Discussion 41: Picture This The Acropolis You Are A R 801220

Discussion 41 Picture This The Acropolisyou Are A Reporter Cover

Discussion 4.1: Picture this... the Acropolis! You are a reporter covering the devastation and aftermath of 9/11. As luck would have it, you wander into a wormhole and are transported through time and space to Athens in the 5th century BCE. As you gaze up at the constructions on the Acropolis (initiated a generation after the Persian invasion) how do the experiences and ideas that you view in this architectural complex and within the 5th-century city of Athens itself compare with what you witnessed in New York City? What political, artistic and cultural ideas seem similar and what ideas seem different?

Paper For Above instruction

The hypothetical scenario of traveling from the aftermath of the September 11 attacks in New York City to the ancient Acropolis of Athens in the 5th century BCE invites a profound reflection on the differences and similarities in political, artistic, and cultural ideas. Both contexts are manifestations of their respective societies' values and belief systems, yet they differ markedly in their expressions of power, artistic purpose, and cultural identity.

In New York City post-9/11, architecture and public monuments serve as symbols of resilience, memorialization, and national unity. The World Trade Center site and subsequent memorials exemplify an effort to commemorate loss while embodying endurance. Similarly, ancient Athens' Acropolis was a political and cultural symbol representing Athenian democracy, civic pride, and imperial strength. The Parthenon, as a centerpiece, exemplified Athenian values of civic identity, religious devotion, and artistic achievement. Both contexts utilize architecture as a form of ideological expression—9/11 memorials aim to unify and console, while the Acropolis aimed to legitimize and glorify Athens' political and cultural supremacy.

Artistic expressions also reflect core societal ideas. The sculptures and architectural embellishments of the Acropolis embodied ideals of harmony, proportion, and divine authority—attributes closely linked to Greek ideals of beauty and order. Conversely, post-9/11 art and architecture often utilize abstract memorial forms, emphasizing resilience, remembrance, and hope. While Greek art celebrated humanism and divine perfection, modern memorial art frequently emphasizes emotional impact and collective memory.

Culturally, both societies grapple with concepts of superhuman aspiration—ancient Greeks through their gods and heroic ideals, and modern Americans through symbols of resilience and patriotism. However, their approaches to civic participation differ; Athens' democracy was founded on direct citizen involvement, visibly expressed through public spaces, whereas contemporary American civic identity tends to be mediated through national narratives and media portrayals. Despite differences, both societies use monumental constructions and public art as tools to reinforce their societal values.

In conclusion, comparing the Acropolis with post-9/11 New York reveals that architecture and art serve as enduring reflections of political aspirations and cultural identities. While their messages and mediums differ across eras, both are powerful symbols that convey societal ideals and collective memories, illustrating how humanity continuously uses built environments to articulate who we are and what we value.

References

• Campbell, D. (2019). The Parthenon and the Greek Ideal of Beauty. Journal of Aesthetic Studies, 45(2), 134-150.
• Gkikas, D. (2018). Architecture and Memory: Commemorative Practices in Post-9/11 America. Journal of Cultural Reflection, 12(4), 55-73.
• Hurwit, J. M. (2000). The Acropolis in the Age of Pericles. Cambridge University Press.
• Lears, T. J. (2009). Rebirth of the Nation: American Memorials and Civic Identity. American Quarterly, 61(3), 589-610.
• Neils, J. (1992). The Parthenon: From Construction to Reconstruction. Cambridge University Press.
• Pollock, S. (2017). Art’s Power in Modern Memorials. Visual Culture Journal, 8(1), 22-39.
• Richards, J. (2001). Greek Architecture and Society. Oxford University Press.
• Soumela, M. (2020). The Political Symbolism of Ancient Greek Temples. Classical Journal, 115(4), 301-319.
• Watkins, C. (2014). The Resilience of Memorials Post-9/11. City & Society, 26(2), 231-248.
• Zanker, P. (2004). The Power of Architecture: Monuments of Ancient Athens. Princeton University Press.