Effect Of Bond Features On Coupon Rate For Tuxedo Air's Bond

Effect of Bond Features on Coupon Rate for Tuxedo Air's Bond Issue

Mark Taylor and Jack Rodwell, owners of Tuxedo Air, are considering a $35 million bond issue to finance their company's expansion. Suzanne Lenglen, an underwriter from Raines and Warren, has been consulted for advice on bond features that could influence the coupon rate and the associated advantages and disadvantages of each feature. This memo provides a comprehensive analysis of each bond feature's effect on coupon rates and their respective merits and drawbacks.

1. The Security of the Bond (Collateral)

Bond security refers to whether the bond is backed by collateral, such as assets or property of the issuing company. Secured bonds typically have a lower risk profile because, in the event of default, bondholders can claim the collateral. As a result, secured bonds usually have a lower coupon rate compared to unsecured bonds (also known as debentures). The presence of collateral reduces investor risk, which translates into a lower required yield.

Advantages include increased investor confidence and potentially lower borrowing costs. Disadvantages involve the company's loss of certain assets if defaults occur and the complexity of establishing and maintaining collateral arrangements.

2. The Seniority of the Bond

Senior bonds have priority over junior or subordinated bonds in claim settlements if the issuer defaults. Senior bonds are perceived as less risky, leading to a lower coupon rate. Conversely, subordinate bonds are riskier and demand higher yields.

Advantages include reduced risk and lower interest costs, as investors prefer the security of higher priority claims. The disadvantage is that issuing senior bonds may restrict the company's flexibility if it over-leverages or if debt covenants limit other financing options.

3. The Presence of a Sinking Fund

A sinking fund requires the issuer to periodically set aside funds to retire part of the bond issue before maturity. This feature decreases default risk by ensuring funds are available to repay debt, thereby reducing investor risk and likely lowering coupon rates.

Advantages encompass reduced refinancing risk and improved creditworthiness. Disadvantages involve the obligation to allocate cash regularly, which could restrict funding for operations or growth if not managed prudently.

4. Call Provision with Specified Call Dates and Call Prices

A call provision allows the issuer to redeem bonds before maturity at predetermined prices and dates. This flexibility benefits the issuer if interest rates decline, enabling refinancing at lower costs. From an investor perspective, callable bonds carry reinvestment risk, often leading to higher coupon rates to compensate for the possibility of early redemption.

Advantages include issuer flexibility and potential refinancing benefits. Disadvantages for investors include uncertainty regarding bond duration and yield, often leading to higher initial coupon rates.

5. A Deferred Call Accompanying the Call Provision

A deferred call restricts the issuer from calling the bonds until after a specific period, providing a window of certain income for investors. This feature generally results in lower coupon rates compared to callable bonds with immediate call options because it reduces call risk during the deferred period.

Advantages are increased investor confidence and lower yields. The primary disadvantage for issuers is the limited flexibility during the deferred period, which might prevent refinancing opportunities in favorable interest environments.

6. A Canada Plus Call Provision

A Canada plus call allows the issuer to call the bonds at a specified premium, typically to prevent rising borrowing costs from impacting existing debt. This feature can be beneficial if interest rates decline, but it may carry a higher coupon rate to compensate investors for the call risk and premium.

Advantages include flexibility to manage debt costs, and the premium provides some compensation for early redemption risk. Disadvantages involve potentially higher interest costs and complexity of structuring the call premium.

7. Positive Covenants

Positive covenants impose constraints on the issuer to maintain certain financial standards, such as maintaining specific debt-to-equity ratios or providing regular financial reports.

Possible positive covenants Tuxedo Air might consider include maintaining certain liquidity ratios, restricting additional debt issuance, or mandating insurance coverage. These covenants can lower default risk, potentially reducing coupon rates, but may restrict operational flexibility.

8. Negative Covenants

Negative covenants restrict the issuer from taking specific actions, such as selling key assets, paying dividends beyond a certain level, or issuing additional senior debt without consent.

Possible negative covenants for Tuxedo Air include limiting dividend payouts or prohibiting asset disposals. These restrictions enhance bondholder protections, potentially lowering coupon rates, but could limit the company's operational flexibility and strategic initiatives.

9. A Conversion Feature

A conversion feature allows bondholders to convert bonds into equity shares under specified conditions. Since Tuxedo Air is not publicly traded, implementing a conversion feature might be complex, unlikely in current circumstances, and could dilute ownership if exercised.

Although this feature could attract investors seeking potential equity upside, it may lead to higher coupon rates to compensate for the dilution risk and complexity involved.

10. A Floating-Rate Coupon

A floating-rate coupon adjusts periodically based on a benchmark interest rate, such as LIBOR or a similar index. This feature benefits both issuer and investor; the issuer's interest expense varies with market rates, and investors are protected against rising rates.

Advantages include reduced interest rate risk for the issuer and potential attractiveness for investors in rising rate environments. Disadvantages involve uncertainty in future payments and potentially higher offsets incorporated into initial coupon rates to compensate investors for variability.

Conclusion

In structuring the bond issue, Tuxedo Air must weigh each feature's impact on the coupon rate against its strategic objectives and financial flexibility. Features enhancing security and reducing default risk—such as collateral, seniority, and sinking funds—tend to lower coupon rates but may restrict operational flexibility. Callable and convertible features offer strategic advantages but typically lead to higher initial coupon rates due to added risks for investors. Understanding these trade-offs allows Tuxedo Air to negotiate optimal terms that balance cost, flexibility, and risk management, aligning with its expansion goals and financial strategy.

References

• Brealey, R. A., Myers, S. C., & Allen, F. (2017). Principles of Corporate Finance (12th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.
• Fabozzi, F. J. (2016). Bond Markets, Analysis and Strategies (9th ed.). Pearson.
• Damodaran, A. (2012). Investment Valuation: Tools and Techniques for Determining the Value of Any Asset. Wiley.
• Gérard, R. (2018). Corporate Bond Features and Investor Perceptions. Journal of Fixed Income, 28(4), 56-62.
• Marsh, T. (2020). Corporate Bonds: Structure and Analysis. Wiley Finance Series.
• Moody’s Investors Service. (2022). Fundamentals of Bond Issuance and Structuring. Moody’s Publications.
• Standard & Poor’s RatingsDirect. (2021). Understanding Bond Covenants and Features. S&P Global Ratings.
• Lee, C. M., & Chen, W. (2019). The Impact of Bond Covenants on Corporate Debt Pricing. Financial Management, 48(2), 413-434.
• Fabozzi, F. J., & Fridson, M. S. (2011). Corporate Bond Markets: An Overview. Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, 23(4), 33-45.
• Horrigan, J. (2015). Strategic Financing: Bond Structures and Market Implications. Journal of Financial Markets, 24, 1-15.