Case 42: Bigelow Stores - A General Merchandising Store

Case 42 Bigelow Stores Bigelow Stores Is A General Merchandise Retail

Bigelow Stores, a prominent general merchandise retailer based in Atlanta, GA, operates 250 stores and three distribution centers (DCs) across the southeastern United States. The company has established a significant presence in the off-price retail market by offering everyday items alongside special buys advertised at discounted prices. Its product range also includes food items with expiration dates that do not require refrigeration. Thanks to high store density and large store formats, Bigelow can efficiently ship full truckloads (TL) from its DCs to stores daily, optimizing transportation efficiency.

However, Bigelow currently lacks an online sales platform. Recognizing growth opportunities, the company aims to expand into the northeast and midwest regions through acquisitions. It has acquired Lions, a medium-sized retailer in Pennsylvania with 100 stores and two DCs, which employs both direct TL shipments and pool distribution to serve its stores. Lions also runs an online grocery ordering and same-day pickup service. Additionally, Bigelow acquired Spartan Stores in Michigan, an omni-channel outdoor sports retailer with 50 stores and one DC that ships both online and in-store orders using less-than-truckload (LTL) carriers and small package carriers.

Bigelow's strategic vision involves regional and eventually national expansion of these acquired companies under its brand, coupled with substantial investment in an internet presence to develop a seamless omni-channel experience. The management faces choices in implementing an integrated, branded approach across diverse product lines, geographies, and customer touchpoints. Critical considerations include designing effective customer fulfillment networks for varied channels, regions, and product types, as well as aligning infrastructure to support a unified online platform that offers comprehensive product assortments.

Paper For Above instruction

Bigelow Stores' transition toward an omni-channel retail model requires strategic planning to unify its diverse operations under a cohesive brand. This involves considering the unique characteristics of each acquired company—Lions and Spartan Stores—and their existing distribution channels, customer engagement methods, and market segmentation. An integrated approach should prioritize aligning physical and digital operations while maintaining service quality and operational efficiency.

Developing a Unified Omni-Channel Strategy

The first step in implementing Bigelow’s one-brand, omni-channel strategy involves establishing a comprehensive integration framework that respects the distinct attributes of each acquired firm. This includes harmonizing branding, product offerings, and customer service protocols to deliver a seamless shopping experience across physical stores and online platforms. A unified branding approach fosters customer loyalty, enhances brand recognition, and enables cross-channel promotions.

To facilitate this, Bigelow should invest in an enterprise resource planning (ERP) and supply chain management (SCM) systems capable of consolidating data from multiple sources. Advanced analytics and customer relationship management (CRM) tools will offer insights into consumer behavior, preferences, and purchasing patterns, guiding personalized marketing and inventory management. These technological investments will be vital in synchronizing inventory availability across channels, managing order fulfillment, and delivering consistent customer experiences.

Designing Customer Fulfillment Networks

Given the geographic spread and varied product lines, Bigelow must develop tailored fulfillment networks for each channel and region. For the brick-and-mortar stores, maintaining a network of strategically located DCs—similar to its existing model—will continue to be effective, especially for non-perishable and bulky merchandise. Full truckload (TL) shipments to stores will remain pertinent in dense markets, providing cost efficiencies and high service levels.

For online orders, especially those involving perishables like food items or specialty sports products, smaller, more flexible fulfillment options are necessary. Spartan Stores’ omni-channel model, utilizing a single DC to serve both store and internet orders, offers a scalable blueprint. This approach minimizes inventory duplication and optimizes delivery throughput. Additionally, implementing regional micro-fulfillment centers (MFCs) near key markets could expedite delivery times and reduce transportation costs, critical in fulfilling same-day or next-day delivery promises to online customers.

Pool distribution strategies, akin to Lions' model, can be expanded for less dense markets or for online order consolidation, reducing logistics costs. Cross-docking practices could further accelerate order processing by transferring products directly from inbound trucks to outbound shipments without prolonged storage.

Offering All Products Across a Single Web Platform: Challenges and Opportunities

Creating a centralized online marketplace that offers the full spectrum of products from all acquired companies presents both rich opportunities and notable challenges. The primary opportunity lies in capturing a broader customer base by providing a one-stop shopping experience, increasing cross-selling potential, and leveraging data insights for targeted marketing. An integrated e-commerce platform can also lower marginal costs per sale through economies of scale and streamline inventory management.

