HS450 Unit 8 Assignment: Ethics And Decision Making In VA

Hs450 Unit 8 Assignmentethics And Decision Making In The Va Healthca

Analyze the ethical decision-making practices and leadership issues related to the problems at the VA healthcare system, including the failure to maintain ethical standards in patient wait lists. Discuss the ethical implications of having unlisted veterans waiting for care, identify policies/standards to improve coordination and transparency, explain Secretary Shinseki's resignation, suggest alternative actions he could have taken, and apply the American College of Healthcare Executives (ACHE) Code of Ethics to this case study.

Paper For Above instruction

The ethical landscape of healthcare governance is fundamentally rooted in principles of integrity, accountability, transparency, and respect for patient rights. In the context of the Veterans Affairs (VA) healthcare system, ethical decision-making is critical to ensuring trust, safety, and quality of care for veterans who have served the nation. The problems at the VA, particularly the manipulative practices surrounding patient wait times and the existence of secret wait lists, reflect significant ethical failures and leadership deficiencies that undermine the core values of healthcare professionalism.

Leadership plays a pivotal role in setting ethical standards and fostering an organizational culture grounded in integrity. The VA crisis illustrates a breakdown in ethical decision-making at multiple levels, where leadership either failed to recognize or choose to ignore systemic issues that jeopardized patient safety. Ethical leadership requires transparency in reporting problems, accountability for corrective actions, and a commitment to patient welfare. When leadership at the VA system manipulated or concealed wait list information to meet performance targets, it exhibited a violation of fundamental ethical principles, including honesty and beneficence.

The specific case of 1,700 veterans waiting for appointments but not listed on the Electronic Wait List (EWL) exemplifies an ethical breach. It demonstrates a disregard for the dignity and rights of veterans, as their health needs were not accurately documented or prioritized, potentially leading to adverse health outcomes or deaths. Concealing or manipulating data to meet administrative targets compromises the trustworthiness and integrity of the healthcare system. Such actions violate the principle of fidelity, which obligates healthcare providers and leaders to be truthful and transparent with patients and stakeholders.

To address these ethical lapses, organizations must implement policies that promote transparency, accuracy, and accountability. First, a policy mandating regular, independent audits of patient wait lists and appointment scheduling practices would be essential. These audits should be aimed at verifying the accuracy of the data and uncovering any discrepancies or manipulations. Second, establishing an ethics oversight committee within the VA that reports directly to top leadership and is empowered to investigate complaints and systemic issues would foster a culture of integrity. This committee would oversee compliance with ethical standards and provide guidance to leaders and staff on ethical decision-making.

Secretary Eric Shinseki resigned his position in 2014 following revelations of systemic misconduct, including manipulated wait times. His resignation was driven by a loss of public and political confidence in his leadership capacity, and by the moral obligation to accept responsibility for organizational failures. However, alternative avenues could have been taken to address these issues proactively. One option would have been for Secretary Shinseki to initiate a comprehensive internal investigation upon discovering early signs of malpractice, rather than waiting for external revelations. Implementing immediate corrective measures, such as personnel accountability, enhanced oversight, and transparency initiatives, might have mitigated the deterioration of trust and prevented the need for resignation.

Another alternative would have been the appointment of an independent commission or ethics panel to evaluate and reform scheduling practices across the VA system. Such a step would demonstrate a commitment to ethical standards and accountability, potentially restoring confidence and ensuring systemic reforms. Incorporating ethical frameworks, such as the American College of Healthcare Executives (ACHE) Code of Ethics, provides guidance for ethical leadership in healthcare organizations. The ACHE emphasizes principles of competency, integrity, confidentiality, honesty, and respect for human dignity. Applying these principles to the VA case underscores the importance of truthful communication, accountability, and prioritizing veterans’ health and welfare over administrative convenience or political considerations.

In conclusion, the VA healthcare crisis highlights critical ethical failures rooted in leadership misconduct, misaligned incentives, and systemic neglect of transparency and accountability. Ethical decision-making requires leaders to prioritize the welfare of patients, uphold honesty, and foster a culture of integrity. Implementing policies such as independent audits and ethics oversight, along with embracing ethical standards like those promoted by the ACHE, can guide organizations toward accountability and improved patient outcomes. Ethical leadership is essential for restoring trust and ensuring that healthcare systems serve their intended purpose—delivering high-quality, equitable, and trustworthy care to those who have served the nation.

References

  • Brennan, T., & McGinn, T. (2019). Ethical leadership in healthcare: Historical perspectives and contemporary challenges. Journal of Healthcare Ethics, 35(2), 320-330.
  • President’s Commission on Ethical Standards in Health Care. (2012). Ethical standards in healthcare provision: Building trust and accountability. U.S. Government Printing Office.
  • United States Department of Veterans Affairs. (2014). Office of Inspector General Report on VA Wait Times. VA.gov.
  • Kaplan, B., & Nicholson, S. (2018). Organizational ethics and health system reform. Health Policy Journal, 122(4), 455-461.
  • American College of Healthcare Executives. (2020). Code of Ethics. ACHE.org.
  • Shinseki, E. (2014). Resignation letter following VA wait time scandal. VA Official Statement.
  • Marquis, B. L., & Huston, C. J. (2021). Leadership roles and management functions in healthcare (10th ed.). Elsevier.
  • Institute of Medicine. (2001). Crossing the Quality Chasm: A New Health System for the 21st Century. The National Academies Press.
  • Whelan, D. L. (2017). Ethical dilemmas in healthcare management. Health Management Journal, 33(1), 12-20.
  • National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine. (2016). Strategies for Improving Public Trust in Healthcare Systems. The National Academies Press.

Related Assignments