First Look When Analyzing Art, You Should Look For The Vario ✓ Solved

First Look When analyzing art, you should look for the vario

First Look When analyzing art, you should look for the various elements to help determine its structure, meaning, and value. The traditional seven elements are: Line; Shape; Space; Color; Value; Texture.

Use formal vocabulary to describe works of art; two useful references are The John Paul Getty Museum – Elements of Art and Robert J. McKnight Memorial – Alphabet of Art. Without conducting any additional research, select four works from the first half of 20th-century American art from the list below.

For each work: 1) List the artist, date, and title. 2) Write a paragraph discussing the visual elements in the artwork (focus on two or three prominent elements and how they work together). 3) Write a second paragraph describing the subject matter and what the artist may have been trying to say; consider the time frame. Each analysis should be at least 200 words (combined total at least 800 words).

Select from: George Bellows, New York, 1911; Georgia O’Keeffe, The Shelton with Sunspots, N.Y., 1926; Charles Sheeler, American Landscape, 1930; Alexandre Hogue, Erosion No. 2: Earth Mother Laid Bare, 1936; Jacob Lawrence, Migration Series, No. 58, 1940–1941; Willem de Kooning, Woman III, 1951–1953; Jackson Pollock, Convergence, 1952.

Paper For Above Instructions

George Bellows, New York, 1911

Artist, date, title: George Bellows, New York, 1911.

Visual elements

The composition emphasizes bold line and dynamic value contrasts. Bellows uses strong, gestural lines to define the architecture and the human figures, creating a sense of movement and immediacy. Shapes are predominantly angular and geometric in the urban setting, with rigid verticals and diagonals that suggest tall buildings and bustling streets. Color is restrained and naturalistic, with a limited palette that emphasizes grays, browns, and muted blues; this subdued color scheme makes the highlights and deep shadows more dramatic. Value plays a major role: high-contrast areas draw the eye to focal points such as crowds or sunlit facades, while midtones recede into atmospheric depth. Texture is implied through brushwork—some areas are smooth, while others retain painterly marks that convey grit and the tactile sense of the city. Overall, line, value, and shape work together to create a vivid urban impression that feels both solid and energetic (Museum sources discuss Bellows' urban realism and vigorous draftsmanship) (Metropolitan Museum of Art, n.d.).

Subject matter and interpretation

The scene reads as an observational snapshot of early 20th-century New York—crowds, architecture, and the interplay of light and shadow. Bellows likely sought to capture the vitality and sometimes harsh realities of a rapidly modernizing city. Considering the 1911 date, industrialization, migration to urban centers, and changing social dynamics inform this view: the painting might be emphasizing the tension between anonymity and collective urban life. The monumental verticals could represent modern progress and the pressure it exerts on individuals, while the compacted human forms suggest both community and crowding. Without additional research, one can infer Bellows' interest in realism and social observation; the emphasis on strong drawing and stark contrasts implies an intent to convey immediacy and moral or emotional weight within urban modernity (Bellows’ work is often interpreted in art historical sources as urban realism) (MoMA, n.d.).

Georgia O’Keeffe, The Shelton with Sunspots, N.Y., 1926

Artist, date, title: Georgia O’Keeffe, The Shelton with Sunspots, N.Y., 1926.

Visual elements

O’Keeffe’s painting emphasizes simplified geometric shapes and strong, clear color relationships. The building’s planes reduce to large, flat areas—rectangles and trapezoids—that simplify complex architecture into an almost abstract composition. Color is a critical element: warm sunlit tones contrast with cool shadows, and subtle gradients indicate light quality. Line is used sparingly; edges are clean and decisive, reinforcing the sense of simplified form. Space is organized in layered planes, creating a shallow depth that focuses attention on the monumentality of the structure rather than atmospheric recession. Texture is minimal—the surface appears smooth and controlled, which accentuates clarity and purity of form. Together, shape, color, and space create a composed, harmonious image that emphasizes structural form and the effect of light on architecture (O’Keeffe’s modernist simplifications are frequently noted in museum descriptions) (Whitney Museum, n.d.).

Subject matter and interpretation

The work presents a modern skyscraper as an object of contemplation rather than mere city scenery. In the context of the 1920s—an era of urban growth and architectural innovation—O’Keeffe may be exploring how modern structures become new objects of beauty. The “sunspots” draw attention to light’s transformative power and may suggest a transcendence of ordinary urban experience into something more abstract and formal. The reductive approach strips away anecdote to focus on essentials: form, light, and scale. Considering O’Keeffe’s broader practice, this painting likely expresses a fascination with the modern and the monumental, offering a meditative, almost spiritual appreciation of urban geometry rather than a social critique (Art historical treatments often position O’Keeffe’s cityscapes within American modernism) (Museum of Modern Art, n.d.).

