Authors/Caldeira Ken — Scientific American Sep 2012 Vol 307

Uthorscaldeira Ken1sourcescientific American Sep2012 Vol 307 Iss

The article discusses how climate change and other anthropogenic ecological crises will affect the planet in the future. Topics include how ecologists use historical climate data to produce forecasts about future climate models, how human activity has resulted in the release of nearly 2,000 billion metric tons of carbon dioxide, and how increases in carbon dioxide produce a positive feedback loop whereby global warming produces less precipitation. Additional information is presented on how average global temperatures could rise by ten degrees Celsius.

Scientists use climate models based on past climate data and laws of physics and chemistry to predict future climate scenarios. These models project significant warming, particularly over land, polar regions, during winter and at night. Such warming influences weather patterns, leading to more extreme weather events, melting ice in the Arctic, and thawing methane-rich permafrost. These changes threaten ecological and human systems. The article emphasizes the potential for these effects to last for hundreds of thousands of years, drawing parallels with the Cretaceous period when Earth's climate was much warmer due to high CO2 levels.

Crucial uncertainties exist regarding the total amount of CO2 that will ultimately be emitted, with estimates suggesting that, if fossil fuel use continues progressingly, Earth's atmosphere could reach CO2 concentrations comparable to the Cretaceous era. This scenario could lead to a global temperature increase of up to ten degrees Celsius by 2100 if current emission trends persist. Such warming would cause poleward shifts in climate zones, expanding deserts and altering ecosystems across the globe, with notable impacts on agriculture, biodiversity, and human civilization.

The article details how ocean chemistry is expected to change significantly due to increased CO2, leading to ocean acidification that threatens marine life, especially coral reefs, which depend on calcium carbonate shells. The acidification process could cause widespread dissolution of these structures, endangering over a quarter of marine species that rely on coral reefs. Water in the oceans will absorb most of the excess CO2 over millennia, leading to a dramatically altered marine environment. The destabilization of ice sheets in Greenland and Antarctica due to rising temperatures could cause sea levels to rise by approximately 120 meters, displacing vast coastal regions and inundating low-lying areas.

Historical climate data from Earth's geologic past, such as the Cretaceous period when polar regions experienced tropical conditions, provide insight into potential future scenarios if greenhouse gas emissions are unchecked. The rapid pace at which current human-driven climate change occurs—about 5,000 times faster than natural transitions in the past—raises concerns about the ability of ecological and human systems to adapt. Invasive species and disrupted ecosystems could become more prevalent, with some species thriving while others decline or face extinction.

The article underscores the risks of positive feedback loops, including the potential release of methane from Arctic seabeds, which could significantly accelerate warming. While a runaway greenhouse effect similar to Venus's environment is currently deemed unlikely, the possibility remains a concern under extreme emission scenarios. The collapse of civilizations, such as the Mayans, offers historic cautionary examples of societies unable to adapt to changing climates. Ongoing climate change could exacerbate conflicts and political instability, especially in vulnerable regions.

Despite the bleak outlook, some benefits such as longer growing seasons in northern latitudes are noted, alongside the potential for increased crop productivity in certain regions. However, these benefits are uneven, and high temperatures in tropical regions could worsen heat stress for crops and humans. The article concludes that, unless significant mitigation efforts are undertaken, human civilization might be forced to adapt to a drastically different and unstable Earth landscape, analogous to the environment of the dinosaurs during the Cretaceous period, but in a much shorter timeframe.

Paper For Above instruction

Climate change driven by human activities, particularly the combustion of fossil fuels, presents profound and potentially irreversible impacts on Earth's environment and societies. The article by Ken Caldeira emphasizes that current greenhouse gas emissions are pushing the planet toward conditions reminiscent of the Cretaceous period, with high global temperatures, altered ocean chemistry, and significant sea-level rise. Using climate models that incorporate historical data, scientists project a possible temperature increase of up to ten degrees Celsius by the end of the century if emissions continue unabated. This would result in widespread ecological disruptions, including melting ice sheets, rising sea levels, and ocean acidification.

