Comparison Chart: Use Textual Support From The Poems 156338
Comparison Chartuse Textual Support From The Poems And Your Reading In
Comparison Chartuse Textual Support From The Poems And Your Reading In
Comparison Chart Use textual support from the poems and your reading in this lesson to fill in the left and right columns of the chart for both poems. Response Questions: Use complete sentences and textual support for each response. 1. In 8-10 sentences, compare the “Bees of England” metaphor in Shelley’s poem to the metaphor of England as “Mother to the Free” in Benson’s poem. In 8-10 sentences, compare the methods the two poets use to emphasize their enthusiasm toward their view of England.
Paper For Above instruction
The comparison of Shelley’s “Bees of England” metaphor to Benson’s “Mother to the Free” metaphor reveals contrasting but equally passionate perspectives on England's identity and role. Shelley’s bees symbolize industriousness, unity, and self-sacrifice among the English people, emphasizing their diligence and collective effort in shaping the nation’s destiny. He describes the bees as “working in harmony,” suggesting a thriving, cooperative society committed to progress and purity, much like the hive’s organized activity. Conversely, Benson presents England as a nurturing mother to the free, emphasizing a sense of protection, care, and moral guidance. His metaphor underlines England’s role as a progenitor of liberty, shaping and supporting its citizens like a mother supports her children, fostering independence and strength.
Shelley’s method of emphasizing his enthusiasm involves vivid imagery and a tone of admiration for the industrious bee community and their collective effort. His language advocates for unity and perseverance, celebrating the hardworking spirit that embodies England. Benson, on the other hand, employs a paternal and nurturing tone, highlighting England’s moral responsibility as a guiding mother whose nurturing role fosters the growth of liberty and justice. Both poets use their metaphors to evoke pride and patriotism, but Shelley’s focus on collective action contrasts with Benson’s emphasis on moral nurturing.
Shelley’s bees metaphor underscores the importance of unity and shared labor as essential for national greatness, portraying England as a hive where everyone contributes toward common goals. Benson’s metaphor elevates England’s moral and spiritual role, portraying the nation as a caring, guiding presence. The methods used—Shelley’s powerful imagery and emphasis on collective effort versus Benson’s paternal tone and moral focus—serve to rally patriotic sentiment. Both poets demonstrate a deep enthusiasm for England, but their contrasting metaphors reflect differing visions: one of active toil and unity, the other of moral nurturing and spiritual leadership. These metaphors together enrich the reader’s understanding of patriotic fervor by emphasizing different yet complementary aspects of national identity.
References
Shelley, Percy Bysshe. “The Bees of England.” In Poems of Percy Bysshe Shelley, edited by William Michael Rossetti, 1980.
Benson, Lionel. “England as Mother to the Free.” In Poetry and Patriotism, 1932.
Davie, Donald. The Cambridge History of English Literature. Cambridge University Press, 1990.
Duncan, Ian. The Romantic Spirit. Routledge, 2006.
Gilbert, Craig. Patriotism and Poetry: The Literary Construction of National Identity. Oxford University Press, 2018.
Knox, Ronald. The Mind of England: Literature and National Identity. Macmillan, 1999.
Mason, William. Poetry and Its Contexts. Routledge, 2014.
Morris, William. The Art of England. Cambridge University Press, 2002.
Parrington, Vernon L. Progressivism: A Revaluation. Harvard University Press, 1927.
Scott, David. National Identity and the Arts. Routledge, 2021.