Discussion: Organizational Policies And Practices To Support

Discussion: Organizational Policies and Practices to Support Healthcare Issues

In the complex landscape of healthcare, nurse leaders often confront ethical dilemmas stemming from the necessity to balance competing needs—such as workforce wellbeing, available resources, and patient safety. These competing needs are especially pronounced when devising policies aimed at addressing pressing healthcare issues, including those highlighted by the Affordable Care Act of 2010 (ACA). The ACA aimed to improve access to healthcare but also introduced challenges related to resource allocation and workforce management, which require careful policy considerations to ensure positive outcomes.

Effective leadership in healthcare necessitates a nuanced understanding of how competing needs influence policy development. Resources, including staffing, funding, and equipment, are limited, compelling leaders to make decisions that can prioritize one need over another. For example, policies promoting extended work shifts, such as 12-hour nursing shifts, are often implemented to address staffing shortages and to reduce costs. However, evidence suggests that longer shifts correlate with increased errors, patient safety risks, and nurse fatigue (Kelly & Porr, 2018). Such policies exemplify how resource constraints can lead to ethical dilemmas where operational efficiency conflicts with patient safety and workforce wellbeing.

Furthermore, the needs of patients, workforce, and organizational sustainability frequently compete, especially under the pressure of a national healthcare crisis. For instance, during the COVID-19 pandemic, healthcare organizations faced unprecedented demands: the need to maximize workforce availability, ensure safety, and deliver quality care, all while managing scarce resources like PPE and ventilators (Milliken, 2018). These competing needs often result in difficult policy decisions, such as rationing care or reallocating staffing, which may impact patient outcomes and staff morale.

Impacts of Competing Needs and Policy Responses

The impacts of these competing needs are profound. Policies that fail to consider the multifaceted nature of healthcare delivery risk unintended consequences. For example, prioritizing cost containment through extended shifts without adequate staffing support can increase burnout among nurses, reduce care quality, and lead to adverse patient outcomes (Kelly & Porr, 2018). Conversely, policies that focus solely on workforce safety and quality may escalate costs or reduce staffing levels, impacting organizational sustainability.

To address these competing needs, policies must be multifaceted and adaptable. For instance, implementing mandated work-hour limits—such as the 16-hour shift policy often recommended—can help mitigate fatigue and errors, aligning workforce and patient safety (Milliken, 2018). Additionally, healthcare organizations can adopt workforce wellness programs, offer flexible scheduling, and invest in staffing solutions—such as hiring additional personnel or integrating technology—to balance the workload (American Nurses Association, 2010).

The role of leadership is pivotal in fostering a culture that values ethical considerations alongside operational efficiency. Ethical frameworks like the ANA Code of Ethics emphasize the importance of prioritizing patient safety while advocating for workforce rights (ANA, 2015). Leaders must engage staff in policy development, ensuring that policies reflect collective priorities and ethical standards. For example, involving nursing staff in scheduling decisions can help balance organizational needs with their wellbeing, ultimately fostering a safer and more ethical work environment.

Specific Competing Needs Impacting Healthcare Issues

Focusing specifically on the ACA, one of the primary competing needs involves expanding access to care while managing the financial and resource implications of such expansion. Increased coverage led to higher demand for services, straining existing workforce and infrastructure. This created a need for policies that could expand provider capacity without compromising quality or safety. For example, policy initiatives to increase funding for provider training, support telehealth integration, and incentivize workforce expansion address these needs while aiming to maintain patient safety.

Another critical need relates to addressing health disparities and ensuring equitable access. Policies must balance resource allocation to underserved communities with overall organizational sustainability. For example, community health initiatives and Medicaid expansion under the ACA aimed to improve access but required careful resource planning to avoid overburdening healthcare facilities or diluting service quality.

Conclusion

In conclusion, effective leadership in healthcare involves navigating the complex interplay of competing needs—workforce wellbeing, resource availability, and patient safety—when developing policies, especially amid a national healthcare issue like that presented by the ACA. Policies that are ethically grounded, evidence-based, and inclusive of stakeholder input can better balance these needs, leading to safer, more equitable, and sustainable healthcare delivery. Leaders must remain adaptable and proactive, continuously evaluating and adjusting policies to meet the evolving landscape of healthcare challenges.

References

• American Nurses Association. (2010). Code of ethics for nurses with interpretive statements. Silver Spring, MD: Author.
• Kelly, P., & Porr, C. (2018). Ethical nursing care versus cost containment: Considerations to enhance RN practice. OJIN: Online Journal of Issues in Nursing, 23(1), Manuscript 6. https://doi.org/10.3912/OJIN.Vol23No01Man06
• Milliken, A. (2018). Ethical awareness: What it is and why it matters. OJIN: Online Journal of Issues in Nursing, 23(1), Manuscript 1. https://doi.org/10.3912/OJIN.Vol23No01Man01
• Laureate Education (Producer). (2012). Ethical, Moral, and Legal Leadership [Video file].
• Laureate Education (Producer). (2009b). Working with Individuals [Video file].
• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2010). The Affordable Care Act: Impact and implications. HHS Publications.
• Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. (2019). Resource planning in healthcare systems. AHRQ Reports.
• Fletcher, K., & Flynn, L. (2019). Nursing workforce management in the era of healthcare reform. Nursing Outlook, 67(2), 115-122.
• Sullivan, E., & Garland, G. (2018). Policy development in healthcare: Ethical perspectives. Journal of Nursing Administration, 48(4), 200-205.
• World Health Organization. (2016). Health workforce policy and management guidelines. WHO Publications.