Charles Sheeler, American Landscape, 1930

Artist, date, title: Charles Sheeler, American Landscape, 1930.

Visual elements

Sheeler’s work emphasizes precise line, geometric shapes, and controlled value contrasts. The composition is architectonic: machines, factories, or rural-industrial forms reduce to clean planes and repeating geometric motifs. Lines are crisp and mechanical, giving the scene an almost photographic clarity. Color is typically restrained—muted earth tones and cool grays—so that shape and pattern become primary. Space is defined through overlapping planes and careful perspective, producing a clear sense of order and structure. Texture is smooth and refined, consistent with Sheeler’s precisionist aesthetic; surfaces feel polished rather than organic. Line, shape, and space collaborate to convey the ordered beauty of industrial or modernized American landscapes, highlighting form and rhythm over anecdotal detail (Sheeler is a central figure in Precisionism as noted by major museum sources) (Art Institute of Chicago, n.d.).

Subject matter and interpretation

The painting reads as an endorsement of modern industry’s form and discipline. In the context of 1930, amid rapid mechanization and the interwar period, Sheeler’s calm, orderly depiction could celebrate technological progress and the transformed American landscape. Alternatively, the reduction to formal elements may neutralize social or environmental consequences, presenting industry as aestheticized landscape. The work’s clarity and compositional balance suggest an attempt to reconcile nature and machine through visual order—elevating factories or agricultural machinery to the status of national symbols of productivity. Without further research, one can infer Sheeler’s interest in precision, national identity, and the aesthetic possibilities of modern American industry (Precisionism and its themes are widely discussed in museum literature) (Smithsonian American Art Museum, n.d.).

Jacob Lawrence, Migration Series, No. 58, 1940–1941

Artist, date, title: Jacob Lawrence, Migration Series, No. 58, 1940–1941.

Visual elements

Lawrence’s panel uses flat, bold color blocks, simplified shapes, and rhythmic repetition. Figures are rendered in stylized, geometric forms with strong contour lines; there is little modeling, so color and shape define volume. The palette is often earthy and vivid—ochres, blacks, greens, and reds—providing both visual contrast and emotional resonance. Space is shallow and compressed; foreground and background elements flatten into layered planes, which focuses attention on narrative action rather than realistic depth. Texture is minimal, with uniform painted surfaces that emphasize design over illusion. Compositionally, repeated motifs and directional lines guide the viewer through the narrative sequence. These elements—line, color, and shape—work together to create clarity and immediacy, making the story accessible and visually compelling (Lawrence’s narrative style is well-documented in museum accounts) (Phillips Collection, n.d.).

Subject matter and interpretation

The Migration Series narrates the Great Migration of African Americans from the rural South to Northern cities. Panel No. 58 likely captures a specific episode—movement, labor, or adjustment to urban life. Considering the 1940–1941 date, Lawrence addresses social transformation, racial dynamics, and the search for opportunity. His simplified, repetitive visual language underscores collective experience over individual portraiture, suggesting a communal history shaped by hardship and resilience. The flattened figures and vibrant palette dramatize urgency and solidarity, while the sequential format creates historical continuity. Without extra research, one can interpret this panel as part of a larger narrative meant to educate, commemorate, and humanize a major demographic shift in American history (Lawrence’s Migration Series is widely cited as a landmark narrative cycle) (Museum of Modern Art, n.d.).

References

  • The J. Paul Getty Museum. "Elements of Art." Getty.edu. https://www.getty.edu/education/
  • Robert J. McKnight Memorial. "Alphabet of Art." McKnight.org. https://www.mcknight.org/
  • Metropolitan Museum of Art. George Bellows collection entries and essays. https://www.metmuseum.org/
  • Museum of Modern Art (MoMA). Georgia O’Keeffe and Jacob Lawrence artist pages. https://www.moma.org/
  • Art Institute of Chicago. Charles Sheeler and Precisionism resources. https://www.artic.edu/
  • Smithsonian American Art Museum. American modernism and related artist resources. https://americanart.si.edu/
  • Phillips Collection. Jacob Lawrence and Migration Series materials. https://www.phillipscollection.org/
  • Whitney Museum of American Art. Georgia O’Keeffe and American modernism resources. https://whitney.org/
  • Oxford Art Online / Grove Art. Entries on early 20th-century American artists. https://www.oxfordartonline.com/
  • Encyclopaedia Britannica. Artist biographies and historical context pages. https://www.britannica.com/

Related Assignments