However, several challenges must be acknowledged. Integrating diverse product categories—offering general merchandise, food items, and specialty sporting goods—requires adaptable inventory and logistics systems capable of handling different expiration dates, shelf lives, and handling requirements. Ensuring consistent product quality, availability, and delivery performance across categories is complex, especially when coordinating multiple suppliers and fulfillment centers.

The current DC network, primarily designed around full truckload shipments to large stores, may not readily support the rapid, small-package deliveries demanded by online consumers. Additional investments in warehouse automation, urban micro-fulfillment centers, or third-party logistics (3PL) providers might be necessary to enhance responsiveness and service levels. Also, maintaining real-time inventory accuracy across channels is crucial to prevent stockouts and oversells, requiring sophisticated inventory tracking systems.

Furthermore, there are strategic considerations regarding product assortment visibility and customer experience. A unified online platform must offer personalized navigation, detailed product descriptions, and flexible delivery options—such as buy-online, pick-up-in-store (BOPIS)—to meet modern consumer expectations. Regulatory compliance, especially for food and perishable items, adds another layer of complexity, mandating stringent quality controls and accurate expiration date management through the e-commerce system.

Operational Implications and Recommendations

To support this omni-channel strategy, Bigelow needs to reorganize and expand its distribution infrastructure. Investing in scalable warehouse management systems, integrating online order fulfillment capabilities into existing DC operations, and establishing regional micro-fulfillment centers will be vital. Building partnerships with last-mile delivery providers or expanding its logistics fleet can enhance delivery speed and reliability. Emphasizing transparent communications regarding order status and delivery times will improve customer satisfaction.

In addition, staff training and change management initiatives are necessary to align store and logistics personnel with new processes. Developing clear performance metrics for online fulfillment—such as delivery accuracy and cycle time—will help track progress and identify areas for improvement. Finally, a phased rollout approach, starting with pilot programs in select regions, can mitigate risks and allow iterative optimization based on customer feedback and operational performance.

Conclusion

Bigelow’s strategic move into omni-channel retailing demands a comprehensive plan that aligns technology, logistics, and marketing efforts across its diverse portfolio of acquisitions. By leveraging existing strengths—such as full truckload distribution for large stores—and expanding into micro-fulfillment strategies for online orders, Bigelow can deliver a seamless shopping experience. Addressing the challenges inherent in integrating varied product lines and regions is critical, requiring investments in advanced systems and infrastructure. With careful planning and execution, Bigelow can realize its vision of a unified, efficient, and customer-centric retail operation that captures increased market share both regionally and nationally.

References

• Aggarwal, K., & Singh, G. (2019). Omni-channel retailing: Challenges and opportunities. Journal of Business & Retail Management Research, 13(2), 1-11.
• Chopra, S. (2018). Supply Chain Management: Strategy, Planning, and Operation. Pearson Education.
• Frei, F. X. (2013). Breaking through the convenience trap. Harvard Business Review, 91(4), 107-114.
• Gupta, S., & Sinha, P. (2020). Retail Supply Chain Management in the Digital Era. Mahatma Gandhi University Journal of Management, 4(1), 23-40.
• Kumar, N., & Petersen, K. (2014). Customer-oriented supply chain strategies. Journal of Business Logistics, 35(2), 87-92.
• LaLonde, D., & Masters, W. (2018). Marketing channels, third edition. Cengage Learning.
• Marchet, G., et al. (2018). Micro-fulfillment centers and last-mile logistics. Supply Chain Forum: An International Journal, 19(3), 136-148.
• Rai, A., & Tang, X. (2014). Harnessing the Internet and supply chain management for strategic advantage. International Journal of Production Economics, 147, 33-44.
• Simchi-Levi, D., Kaminsky, P., & Simchi-Levi, E. (2014). Designing and Managing the Supply Chain: Concepts, Strategies, and Case Studies. McGraw-Hill Education.
• Zhang, M., & Lee, H. (2019). The impact of omni-channel retailing on supply chain management. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services, 50, 299-305.