Formulate The Expected Financial Returns Of A Company

Formulate the expected financial returns of a company and associated risks by completing the following calculations

Calculate the Return on Equity (ROE) using the DuPont system. ROE evaluates a firm's efficiency in generating profit from its shareholders’ equity. For Morgan Stanley, the last quarter net income was $8,340 million, and shareholders’ equity was $81,965.50 million. The basic ROE calculation is:

ROE = Net Income / Shareholders’ Equity = 8,340 / 81,965.50 ≈ 10.18%

However, ROE alone does not reveal the factors contributing to this efficiency. The DuPont formula decomposes ROE into three components: profitability (margin), asset efficiency (turnover), and leverage (financial leverage). These are defined as:

• Profitability (Margin) = Net Profit / Sales
• Asset Efficiency (Turnover) = Total Sales / Total Assets
• Leverage = Total Assets / Shareholders’ Equity

Using Morgan Stanley’s data from the last quarter, where total sales were $40,896 million, total assets stood at $899,016.50 million, and shareholders’ equity was $81,965.50 million, the calculations are as follows:

Margin = 8,340 / 40,896 ≈ 20.39%

Turnover = 40,896 / 899,016.50 ≈ 0.0455

Leverage = 899,016.50 / 81,965.50 ≈ 10.9682

The DuPont ROE is then:

ROE = Margin × Turnover × Leverage = 20.39% × 0.0455 × 10.9682 ≈ 10.18%

This suggests that Morgan Stanley’s return on shareholders’ equity, while positive, is relatively modest at approximately 10.18%. Compared to the typical acceptable rate of 15%, investors might find this ROI less appealing, indicating room for improvement in profitability or efficiency.

Calculation of the Constant Growth Stock Valuation (CGSV) and Price Comparison

The current stock price of Morgan Stanley is $33.90. The CGSV model estimates the fair value of a stock assuming dividends grow at a constant rate. The formula used is:

P_n = D₁ × (1 + g)ⁿ / (k – g)

Where:

• P_n = Expected stock price after n years
• D₁ = Expected dividend next year
• g = Dividend growth rate (18.20%)
• k = Required rate of return or cost of capital
• n = Number of years

Given the dividend growth rate, g = 0.182, and assuming the current dividend per share D₀ is known, D₁ can be calculated as: D₁ = D₀ × (1 + g). Without the exact dividend value, we typically estimate D₀ based on payout ratios or recent dividend payments. For illustration, if Morgan Stanley’s latest dividend per share is $1.20, then:

D₁ = 1.20 × (1 + 0.182) ≈ 1.417

Assuming the required rate of return, k, is 8% (a common estimate for equity risk), and projecting over n = 5 years, the price estimate becomes:

P₅ = 1.417 × (1 + 0.182)⁵ / (0.08 – 0.182)

Calculations:

• (1 + 0.182)⁵ ≈ 2.331
• Numerator: 1.417 × 2.331 ≈ 3.300
• Denominator: 0.08 – 0.182 = -0.102

Since the denominator is negative, this indicates that the assumed required rate is less than the growth rate, which violates the model’s assumptions and suggests infinite growth or an overestimation of growth rate. Adjusting the rate to a higher value, say 20%, yields a more realistic scenario:

P₅ = 1.417 × 2.331 / (0.20 – 0.182) ≈ 3.300 / 0.018 ≈ 183.33

Therefore, the estimated fair value per share is approximately $183.33—significantly above the current market price of $33.90—implying the stock may be undervalued based on dividend growth assumptions.

Evaluating Capital Constraints and Strategic Considerations

To remain competitive, Morgan Stanley must consider several capital constraints. These include maintaining liquidity, controlling leverage, and ensuring efficient capital allocation. As a leading financial services firm, Morgan Stanley faces unique capital challenges that impact its strategic positioning.

Firstly, the firm needs to continually attract and retain highly skilled personnel, which involves investing in competitive compensation packages and training programs. This human capital is critical for innovation and customer service excellence but increases operational costs. Techniques such as cost-benefit analyses and human resources metrics allow the firm to evaluate the efficiency of these investments.

Secondly, offering a diverse range of products and services requires substantial capital to develop new offerings, expand existing platforms, and acquire new clients. Portfolio diversification strategies, backed by financial modeling and scenario analysis, help Morgan Stanley assess potential risks and returns from diversification initiatives.

Thirdly, geographic diversification introduces both opportunities and constraints. Expansion into emerging markets necessitates an understanding of local regulatory environments, currency fluctuations, and political risks. Techniques like country risk assessments and sensitivity analysis enable Morgan Stanley to evaluate the feasibility of such expansion without jeopardizing financial stability.

Furthermore, optimizing capital allocation is essential. Idle or excess capital reduces returns; therefore, techniques such as capital budgeting, return on invested capital (ROIC), and economic value added (EVA) analyses are used to ensure resources are directed toward high-yield activities.

Lastly, technological innovation plays a pivotal role in maintaining competitiveness. Investing in cutting-edge financial technology, blockchain, and AI-driven analytics can provide efficiency gains and cost reductions. Cost-effective investment evaluation methods, like discounted cash flow (DCF) analysis and real options analysis, assist in assessing these technological investments’ potential value.

Conclusion

In summary, Morgan Stanley’s financial performance analysis reveals a modest ROE when decomposed through the DuPont system, indicating potential areas for operational improvement. Its stock valuation, based on dividend growth models, suggests substantial undervaluation, providing an opportunity for investors. To sustain competitiveness, Morgan Stanley must address capital constraints like talent acquisition, product diversification, geographic expansion, and technological advancement through strategic financial management techniques. These efforts will enable the firm to adapt to evolving market dynamics and maintain a competitive edge in the financial services industry.

References

• Investing.com. (2020). Morgan Stanley (MS) income statement.
• Morgan Stanley. (2019). Sustainable investing’s competitive advantages.
• Morgan Stanley. (2020). Strategies.
• Yahoo. (2020). Morgan Stanley (MS).
• Brigham, E. F., & Houston, J. F. (2019). Fundamentals of financial management. Cengage Learning.
• Damodaran, A. (2012). Investment valuation: Tools and techniques for determining the value of any asset. John Wiley & Sons.
• Ross, S. A., Westerfield, R. W., & Jaffe, J. (2019). Corporate finance. McGraw-Hill Education.
• Graham, J. R., & Harvey, C. R. (2001). The theory and practice of corporate finance: Evidence from the field. Journal of Financial Economics, 60(2-3), 187-243.
• Brealey, R. A., Myers, S. C., & Allen, F. (2020). Principles of corporate finance. McGraw-Hill Education.
• Damodaran, A. (2015). Narrative and numbers: The value of stories in business. Columbia University Press.