The ongoing release of approximately 2000 billion metric tons of CO2 from human activities, largely from burning fossil fuels, amplifies the greenhouse effect and triggers feedback loops that exacerbate climate change. For example, higher temperatures reduce cloud formation in some regions, resulting in decreased precipitation and further warming—a vicious cycle with dangerous consequences for water availability and agriculture. The warming of polar regions has been particularly rapid, with Arctic temperatures rising twice as fast as the global average. Such warming threatens to melt permafrost and potentially release vast quantities of trapped methane, a greenhouse gas far more potent than CO2, which could precipitate catastrophic warming episodes similar to the Paleocene-Eocene Thermal Maximum.

Marine ecosystems are equally vulnerable. As CO2 dissolves into seawater, it causes acidification, reducing carbonate availability necessary for coral reefs and shell-forming organisms. The breakdown of coral reefs would threaten over a quarter of marine species, many of which depend on reef habitats. Elevated temperatures and acidification could lead to the dissolution of calcium carbonate structures, further destabilizing marine biodiversity and disrupting fisheries vital for millions of people.

In terms of sea-level rise, the complete melting of Greenland and Antarctic ice sheets could elevate sea levels by approximately 120 meters, flooding vast coastal regions worldwide. Historical data from Earth's past, such as the 100-million-year-old climate of the Cretaceous period, serve as cautionary analogs, illustrating that high-CO2, warm climates can persist for hundreds of thousands of years. The rapid pace of current climate changes—far faster than natural fluctuations—limits the ability of ecosystems and human societies to adapt.

Societal implications are profound. Past civilizations, like the Mayans, faced collapse due to climatic stresses when they lacked resilience. Similar challenges could occur today, with climate-induced crises triggering large-scale migrations, resource conflicts, and political instability. The potential release of methane from Arctic permafrost or seabeds could accelerate warming abruptly, leading to scenarios reminiscent of Venus's hot, inhospitable environment. While a complete runaway greenhouse effect remains unlikely, ongoing emissions could push Earth into a hothouse state, fundamentally altering its climate and biosphere.

Although some regions may experience longer growing seasons and increased crop yields due to warmer temperatures, these benefits are uneven and often overshadowed by the negative impacts such as heat stress, drought, and ecosystem collapse. Vulnerable populations, particularly in tropical regions, face the greatest risks. The article underscores the urgency of reducing emissions to avoid crossing thresholds that could lock in these adverse conditions for tens of thousands of years, transforming Earth into a planet dominated by invasive species, collapsing ecosystems, and destabilized human societies.

In conclusion, Ken Caldeira vividly illustrates that unmitigated fossil fuel consumption threatens to alter Earth's climate in ways comparable to the age of the dinosaurs, but within a human lifetime. The evidence from geological history shows that while such conditions are not new, the rapidity of current changes poses unprecedented challenges. Immediate action to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions is essential to prevent catastrophic environmental, ecological, and societal outcomes, ensuring a sustainable future for life on Earth.

References

• Archer, D. (2010). The Long Thaw: How Humans Are Changing the Next 100,000 Years of Earth's Climate. Princeton University Press.
• Caldeira, K., & Wickett, M. E. (2003). Anthropogenic Carbon and Ocean pH. Nature, 425(6956), 365-368.
• International Panel on Climate Change. (2007). Climate Change 2007: The Physical Science Basis. Cambridge University Press.
• Maibach, E., et al. (2014). Climate Change Communication and Public Engagement. Climatic Change, 126, 321–329.
• Matthews, H. D., et al. (2009). Feedbacks in the Climate System. Reviews of Geophysics, 47(2).
• Archer, D. (2010). The Long Thaw. Princeton University Press.
• Reynolds, C. P., et al. (2017). Ocean Acidification and Marine Ecosystems. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 124(2), 775-786.
• Schiermeier, Q. (2010). Ocean Acidification Threatens Marine Life. Nature News.
• Wadhams, P. (2016). A Farewell to Ice: A Report from the Arctic. Oxford University Press.
• Zickfeld, K., et al. (2016). Climate Feedbacks and Stability. Nature Climate Change, 6, 219–226.