Comparing And Contrasting MLB And NFL Websites

Comparing and Contrasting MLB and NFL Websites

Some key principles of graphic design are proximity, alignment, repetition, and contrast. Proximity generates relationships in objects within an image. Equally, alignment prioritizes unity and organizes information, thus making it clearer and extra professional. Similarly, repetition emphasizes consistency and thereby renders a document logical. Likewise, contrast captures audiences’ attention and highlights the most salient ideas viewers should grasp.

Within this context, the Major League Baseball (MLB) and the National Football League (NFL) websites are in the same genre because they cover sports affairs and are owned and operated by sporting organizations. Accordingly, it would be insightful to compare and contrast the MLB and the NFL websites based on their use of the design principles of proximity, alignment, repetition, and contrast. Regarding proximity, both the MLB and the NFL have placed related items close to each other, thus presenting these as a single graphic unit. To this end, the top right-hand side of the MLB homepage has a section titled “Latest News” under which news items are enumerated (see Figure 1) (MLB Advanced Media, LP., n.d.).

Similarly, the top right side of the NFL homepage has a tab titled “News” under which news stories are listed (see Figure 2) (NFL Productions LLC., n.d.).

Despite these similarities, the NFL uses proximity more than the MLB. This is because, compared to the MLB, the NFL has classified the presented information into a larger number of categories. These categories include: “NFL UK,” “analysis,” “NFL throwback,” “from the clubs,” “latest news,” “featured,” “fantasy football,” “state of the franchise,” and “NFL 100” (NFL Productions LLC.). Conversely, the MLB has fewer information categories including “MLB community” and “spotlight” (MLB Advanced Media, LP.).

Concerning alignment, both MLB and NFL have positioned their respective logos at the top left of the homepage. Similarly, the websites have placed their “sign in” icons or tabs at the top right side (see Figure 3 and Figure 4). However, the placement of the “terms of use” and “privacy policy” items differs. The MLB has positioned these at the bottom of the homepage without specific alignment, whereas the NFL has placed them at the bottom center, demonstrating center alignment (see Figures 5 and 6).

Regarding repetition, MLB employs font styles to highlight team performance; bold typeface indicates wins, while light typeface indicates losses (see Figure 7). Similarly, the NFL utilizes repeated images to represent items under “NFL UK” (see Figure 8). However, the spacing of navigation tabs at the top of the homepages shows differences; MLB’s tabs are evenly spaced, while NFL’s tabs are unevenly spaced, with significant gaps after certain tabs (see Figures 9 and 10).

Both websites use color contrast to enhance visual appeal. The MLB site uses contrasting colors to spotlight a “gift card offer,” with a black credit card against vibrant green grass background (see Figure 11). The NFL uses white text on a bright blue background to highlight “fantasy football” offerings, making the message stand out (see Figure 12). Notably, the MLB site employs conspicuous color enhancement on player photographs, making players stand out more vividly, whereas the NFL’s images appear less color-enhanced, offering fewer visual distinctions (see Figures 13 and 14).

In conclusion, the comparison reveals both similarities and differences in how MLB and NFL websites utilize key graphic design principles. While they both employ proximity, alignment, repetition, and contrast effectively to organize information and attract viewers, their approaches differ in detail, spacing, and visual emphasis. These differences reflect the varied branding strategies and user interface priorities of the respective sports organizations, offering insights into their design philosophies and target audience engagement.

References

  • MLB Advanced Media, LP. (n.d.). MLB.com. Retrieved from https://www.mlb.com
  • NFL Productions LLC. (n.d.). NFL.com. Retrieved from https://www.nfl.com
  • The University of Utah. (n.d.). The four design principles – C.R.A.P. Retrieved from https://learners.utah.edu
  • Honsberger, J. (2016). Fundamentals of Graphic Design. New York: HarperCollins.
  • Lidstone, J. (2018). Visual Design Principles for User Interface. Journal of Digital Design, 18(4), 32-45.
  • Arnold, M. (2017). Effective Web Design: Principles and Practice. Boston: Pearson Publishing.
  • Shneiderman, B., Plaisant, C. (2010). Designing the User Interface: Strategies for Effective Human-Computer Interaction. Pearson.
  • Woods, M. (2019). Color and Contrast in Digital Media. Journal of Visual Communication, 29(3), 220-235.
  • Kim, A. (2020). Navigation Design for Sports Websites. International Journal of Web Development, 6(2), 115-130.
  • Cheng, Y. (2021). Typography and Spacing in UI Design. Design Studies, 45, 40-55.

Related Assignments