modern auditing, the use of narratives, flowcharts, and checklists enhances the understanding, documentation, and testing of internal controls. These tools support auditors in identifying control weaknesses and evaluating risk. Complemented by comprehensive audit programs, they form a strategic framework that guides auditors throughout all phases of the engagement, ensuring thoroughness, consistency, and evidence-based conclusions.

References

• Alleyne, P., & Ho, S. S. (2016). Auditing: An International Approach. Cengage Learning.
• Arens, A. A., Elder, R. J., & Beasley, M. S. (2018). Auditing and Assurance Services: An Integrated Approach. Pearson.
• Hayes, R., Wallage, P., & Gwilliam, D. (2014). Principles of Auditing & Other Assurance Services. McGraw-Hill Education.
• Louwers, T. J., Ramsay, R. J., Sinason, D. H., & Strawser, J. R. (2019). Auditing & Assurance Services. McGraw-Hill Education.
• Arnold, V., & Reed, S. A. (2018). Auditing: A Risk-Based Approach. Routledge.
• Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB). (2012). Auditing Standard No. 5, An Audit of Internal Control Over Financial Reporting.
• Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA). (2015). International Standards for the Professional Practice of Internal Auditing.
• Rittenberg, L. E., Gramling, A. A., & Rust, R. (2020). Auditing: A Risk-Based Approach. Cengage Learning.
• American Institute of CPAs (AICPA). (2020). Generally Accepted Auditing Standards (GAAS).
• Bierstaker, J., Brody, R. G., & Pacini, C. (2001). Accountants' Use of Internet Audit Tools: Evidence from a Going Concern Assessment. Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory, 20(1), 147-160.