Critical Thinking Assignment 100 Points Important Rea 815969

Critical Thinking Assignment100 Pointsimportant Read Firstchoose On

Critical Thinking Assignment (100 Points) Importantly, choose one of the following two assignments to complete this week. Do not do both assignments. Indicate your chosen assignment in the title of your submission. When ready to submit, click the Module 6 Critical Thinking header on the Assignments page to upload the document.

Paper For Above instruction

The provided assignment offers two distinct options, each requiring critical analysis and well-structured arguments. The first option involves creating a virtual desktop business proposal, while the second involves developing a presentation to argue against outsourcing in the context of IT department outsourcing. Candidates must select one task to focus on, based on their strengths and interests, and produce comprehensive, well-supported work adhering to academic standards.

Assignment Choice #1 involves analyzing the potential benefits and costs associated with adopting a virtual desktop solution, especially for a financially struggling company. The task demands a detailed proposal of at least four advantages over the existing system, with a clear comparison and justification for choosing the recommended solution. The work must be a minimum of two pages, double-spaced, and supported with at least three credible sources, properly cited in APA format, reflecting the student's research and critical evaluation skills.

Assignment Choice #2 tasks students with defending the existing IT department against outsourcing, which the company considers due to financial difficulties. The student must critically evaluate the costs and benefits of outsourcing, then craft a minimum of 10 slides for a presentation that articulates at least four strong reasons for retaining the department. Each slide should include detailed notes to elaborate on points, with references cited properly per APA guidelines. The goal is to demonstrate critical thinking, persuasive argumentation, and proper academic referencing in a presentation format.

Paper For Above instruction

Choosing between the two assignments requires careful consideration of one's expertise and confidence in either proposal writing or presentation development. Both options demand the application of critical thinking, analytical skills, and research proficiency. The first assignment emphasizes understanding technological solutions, cost-benefit analysis, and business justification, requiring a formal proposal. The second emphasizes advocacy and persuasive communication, focusing on strategic reasoning and structured oral presentation skills.

In the context of the virtual desktop solution proposal, it is essential to assess the significant advantages this technology offers to a financially constrained organization. Virtual desktops provide numerous benefits, including enhanced mobility, improved security, simplified management, and cost savings over traditional desktop setups (Smith, 2020). These benefits, when thoughtfully articulated, can convincingly demonstrate how moving to a virtual desktop infrastructure (VDI) aligns with strategic organizational goals. For instance, increased flexibility and remote access can support a mobile workforce, thereby boosting productivity and employee satisfaction (Jones & Williams, 2019). Additionally, virtual desktops offer centralized control, which simplifies cybersecurity measures and reduces the risk of data breaches—a critical concern in today's digital landscape (Kumar & Clark, 2021).

From a cost perspective, while the initial investment in VDI may be substantial, over time, operational costs decrease due to lower hardware expenses, easier maintenance, and more efficient resource utilization (Brown & Patel, 2022). Moreover, virtual desktops facilitate disaster recovery and business continuity planning, limiting downtime and data loss, which are crucial in a financially strained environment (Lee, 2018). Analyzing these factors highlights how the benefits of VDI can outweigh the costs, making the proposal a strategically sound move.

In contrast, the job retention presentation must focus on refuting the rationale for outsourcing IT functions. Outsourcing is often justified by the belief in cost savings, access to specialized expertise, and operational flexibility (Martin & Gonzalez, 2020). However, defense of maintaining an internal IT department can be rooted in the value of organizational knowledge, quicker response times, and control over critical data (Taylor, 2021). The internal team develops a nuanced understanding of company-specific needs, which cannot be easily replicated by external contractors. Additionally, in-house IT staff contribute to innovation and proactive problem-solving, which enhances overall business agility (O'Neill & Roberts, 2022).

Furthermore, outsourcing can expose companies to risks such as loss of proprietary information, reduced accountability, and potential service disruptions (Chen & Liu, 2019). Maintaining the internal IT department guarantees continuous oversight, immediate issue resolution, and customized service delivery, all of which are vital during economic uncertainties. From a strategic perspective, preserving the internal team fosters organizational resilience and preserves core competencies that contribute to competitive advantage (Singh & Kaur, 2020). Therefore, the arguments emphasize that despite apparent cost savings, outsourcing might undermine long-term stability and security.

In conclusion, whether developing a business proposal for virtual desktops or crafting a persuasive presentation against outsourcing, the key to effective critical thinking lies in comprehensive analysis, balanced evaluation of evidence, and clear articulation of arguments. Both assignments serve as exercises in strategic reasoning and evidence-based decision-making—skills crucial for IT professionals navigating complex organizational challenges.

References

  • Brown, T., & Patel, S. (2022). Cost analysis of virtual desktop infrastructure deployment. Journal of Technology Management, 18(3), 45-59.
  • Chen, R., & Liu, Y. (2019). Risks and rewards of IT outsourcing: An empirical study. International Journal of Information Management, 39, 183-190.
  • Jones, A., & Williams, M. (2019). Enhancing workplace flexibility through virtual desktops. Journal of Business Technology, 12(4), 233-245.
  • Kumar, P., & Clark, J. (2021). Cybersecurity benefits of centralized virtual desktop deployment. Cybersecurity Review, 5(2), 105-120.
  • Lee, S. (2018). Disaster recovery strategies with cloud-based virtual desktops. Cloud Computing Journal, 7(1), 28-34.
  • Martin, L., & Gonzalez, D. (2020). The pitfalls and promises of outsourcing IT functions. Journal of Strategic Management, 22(2), 112-125.
  • O'Neill, D., & Roberts, P. (2022). Internal IT teams as catalysts for innovation. Journal of Information Systems Management, 29(1), 33-47.
  • S Singh, K., & Kaur, P. (2020). Core competencies and organizational resilience. International Journal of Business Strategy, 16(1), 50-60.
  • Smith, J. (2020). Virtual desktop infrastructure benefits and challenges. IT Management Journal, 14(4), 50-62.
  • Taylor, R. (2021). Organizational knowledge and control in IT management. Management Science Review, 27(3), 199-211.

Related Assignments