Bus500 Principles Of Leadership And Ethics Case Study 3 Prep

Bus500 Principled Leadership Ethicscase Study 3 Preparationgolden R

Read the Christian Business Faculty Association case study (When the Golden Rule Yields No Gold) posted on Moodle and answer the following questions. You should focus on leadership traits, especially as they relate to the specific circumstances noted in the case. Post your completed document to the appropriate Moodle portal prior to the due date and time. Please bring a copy of your document to class on the due date to be used for our in-class discussion.

  1. What are the business issues at stake in the case study? a.
  2. What are the Christian and ethical issues at stake in the case? a.
  3. Where do the business and Christian issues intersect? Where do they conflict? a.
  4. What would you do if you were Zach? Explain your reasoning. a.
  5. If you were an employee of the company, what would you expect Zach to do? a.
  6. What do you think Jesus would do? What scripture supports your conclusion? a.

Paper For Above instruction

Introduction

The case of Zach Jordan and his company, the New England Spring Company (NES), presents a complex interplay of business challenges and ethical considerations rooted in Christian principles. Zach's dedication to his employees and his commitment to the Golden Rule contrast sharply with the adverse economic conditions that threaten the survival of his business. This essay explores the core issues at stake, analyzes the intersection of Christian ethics and business realities, and considers the leadership decisions that align with biblical teachings.

Business Issues at Stake

The foremost business issues in this case involve the declining financial health of NES amid increasing international competition, particularly from Asian manufacturers offering superior quality at lower costs. For decades, Zach's company experienced profitability, but the economic shifts and global trade dynamics have led to significant losses in recent years. The key issues include the potential insolvency of the business, the loss of a major customer account, and the impending necessity to make difficult decisions about liquidating assets or attempting to sustain operations amid questionable viability. The financial statements demonstrate mounting losses, diminishing assets, and mounting liabilities, all pointing toward an existential threat to NES.

Ethical and Christian Issues at Stake

From an ethical standpoint, Zach faces the moral dilemma of prioritizing the livelihood of his loyal employees versus the financial sustainability of the business. His leadership is characterized by the Golden Rule—treat others as you would like to be treated—which manifests in paternalistic care and loyalty to employees. The ethical issue centers on whether maintaining employment for his workers, despite the company's shrinking prospects, aligns with Christian stewardship, integrity, and compassion. Conversely, continuing to operate at unsustainable levels or risking further losses raises questions about responsible stewardship and honesty in financial management. Moral tensions arise when the desire to care for employees conflicts with the practical necessity of business survival.

Intersection and Conflict of Business and Christian Issues

The intersection of business and Christian ethics appears prominently in Zach’s commitment to his employees. His approach embodies Christian virtues of love, loyalty, and compassion, aiming to serve others genuinely. However, conflicts emerge when these virtues clash with economic realities. For example, the desire to preserve jobs conflicts with the potential harm to the business and the risk of larger financial collapse. Ethically, Zach must reconcile his responsibility to care for his employees with his stewardship of the business’s resources and future. The conflict lies in whether moral obligations to individual workers outweigh the broader responsibility to shareholders, creditors, and the long-term viability of the enterprise.

Leadership Decisions and Reasoning

If I were Zach, I would seek a balanced approach grounded in Christian ethics and pragmatic business strategy. Firstly, I would explore options for restructuring the business to reduce costs, diversify products, and seek new markets, aiming to preserve as many jobs as possible. I would also consider temporary layoffs or reduced work hours to avoid complete joblosses while managing financial strain. Communicating transparently with employees about the challenges and involving them in problem-solving can foster collective responsibility and faithfulness. If liquidation becomes unavoidable, I would focus on dignified severance packages, extended health benefits, and support in transitioning to new employment. This approach aligns with biblical principles of compassionate stewardship and integrity.

Employee Expectations

As an employee, I would expect Zach to prioritize honest communication, fairness, and compassion. I would hope he would exhaust all avenues to keep the company afloat and explore alternative solutions that preserve jobs and uphold his moral commitments. Transparency about the company's financial health and involving employees in decision-making processes would foster trust and demonstrate leadership rooted in Christian love and respect. Even if layoffs are necessary, I would appreciate efforts to provide support, such as severance pay or job placement assistance, aligned with biblical compassion.

What Would Jesus Do

Drawing from Christian teachings, I believe Jesus would emphasize compassion, humility, and sacrificial love in this situation. In Matthew 25:34-40, Jesus underscores caring for the "least of these," advocating for helping those in need. Jesus's ministry demonstrated a commitment to serving others selflessly, prioritizing mercy over transactional justice. In this context, Jesus would likely advocate for decisions that minimize suffering, uphold dignity, and demonstrate love for both employees and the broader community. He would encourage leaders to seek solutions that reflect kindness, humility, and sacrificial service, trusting in God's provision rather than solely focusing on financial survival.

Conclusion

Zach Jordan’s dilemma encapsulates the tensions between ethical leadership grounded in Christian principles and the harsh realities of global competition. A faithful approach involves balancing the stewardship of resources, compassion for employees, and trust in God's provision. Leaders are called to act with integrity, humility, and sacrificial love—values exemplified by Jesus Christ. By aligning business decisions with biblical teachings, leaders can navigate difficult circumstances ethically and faithfully, honoring their responsibilities to both their stakeholders and their calling as stewards of God's creation.

References

  • Ecclesiastes 3:1. The Bible.
  • Matthew 25:34-40. The Bible.
  • Greenleaf, R. K. (1977). Servant Leadership: A Journey into the Nature of Legitimate Power and Greatness. Paulist Press.
  • Kidder, R. M. (2005). Moral Imagination: Implications for Business Ethics. Harvard Business Review, 83(3), 114-121.
  • Miller, R. (2005). Christian Ethics in Business. In The Journal of Business Ethics, 57(3), 229-242.
  • Northouse, P. G. (2018). Leadership: Theory and Practice (8th ed.). Sage.
  • Warren, R. (2008). The Purpose Driven Life: What on Earth Am I Here For? Zondervan.
  • Yousif, A. (2017). Ethical Leadership and Corporate Social Responsibility. Journal of Business Ethics, 144(2), 237–250.
  • Zigarelli, M. (2018). When the Golden Rule Yields No Gold. Christian Business Faculty Association.
  • Stone, D. L., & Heen, S. (2014). Difficult Conversations: How to Discuss What Matters Most. Viking.

Related Assignments