Discuss The Various Direct And Indirect Environmental Values

Discuss The Various Direct And Indirect Environmental Valuesassociated

Environmental values related to oceans encompass both direct and indirect benefits derived from these expansive aquatic systems. While direct values often involve quantifiable resources such as fish, water, and minerals, indirect values are more abstract yet equally vital, including ecosystem stability, biodiversity, recreational opportunities, and climate regulation. These values are critical considerations in environmental policy and resource management as they reflect different ways humans benefit from oceans.

Direct environmental values of oceans primarily include resources exploited commercially and sustenance-based uses. Fisheries provide vital protein sources to millions worldwide, generating economic benefits for fishing industries and local communities. Coastal regions depend on ocean water for drinking and agriculture, with desalination technologies offering fresh water in arid zones. Moreover, oceans are significant for shipping routes, facilitating global trade, and harboring minerals like oil, gas, and deep-sea minerals, which are extracted for energy and industrial purposes. Tourism related to beaches, coral reefs, and marine life also provides substantial revenue, directly tied to the health of the marine environment.

Conversely, indirect values are less tangible but crucial for ecological resilience and human well-being. Oceans regulate climate by absorbing solar radiation and distributing heat via currents, thus moderating global temperature fluctuations. They support vast biodiversity, maintaining ecological balance and genetic diversity, which underpin resilience against environmental changes and provide potential resources such as pharmaceuticals derived from marine organisms. Additionally, healthy oceans facilitate recreational activities like snorkeling and diving, which contribute to mental health and cultural identity. The presence of vibrant ecosystems such as coral reefs and mangroves also offers coastal protection against storm surges and erosion, reinforcing their indirect environmental value.

Policy Tension Between Ocean Resources and Threats: Pollution and Overfishing

The primary policy tension concerning oceans revolves around balancing economic interests with conservation needs, especially in preventing pollution and overfishing. Pollution poses a severe threat by degrading marine habitats and harming species. Oil rigs and cruise ships frequently release oil, chemicals, and debris into the ocean, which can have devastating effects on marine life and water quality. Overfishing further intensifies this tension as fish stocks decline, disrupting ecological balance and threatening food security for dependent populations.

In response, policies such as the 2004 Oceans 21 bill aim to create a comprehensive framework for ocean protection. The bill advocates establishing national policies focused on maintaining and restoring healthy ocean ecosystems through measures like reducing pollution, regulating fishing activities, and controlling unregulated maritime activities. Implementing such policies may require restrictions on cruise ship operations, fishing quotas, or the development of marine protected areas to support biodiversity and ecosystem functioning.

Worldview Influences on Policy Tensions: Biocentrism Versus Anthropocentrism

The policy tension surrounding ocean conservation is largely shaped by different underlying worldviews. Biocentrism emphasizes the intrinsic value of all living organisms and ecosystems, advocating for the protection of oceans regardless of their utility to humans. This perspective perceives the ocean as a web of interconnected life forms, where human activities are just one part of a larger organic system. This worldview influences policy by prioritizing ecological health and biodiversity, often advocating for stricter regulations to minimize human impact and maintain the ecosystem's integrity (Dale, 2015).

In contrast, anthropocentrism centers human interests and benefits, valuing nature primarily for its utility to human welfare. This outlook might favor resource exploitation for economic growth, tourism, and development, with conservation efforts seen as secondary or only necessary to sustain resources for future human use. Although some policies incorporate this perspective by promoting sustainable resource use, it often conflicts with biocentric ideals, especially regarding restrictions on activities like fishing or shipping.

In the case of the Oceans 21 bill and marine conservation efforts, the predominant worldview appears to be biocentric. The emphasis on maintaining healthy ecosystems and restoring biodiversity reflects a recognition of the intrinsic value of ocean life. This perspective is vital for fostering long-term sustainability, as it encourages policies that protect ocean ecosystems from exploitation and pollution, aligning with the broader goal of preserving the planet’s ecological integrity for future generations.

References

• Dale, L. (2015). Environmental policy (2nd ed.). Bridgepoint Education.
• Safina, C., & Chasis, S. (2004). Saving the oceans. Issues in Science & Technology, 21(1), 37-44.
• Grafton, R. Q., Kompas, T., & Longo, C. (2017). The economics of the ocean. Marine Policy, 15-29.
• Jackson, J. B. C., et al. (2001). Historical overfishing and the recent collapse of coastal ecosystems. Science, 293(5530), 629-637.
• Lubchenco, J., et al. (2003). Plugging the marine habitat and resource management gaps. Science, 302(5649), 1715-1716.
• Pauly, D., et al. (2002). Fishing down marine food webs. Science, 279(5352), 860-863.
• Rochette, J., et al. (2020). Impacts of marine pollution on fish health: a review. Environmental Pollution, 264, 114735.
• World Wildlife Fund (WWF). (2018). The state of our oceans. WWF Reports.
• Jackson, J. B. C., et al. (2001). Historical overfishing and the recent collapse of coastal ecosystems. Science, 293(5530), 629-637.
• Sutton, M. A., et al. (2018). Coastal and marine ecosystem services: insights into their management and valuation. Marine Policy, 65, 84-92.