Factors For Investment Decisions In Automated Milling Machin

Factors for Investment Decision in Automated Milling Machine Replacement

Assume that your company is considering the replacement of an automated milling machine with one from three different manufacturers. Each machine has a projected five-year useful life, increased production capacity, and rising working capital needs during the first year. The decision hinges on a net present value (NPV) analysis. The old machine can be sold at its projected salvage value. Various factors influence the calculation of initial investment, operating cash flows, and terminal value, and understanding which factors to include is essential for accurate NPV estimation. Incorrect inclusion or exclusion can lead to overstated or understated project valuation, impacting decision-making.

Factors Used to Determine the Initial Investment

Purchase price of capital asset

Include: Yes. The purchase price constitutes the primary component of the initial investment. Omitting it would underestimate the investment required, leading to an overstated NPV.

Cost of shipping and installing the new equipment

Include: Yes. These costs are necessary to bring the asset into operational condition. Excluding them would understate total initial cash outflows, overstating NPV.

Sale of old machine at salvage value

Include: Yes. The after-sale value provides cash inflow at the project's inception. Not including it would overstate the initial net investment, thus overstating NPV.

Interest on the loan used to finance the asset purchase

Include: No. Interest is a financing expense and is accounted for in financing cash flows, separate from investment analysis. Omitting it from investment calculations prevents double-counting and distortion of project value.

Increase in working capital

Include: Yes. The increased working capital required at project initiation is part of the initial outlay. Ignoring it would underestimate initial costs, thereby overestimating NPV.

Total purchase price of the asset

Include: Yes. This total reflects the purchase expenditure necessary for the asset. Excluding it would underestimate initial capital costs, overstating project value.

Investment tax credit

Include: Yes. The tax credit effectively reduces the initial investment (cash inflow). Failure to include it would result in overstating the initial outlay, thus overstating NPV.

Factors Used to Determine Operating Cash Flow Estimates

Total company sales revenue

Include: Yes. Increased sales due to higher capacity influence operating cash flows. Excluding this would understate revenue and cash flows, undervaluing project worth.

Total annual depreciation expense

Include: No. While depreciation affects net income, it is a non-cash expense and is added back in cash flow calculations. It does not directly affect the cash flows, so it is not included in operating cash flow estimates.

Incremental annual depreciation expense

Include: No. Similar to total depreciation, it impacts net income but is non-cash. For cash flow purposes, depreciation is added back; thus, it is not directly included as a separate cash flow factor.

Cash realized from sale of the old machine at its salvage value

Include: Yes. This cash inflow occurs at project inception and is part of initial investment recovery, but the actual sale proceeds are already reflected in initial cash flows, not incremental operating cash flows.

Decreases in working capital after initial increase

Include: Yes. If the working capital decreases at project end, it constitutes a cash inflow during terminal cash flows, which increases overall cash flow.

Increase in working capital

Include: Yes. The increased working capital needed during the project adds to initial investment and reduces operational cash flows until recovered at project end.

Incremental net income before tax

Include: Yes. The additional earnings attributable to the project influence operating cash flows but must be adjusted for non-cash expenses and taxes to compute cash flows.

Marginal income tax rate

Include: Yes. The tax rate is essential for calculating after-tax cash flows, which are the basis of NPV analysis.

Cost of shipping and installing the new equipment

Include: Yes. These costs are part of the initial investment, affecting cash outflows and consequently the project valuation.

Investment tax credit

Include: Yes. As a reduction of initial investment, failure to include it would lead to overstating project costs and underestimating NPV.

Factors Used to Determine the Terminal Value Estimate

Salvage value of the new machine

Include: Yes. The estimated sale price at the end of five years forms the terminal cash inflow and must be incorporated to accurately assess project value. Not including it would underestimate the terminal cash flow and thus undervalue the project.

Residual value of the machine after five years

Include: Yes. Similar to salvage value, residual value impacts terminal cash flows, influencing the project's overall valuation. Omission would underestimate terminal cash inflows, undervaluing the project.

Decreased working capital at end of project

Include: Yes. The recovery of working capital contributes to terminal cash flows, increasing the project's net present value. Ignoring it would underestimate cash inflows at project termination.

Expected market value of the equipment after 5 years

Include: Yes. This market value impacts the terminal cash flow; excluding it results in an understated project value.

Reinvestment of salvage proceeds

Include: No. While salvage proceeds impact cash flows, reinvestment assumptions are part of project cash flows rather than terminal value estimation directly. Therefore, they are not included in terminal value calculations.

Conclusion

Accurately identifying and including relevant factors in each cash flow category is vital for a valid NPV analysis. Omitting critical items such as purchase price, salvage value, or working capital changes can lead to incorrect project valuation, leading managers to potentially overestimate or underestimate the project's profitability. Proper allocation of factors ensures a fair and comprehensive analysis, supporting sound investment decisions.

References

  • Anthony, R. N., & Govindarajan, V. (2019). Management Control Systems. McGraw-Hill Education.
  • Berk, J., & DeMarzo, P. (2020). Corporate Finance. Pearson.
  • Damodaran, A. (2012). Investment Valuation: Tools and Techniques for Determining the Value of Any Asset. Wiley Finance.
  • Kotler, P., & Keller, K. L. (2016). Marketing Management. Pearson.
  • Ross, S. A., Westerfield, R., & Jaff,ery, J. (2016). Corporate Finance. McGraw-Hill Education.
  • Brigham, E. F., & Ehrhardt, M. C. (2016). Financial Management: Theory & Practice. Cengage Learning.
  • Copeland, T., Weston, J. F., & Shastri, K. (2005). Financial Theory and Corporate Policy. Pearson.
  • Gitman, L. J., & Zutter, C. J. (2015). Principles of Managerial Finance. Pearson.
  • Higgins, R. C. (2012). Analysis for Financial Management. McGraw-Hill Education.
  • Drury, C. (2018). Management and Cost Accounting. Cengage Learning.

Related Assignments