Chapter 7: Ethical Issues In The Global Arena

Chapter 7 Ethical Issues In The Global Arenaintroductionthe Growth Of

The growth of global business as a critical element in the world economy is one of the most important developments of the past half century, but it has also been an increasingly fertile ground for corruption and ethical challenges. Epstein and Hanson refer to the global level as potentially being part of the “Bad Orchard” level. At this competitive, global level, ethical behavior becomes much more challenging, and misconduct is more likely. Domestic issues are compounded by the rapid international expansion of commerce, which has made the global landscape more complex for businesses operating across borders.

The internationalization of business presents unique challenges, with international markets seen as natural extensions of an expanding global marketplace referred to as the transnational economy. This economy involves trade in goods, moderate trade in services, international movement of labor, and flows of capital and information. Despite expectations of continued rapid growth in international business, recent trends suggest a slowdown since the global financial crisis of 2009, further accentuated by the COVID-19 pandemic since 2020. As French President Emmanuel Macron stated, COVID-19 will “change the nature of globalization,” prompting questions about the benefits of offshoring jobs or expanding supply chains amid rising costs and geopolitical risks.

Global economic growth has become sluggish amidst rising global instability driven by geopolitics, migration, tariffs, trade wars, terrorism, and corruption. Nonetheless, surveys indicate that many CEOs remain optimistic about a recovery starting in 2021. According to McKinsey & Company, resilience developed during disruptions such as the pandemic can serve as a foundation for future growth. Companies are reevaluating their global operations due to regional vulnerabilities, and the overall complexity of global business is increasing in response to transformative trends such as the rise of emerging markets, rapid technological innovation, aging populations, and greater interconnectedness of trade, capital, people, and data.

This evolving global environment accentuates the social and ethical challenges faced by businesses. When corporations operate across different cultures, they encounter varying customs, legal standards, and notions of ethical conduct. These differences can lead to conflicts and dilemmas, especially when local practices clash with the expectations of the company's home country. An illustrative example is how bribery, perceived differently across cultures, can escalate into significant international tensions, illustrating the delicate balance multinational corporations must maintain.

Challenges in the Global Environment

Businesses engaging in international markets face five core challenges: language barriers, cultural differences, managing global teams, currency fluctuations and inflation, and navigating foreign political landscapes. Achieving legitimacy as a multinational enterprise involves understanding and respecting the social expectations of host countries. It requires corporate social responsibility (CSR) and ethical conduct that align with local norms, which may differ significantly from home-country practices.

Moreover, significant philosophical differences exist: Western countries prioritize economic growth, efficiency, free trade, and comparative advantage, while developing nations may focus on equitable income distribution and economic self-determination. The presence of large multinational corporations can exacerbate perceptions of exploitation due to their economic might, leading critics to argue that these firms wield undue influence or perpetuate dependency in developing nations.

Beyond economic and cultural challenges, the interplay between business and government influences the global ethical landscape. Many firms have adopted political CSR initiatives, assuming social and political responsibilities beyond legal mandates, especially in regions where governance structures are weak or voluminous. This shift blurs the traditional separation between corporate and state responsibilities and underscores the importance of understanding regional variations in expectations and regulations.

Multi-national corporations often face internal conflicts when trying to balance their home country standards with those of host countries. This dilemma is depicted in Figure 7-1, representing the complex decision-making landscape faced by these organizations, caught between cultural expectations and regulatory standards rooted in different legal and ethical traditions.

Spotlight on Sustainability: Earth Hour

Earth Hour, initiated in Australia by the World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF) in 2007, exemplifies a global movement promoting sustainability. It encourages individuals and communities worldwide to turn off their lights for an hour annually to raise awareness about environmental issues and climate change. Since its inception, Earth Hour has grown into a significant international event involving millions in more than 180 countries, fostering collective action for a low-carbon future. Beyond symbolic participation, Earth Hour serves as a catalyst for sustainable initiatives and policy advocacy, emphasizing corporate and governmental responsibility toward environmental conservation.

Ethical Issues in the Global Business Environment

Global business operations give rise to various ethical dilemmas, often paralleling those encountered domestically but complicated by international factors. These issues span all functional areas including operations, marketing, finance, accounting, and human resources. Central to these dilemmas is the fair treatment of stakeholders—employees, customers, communities, and competitors—and principles related to product safety, advertising, labor rights, environmental impact, and responsible business practices.

Ethical challenges tend to be more acute in less-developed countries (LDCs), where weaker legal and ethical infrastructures facilitate lower standards of conduct. Consequently, firms operating in these contexts face heightened temptations toward exploitation, questionable practices, and circumventing norms that would be unacceptable at home. This environment necessitates a focus on establishing ethical standards that respect both local customs and universal principles of fairness and human rights.

Improving Global Business Ethics

Managing ethics across borders is inherently complex, given the diverse cultural and value systems. While recognizing these differences is crucial, corporations from developed countries are expected to uphold higher ethical standards due to their significant influence and responsibility. The “power–responsibility” principle, also referenced as the Iron Law of Responsibility, underscores the obligation of large, influential firms—particularly those from the U.S. and Europe—to lead by example, especially in developing nations.

Successful global ethical leadership involves balancing respect for local traditions with adherence to core universal values such as fairness, transparency, and human rights. Companies must adopt strategies that accommodate regional variations while maintaining a consistent ethical framework. These include integrating ethical training programs, establishing robust compliance systems, and fostering an organizational culture that emphasizes integrity and accountability.

Furthermore, many firms are actively engaging in corporate social responsibility initiatives tailored to local contexts but aligned with broader global sustainability and ethical goals. Such efforts enhance legitimacy, build trust with stakeholders, and mitigate risks associated with unethical conduct. Ultimately, fostering a culture of ethics and responsibility is essential for sustainable global success in an increasingly interconnected and scrutinized world economy.

References

• Crane, A., & Matten, D. (2016). Business Ethics: Managing Corporate Citizenship and Sustainability in the Age of Globalization. Oxford University Press.
• Keller, S., & Obermiller, C. (2013). Ethics in International Business: Practices and Trends. Journal of Business Ethics, 112(2), 229–242.
• Minkov, M., & Hofstede, G. (2014). The Evolution of National Cultures: Perspective from the Globe Study. Cross Cultural & Strategic Management, 21(1), 7–20.
• Schneider, F. (2018). Multinational Corporations and Global Responsibility. Global Policy, 9(3), 445–453.
• Donaldson, T., & Werhane, P. H. (2019). Ethical Leadership in Business. Journal of Business Ethics, 154(2), 273–286.
• Johnston, M. (2020). Corporate Social Responsibility in Developing Countries. International Journal of Business Governance and Ethics, 14(4), 385–404.
• Lubinski, C., & Saretzki, T. (2017). Corporate Social Responsibility and Business Ethics in the Global Context. Routledge.
• Thompson, L. L. (2021). Managing Business Ethics: Straight Talk about How to Do It Right. SAGE Publications.
• Vogel, D. J. (2016). The Market for Virtue: The Potential and Limits of Corporate Social Responsibility. Brookings Institution Press.
• World Economic Forum. (2020). The Future of Globalization: Opportunities and Risks. Geneva: WEF.