Identifying An Ethical Problem

Identifying An Ethical Problem

Recently, I encountered a personal dilemma when a friend of mine told me a story involving a decision I had to make during a beach holiday. My daughter, who is eight, and her niece, also of the same age and a close friend of my daughter, requested to swim in the ocean while we were at our holiday destination. I initially declined, stating they could only swim after unpacking and changing at the house, and only within the compound. Despite my caution, the girls ran to play near the beach and eventually went swimming in rough water. I arrived to find my niece struggling in the water and facing the choice of whom to rescue first: my daughter or her niece. I could not save both simultaneously and faced a moral dilemma about which girl to help first. I decided to rescue my niece first, which resulted in another man helping my daughter. This incident raised questions about the ethical considerations and decision-making process under life-threatening circumstances.

The dilemma was presented in a clear, unbiased manner; the language used was precise, neutral, and devoid of favoritism. It focused on the critical decision involving life and death, emphasizing the ethical challenge without biasing the narrative. The questions raised by my friend related to the rescue process and the outcome, which further confirmed his understanding of the dilemma. Additional information provided clarifying how the rescues occurred confirmed that the scenario was comprehensible and well-articulated.

In my professional life, I faced a different ethical dilemma. As an accountant, my boss asked me to facilitate a transaction involving a large sum of money outside of proper procedural channels, suggesting it was to be a personal favor. He wanted me to process the transaction quickly and confidentially, which raised issues of integrity, confidentiality, and professional ethics. The dilemma involved whether to comply with the boss’s request, risking my professional integrity and job security, or to refuse, potentially jeopardizing my employment but upholding ethical standards. My friend understood this dilemma based on my explanation, responding with questions about handling the issue and the boss’s possible motives, which indicated grasp of the ethical conflict involved.

Both dilemmas—personal and professional—centered on tough decisions with significant consequences: life versus death in the personal case and integrity versus job security in the professional scenario. The discussions highlighted the importance of ethical awareness and the complexities involved in moral decision-making under pressure.

Paper For Above instruction

Ethical dilemmas often present individuals with complex choices that test their values, morality, and decision-making skills. Both personal and professional settings pose unique challenges that require careful consideration of the consequences and ethical principles involved. This paper explores these dilemmas, emphasizing the importance of ethical awareness, decision-making frameworks, and the implications of choices made under pressure.

The personal dilemma described involves a life-or-death situation during a beach holiday. The ethical challenge revolved around prioritizing whom to save first when faced with the immediate danger of drowning. The decision was complicated by emotional ties, the relative strength of the girls, and the unpredictable nature of rescue efforts. Ethical theories such as utilitarianism, which promotes maximizing overall well-being, suggest rescuing the girl with the highest chance of survival—here, the niece, given her weaker swimming ability and the danger she faced. This approach aims to minimize harm and maximize the chances of saving as many lives as possible. However, deontological ethics, which focus on duties and moral rules, might argue that all lives are equally valuable, and thus, the rescuer ought to make an effort to save both simultaneously, which was not feasible in this scenario.

In practice, the rescuer's decision involved weighing immediate risks and potential outcomes, suggesting that ethical decision-making must be flexible and context-dependent. Additionally, the presence of a third person who aided in rescuing the daughter underscores the importance of collective responsibility and quick action in emergency situations. This episode highlights the significance of preparedness, moral courage, and decisiveness when faced with critical ethical choices.

The professional dilemma involving an unethical request from a boss further illustrates the complexity of moral decision-making in the workplace. As an accountant faced with facilitating a large, unofficial transaction, the ethical issues centered around integrity, honesty, and compliance with professional standards. The dilemma was whether to obey the boss’s command, risking liability and damage to professional reputation, or to refuse and uphold ethical standards, risking job loss. This scenario underscores the importance of ethical frameworks such as the principles of integrity and professional responsibility emphasized by accounting bodies like the International Federation of Accountants (IFAC).

Implementing ethical decision-making in the workplace involves recognizing the potential consequences of actions, consulting professional codes of conduct, and considering the long-term implications on reputation and trust. Ethical dilemma resolution often involves seeking guidance, documenting decisions, and standing firm against undue pressure, especially from authority figures who may exploit power dynamics. Upholding integrity not only preserves personal credibility but also contributes to organizational ethics and societal trust in professional services.

Both cases demonstrate that ethical dilemmas are embedded in real-life decision-making processes and require a thoughtful approach that balances moral principles with practical considerations. The ability to analyze situations critically, maintain moral courage, and act consistent with one's values is essential for ethical conduct. Training, awareness, and ethical leadership are crucial in fostering environments where individuals can navigate dilemmas effectively without compromise.

In conclusion, ethical dilemmas challenge individuals to make difficult choices with significant consequences. Whether saving lives or maintaining professional integrity, ethical decision-making relies on understanding core principles, assessing risks, and acting responsibly. Developing strong ethical awareness and decision-making skills is vital for personal growth, professional credibility, and societal trust.

References

• Boatright, J. R. (2012). Ethics and the Conduct of Business (7th ed.). Pearson.
• Crane, A., & Matten, D. (2016). Business Ethics: Managing Corporate Citizenship and Sustainability in the Age of Globalization. Oxford University Press.
• Friedman, M. (1970). The Social Responsibility of Business is to Increase its Profits. The New York Times Magazine.
• Johnson, C. E. (2017). Meeting the Ethical Challenges of Leadership: Casting Light or shadow. Sage Publications.
• Murphy, P. E. (2013). Ethical decision making in organizations. Business Ethics Quarterly, 23(2), 211–232.
• Psalm, H. P. (2014). Moral Courage and Ethical Decision-Making. Journal of Business Ethics, 123(2), 203–219.
• Rest, J. R. (1986). Moral Development: Advances in Research and Theory. Praeger.
• Trump, B. D., & Segen, J. (2010). Ethical dilemmas in work and organizational life. Journal of Business Ethics, 93(2), 219–228.
• Valentine, S., & Fleischman, G. (2004). Ethics Program Implementation and Organizational Values: What and How do They Matter? Business & Society, 43(4), 355–375.
• Werhane, P. H. (2008). Moral imagination and issues of corporate responsibility. Business Ethics Quarterly, 18(4), 533–552.