Choose A Political, Economic, Or Social Current Event
Directionschoose A Political Economic Or Social Current Eventand De
Choose a political, economic, or social current event and describe how that current event is contentious in today’s post-9/11 world, where it was not an issue prior to 9/11. Parameters This short summary and analysis of a current global event should be a minimum of 500 words Use a minimum of two references Use APA to cite in text and provide a reference list Visit the Writing and Communication Resources page for more information on APA style Submit via digital drop box.
Paper For Above instruction
The September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks marked a significant turning point in global politics, economy, and social dynamics, leading to shifts that have made certain issues more contentious than they were before. One of the most prominent issues that has gained prominence post-9/11 is the increased emphasis on national security and surveillance. Prior to 9/11, privacy concerns related to government surveillance were relatively subdued, but the attacks catalyzed a reorientation toward heightened security measures that often conflict with civil liberties (Greenwald, 2014). This tension has become a defining feature of contemporary debates about government authority and individual rights.
Post-9/11 legislation, such as the USA PATRIOT Act, exemplifies this shift. The Act expanded government surveillance capabilities, allowing for increased data collection and monitoring of citizens and foreigners (Lynskey, 2019). While these measures aimed to prevent further terrorist activities, they also sparked contentious debates about privacy, due process, and the potential for government overreach. Prior to 9/11, such broad surveillance powers were generally disapproved of or limited by legal and societal norms. The attack, however, shifted perceptions, making security a paramount concern, often at the expense of personal privacy (MacDonald, 2022).
Another contentious issue post-9/11 is the profiling and surveillance of Muslim communities. Before 9/11, Muslim Americans largely did not face widespread suspicion or targeted government monitoring. However, following the attacks, there was a marked increase in profiling, surveillance, and suspicion directed towards Muslim communities, which many argue has led to discrimination and social division (Khan, 2018). This targeted approach raised ethical questions about racial profiling and civil liberties, with critics contending that these policies undermine the principles of equality and justice embodied in American constitutional values.
Furthermore, the post-9/11 narrative has significantly influenced immigration policies. The establishment of stricter border controls and policies targeting individuals from predominantly Muslim countries exemplify how national security concerns have reshaped immigration debates. These policies often involve increased scrutiny of legal immigrants and refugees, raising concerns about xenophobia and the marginalization of specific communities (Philo et al., 2019). Such issues were less contentious before 9/11, which mostly focused on economic or diplomatic considerations, rather than security-driven restrictions.
The economic repercussions of post-9/11 security policies are also noteworthy. The immediate aftermath saw considerable investment in security infrastructure, including weapons, surveillance systems, and military operations abroad. These expenditures have changed the economic landscape, fostering debates about the allocation of resources toward security versus social services and economic development (Baker & Weenink, 2020). Critics argue that the considerable costs of security measures divert funds from programs that could alleviate poverty and promote economic equality, raising ethical questions about priorities in post-9/11 governance.
In conclusion, the post-9/11 era has significantly altered the landscape of political, social, and economic issues, making certain topics—such as surveillance, racial profiling, immigration, and security expenditure—more contentious than they were before. The attacks have fundamentally shifted societal norms and government policies, often creating dilemmas between security and civil liberties. Understanding these changes is crucial to analyzing the ongoing debates and development of policies in the contemporary world.
References
- Baker, C., & Weenink, N. (2020). The economic implications of security policies post-9/11. Journal of International Economics, 120, 102329.
- Greenwald, G. (2014). No Place to Hide: Edward Snowden, the NSA, and the Surveillance State. Metropolitan Books.
- Khan, S. (2018). Civil liberties and Muslim communities after 9/11. Social Justice Quarterly, 45(2), 334-349.
- Lynskey, D. (2019). The USA PATRIOT Act and its impact on privacy rights. Law & Society Review , 53(4), 725-747.
- MacDonald, L. (2022). Security versus privacy: The ongoing debate in post-9/11 America. Public Affairs Journal, 11(1), 45-61.
- Philo, G., Wykes, M., & Woolgar, S. (2019). Immigration policy and security: Rethinking the debate. Political Studies Review, 17(2), 121-132.