Environmental Issue Project 5 - Rough Draft

Environmental Issue Project 5 - Rough Draft (HUMAN OVERPOPULATION)

For a major part of your grade, you are going to research and complete an environmental issues paper. This will help you build the skills necessary to develop an informed opinion and present that opinion in written form. This project will serve as a final assessment for the course. Using the content of the course, critically evaluate and analyze a controversial environmental issue of your choosing. You must examine the pros, cons, compromises, and tradeoffs of the issue by gathering credible information from various sources and assess the scientific credibility of the information. You will then develop from this information a well thought out paper that will address the major players involved, relevant cited facts, and a clearly identified opinion.

The first part of this project will be to submit a topic to your instructor for approval. Research the topic using online library, the online library, scientific journals, government documents, books, science magazines, and personal interviews. Peer reviewed sources should form the basis of your paper. Use a minimum of 6 sources. The final paper should be double-spaced, 12 point, and 6 to 8 pages in length with citations in APA format.

Anytime you use the writings or ideas of others as though they were your own, you are plagiarizing (even if you paraphrase). All information and ideas that are not a part of general knowledge must be cited. When in doubt, cite! Your final paper should address the following key points:

  • The Controversy: Identify the controversy
  • The Major Players: Who is involved? Why are they involved?
  • Important Facts: State relevant facts concerning the issue. Try to separate fact from opinion. Try not to show your own bias. Properly use APA citations
  • Side One: Arguments; state briefly and cite your sources
  • Side Two: Arguments; state briefly and cite your sources
  • Your Opinion and Rationale: I believe that..., We should..., I feel that... Use supporting arguments and rationale. What arguments would you use to present to those who disagree with you? Cite all of your sources.
  • References: Alphabetize your sources. Make sure there are sources representing both sides of the issue.

Paper For Above instruction

Human overpopulation remains a defining global challenge, with profound implications for environmental sustainability. This paper critically examines the controversy surrounding human overpopulation, identifying the major stakeholders involved, presenting relevant facts, and analyzing arguments from both sides, culminating in a well-supported personal stance.

The Controversy: At its core, the debate centers on whether human overpopulation exacerbates environmental degradation or if technological and societal adaptations can mitigate its impacts. Proponents argue that exponential population growth strains natural resources, accelerates climate change, and leads to biodiversity loss, while opponents contend that sustainable development and technological innovation can support increasing populations without adverse environmental effects.

Major Players: Key stakeholders include scientists, environmental NGOs, government policymakers, industry leaders, and local communities. Scientists provide research and predictions on ecological impacts; NGOs rally public awareness and advocate for sustainable practices; governments craft policies to manage population growth and resource use; industries influence environmental outcomes through production practices; and local populations are directly affected by resource scarcity and environmental degradation.

Important Facts: Globally, the population has surged from approximately 3 billion in 1960 to over 8 billion today (United Nations, 2022). This rapid growth consumes more land, freshwater, and energy, often surpassing the Earth's regenerative capacity (World Resources Institute, 2020). Urbanization intensifies pressure on infrastructure and ecosystems. Conversely, some regions, such as Japan and parts of Europe, face declining populations, raising questions about sustainable demographics and economic viability.

Arguments Supporting Overpopulation as a Problem: Data demonstrates that overpopulation contributes significantly to deforestation, pollution, and increased greenhouse gas emissions (Steffen et al., 2015). The IPAT equation (Impact = Population x Affluence x Technology) illustrates how population growth amplifies environmental impact. Critics argue that current consumption patterns, rather than population alone, are primary drivers of environmental harm (Jackson, 2017).

Arguments Against Overpopulation as a Sole Issue: Advocates emphasizing technological advances suggest that innovation can decouple economic growth from environmental degradation (Kaur & Kaur, 2020). They point to renewable energy, sustainable agriculture, and urban planning as solutions that accommodate population increases without detrimental effects. Moreover, some argue that focusing solely on population reduction overlooks systemic issues like inequality and overconsumption.

My Opinion and Rationale: I believe that human overpopulation intensifies environmental stress and that effective strategies are needed to stabilize population growth through education, family planning, and equitable development. We should focus on reducing consumption inequality and promoting sustainable resource use, recognizing that technological solutions alone cannot address all impacts.

In addressing disagreements, I would argue that while technology can mitigate some environmental impacts, it is not a panacea. Without controlling population growth and changing consumption behaviors, technological advancements may be insufficient to prevent environmental collapse. Therefore, a balanced approach involving population stabilization and technological innovation is essential.

References

  • Jackson, T. (2017). Prosperity Without Growth: Foundations for the Economy of Tomorrow. Routledge.
  • Kaur, P., & Kaur, S. (2020). Sustainable development and technological progress: A review. Environmental Science & Policy, 112, 101-108.
  • Steffen, W., Richardson, K., Rockström, J., et al. (2015). The planetary boundaries: Guiding human development on a changing planet. Science, 347(6223), 1259855.
  • United Nations. (2022). World Population Prospects 2022: Summary of Results. United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs.
  • World Resources Institute. (2020). Resource Facts and Figures. WRI Publications.

Related Assignments