Ethical Decision-Making Steps For Healthcare Administrators

Ethical Decision Making Stepshealthcare Administrators Presentation

Complete this form, the Ethical Decision-Making Steps as defined by the American College of Healthcare Executives (ACHE), based on your selected ethical case study. You will present this information during your next ethics committee meeting. Provide detailed responses to each step with supporting evidence, using APA format for in-text citations and a separate APA reference page. References should be from the last five years, including up to two additional sources outside weekly course content. Indicate your selected case by placing an X in front of the corresponding option below:

  • Option 1 from the eBook - HealthT Seeks Healthier Employees
  • Option 2 from the eBook - CEO Misuse of Company Funds?
  • Option 3 PDF - HealthSouth: A Case Study in Corporate Fraud
  • Option 4 PDF – Ethics and Intimate Sexual Activity in Long-Term Care

Ethical Decision-Making Steps

Step One: Recognize the Background (The Circumstances Leading to the Ethics Conflict)

Describe the context and circumstances that have led to the ethical dilemma in your chosen case. Identify key events, stakeholders involved, and the environment in which the conflict arises. This step involves understanding the factual background thoroughly to set the stage for ethical analysis.

Step Two: Identify the Specific Ethical Question(s) that Need Clarification

Pinpoint the core ethical questions or issues that require resolution. Clarify what makes the situation ethically challenging and what ambiguity exists regarding the moral considerations involved.

Step Three: Consider the Related Ethical Principles and/or Organizational Values

Identify the relevant ethical principles such as autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, justice, and fidelity. Also, relate these principles to your organization’s core values, mission statement, or code of ethics that influence decision-making.

Step Four: Determine the Options for Response(s)

List possible courses of action available to address the ethical dilemma. Evaluate the viability, potential consequences, and ethical implications of each option.

Step Five: Recommend a Response(s)

Choose the most appropriate course of action based on ethical principles, organizational policies, and potential outcomes. Justify your recommendation with supporting evidence.

Step Six: Anticipate the Ethical Conflict

Foresee potential objections, conflicts, or unintended consequences that could arise from your recommended response. Consider how stakeholders might react and what measures could mitigate negative impacts.

Paper For Above instruction

The ethical dilemma selected for detailed analysis is Option 3: "HealthSouth: A Case Study in Corporate Fraud." This case exemplifies significant ethical breaches within a healthcare corporation, involving fraudulent reporting, manipulation of financial statements, and leadership misconduct. The background of this case reveals a high-pressure environment under leadership seeking financial growth at any cost, leading to widespread deception with detrimental impacts on patients, employees, shareholders, and the community.

The core ethical questions arising in this context involve the extent of responsibility leaders have to maintain honesty and transparency versus their own financial and reputational interests. Clarification is needed on whether falsifying reports to inflate company performance aligns with ethical standards and organizational values, and how ethical principles such as honesty, integrity, and justice guide decision-making in corporate fraud cases.

Relevant ethical principles include beneficence and non-maleficence, emphasizing that organizational actions should promote the well-being of stakeholders and prevent harm. Justice and fairness must also be considered, especially regarding shareholder rights and employee trust. The organization's core values—integrity, accountability, and transparency—must be central to resolving such dilemmas, aligning with professional and legal standards governing corporate governance in healthcare entities.

Potential response options include implementing stricter internal controls, fostering an organizational culture of transparency, and initiating forensic audits to uncover misconduct. Other options might involve whistleblower protections or external investigations to hold responsible parties accountable. Each option carries ethical implications regarding transparency, accountability, and the obligation to prevent further harm.

The recommended response is to conduct an independent external audit, reinforce a culture that encourages ethical reporting, and hold accountable those responsible for misconduct while safeguarding whistleblowers. This approach aligns with ethical principles by promoting honesty, integrity, and organizational accountability. It also supports organizational values of transparency and stewardship, essential in restoring trust among stakeholders.

Anticipating ethical conflicts, resistance from leadership, or legal repercussions may occur when exposing misconduct. Stakeholders such as shareholders or management may resist transparency efforts fearing reputational damage or financial loss. To mitigate conflicts, clear communication, legal safeguards for whistleblowers, and transparent engagement with all stakeholders are vital. Ensuring that the response is ethical, legally compliant, and aimed at organizational improvement is critical to resolving the dilemma effectively.

References

  • Booth, L. (2019). Corporate Governance and Ethical Conduct in Healthcare. Journal of Healthcare Management, 64(2), 123-134.
  • Johnson, P., & Smith, R. (2021). Leadership Ethics and Fraud Prevention in Healthcare Organizations. Healthcare Ethics Review, 33(4), 215-229.
  • Roberts, K., & Williams, M. (2020). Navigating Ethical Challenges in Healthcare Corporations. Journal of Medical Ethics, 46(7), 435-440.
  • Steinberg, R. (2022). Restoring Trust: Ethical Responses to Corporate Fraud. Healthcare Leadership Review, 37(3), 142-149.
  • American College of Healthcare Executives. (2018). Ethical Principles for Healthcare Managers. ACHE Publishing.

Related Assignments