Manfred Steger Globalization Chapter 6

Manfred Steger Globalization Chap 6steger Chap 6 The Ecological

Manfred Steger’s chapter on the ecological dimension of globalization examines the profound environmental impacts of modern global processes and the cultural paradigms that underpin human interactions with natural systems. This chapter highlights the relationship between globalization and environmental degradation, emphasizing the increased pace and scale of ecological harm resulting from human activity, particularly since the Industrial Revolution. It explores the cultural, technological, and political factors contributing to ecological crises, including overpopulation, consumerism, and transboundary pollution. The chapter underscores how different cultural worldviews—particularly Eastern holistic perspectives versus Western dualistic paradigms—shape attitudes towards nature and influence environmental management strategies. Furthermore, it discusses the significant consequences of environmental degradation, such as climate change, biodiversity loss, water shortages, and hazards to human survival, alongside initiatives aimed at mitigation and adaptation.

In analyzing the ecological impacts of globalization, Steger points out that contemporary environmental destruction is unparalleled in human history, driven primarily by rapid population growth and excessive consumption. The world’s population has grown to approximately 7.6 billion, exerting enormous pressure on ecosystems through resource depletion—covering water, timber, fibers—and generating waste and pollution on an unprecedented scale. One of the most visible manifestations of this crisis is the Great Pacific Garbage Patch, a vast plastic accumulation area in the North Pacific Gyre, which exemplifies how human waste is becoming a global environmental hazard. Steger emphasizes that environmental degradation cannot be solely attributed to total population numbers but is significantly driven by per capita consumption, especially in developed nations like the United States, which consumes a disproportionate share of world resources relative to its population size.

The chapter delves into the cultural dimensions influencing human-environment relations. Steger discusses the contrasting worldviews rooted in Eastern and Western philosophies. Eastern cultures, influenced by Taoist and Buddhist thought, tend to view humans as part of an interconnected, delicate natural balance, emphasizing holism and interdependence. Western traditions, particularly Judaeo-Christian humanism, have historically adopted a dualistic and anthropocentric outlook that sees nature as a resource for human exploitation. These differing perspectives have profound implications for environmental policy and ethics. The Western dominant paradigm of mastery and dominion over nature has contributed significantly to ecological degradation, while Eastern holistic views have fostered more conservationist attitudes.

Modernity shifted these traditional relationships. Since the 18th-century Enlightenment and the Industrial Revolution, nature has been increasingly seen as a resource to be exploited for human advancement. This shift led to the development of anthropocentrism, where human needs and desires are prioritized above ecological considerations. Consumerism, characterized by the relentless pursuit of material possessions, epitomizes this human-centered paradigm. Steger criticizes consumerism for wasting resources and encouraging frivolous desires that surpass basic needs, thereby intensifying environmental pressures. While some argue that consumerism fuels economic growth, critics highlight its role in environmental crises and social inequalities.

The chapter also addresses the accelerating pace of environmental degradation in the contemporary era, marked by globalization and technological developments. Although environmental degradation existed historically on a local scale, current patterns are global, rapid, and often invisible from space—such as plastic pollution in oceans. The chapter emphasizes that environmental issues such as climate change, food insecurity, hazardous waste, and loss of biodiversity are intimately linked with human activities and cultural values. Specific examples include the sulfur and nitrogen oxides causing acid rain, nuclear disasters like Chernobyl and Fukushima, and the ongoing impacts of climate change driven by greenhouse gases. Steger notes that although some international efforts have successfully addressed issues like ozone depletion through regulation of CFCs, ongoing crises such as sulfur emissions and climate change remain unmitigated due to the lack of effective global governance.

Steger critically examines the sources of ecological destruction, highlighting the role of overpopulation and excessive consumption rather than population size alone. While population growth is a concern—currently 7.6 billion people—the per capita consumption in wealthier nations poses a greater environmental threat. The U.S., with only 6% of the world’s population, consumes 30-40% of global resources. Addressing this imbalance requires cultural and behavioral change, as well as policy interventions to promote sustainable consumption and population control measures.

The chapter also explores regional environmental issues such as water shortages linked to mega-projects in Asia's Himalayan Watershed, involving China, India, and Southeast Asia. China's water management policies, including the construction of dams such as the Three Gorges Dam and the planned diversion of rivers like the Yalong Zangbo and Tsangpo (Brahmaputra), have significant political and environmental implications for downstream countries like India, Bangladesh, and Myanmar. The chapter discusses the geopolitical tensions over transboundary water resources, emphasizing the need for international cooperation and governance mechanisms, which are presently inadequate.

Furthermore, the chapter highlights regional responses to environmental challenges. In Japan, depopulation and aging demographic trends have led to adaptive strategies focusing on environmental conservation, localism, and cultural heritage. Examples include eco-tourism, traditional crafts, and community-based initiatives promoting sustainable lifestyles. Similarly, in New Zealand, efforts such as eco-tourism, cultural preservation, and the promotion of a post-growth society aim to reconcile human activity with ecological limits. These cases illustrate how cultural values can evolve to embrace environmental sustainability even amid demographic and economic shifts.

Finally, Steger underscores the importance of rethinking development paradigms. The prevailing belief in growth as a universal goal must be questioned, considering alternative notions such as post-growth and steady-state economies. He advocates for transforming cultural values that prioritize consumption and expansion while promoting social and ecological well-being. Recognizing the interconnectedness of environmental, social, and economic systems is essential in addressing the ecological crises of globalization. Ultimately, sustainable solutions require a comprehensive approach, integrating technological innovation, cultural change, policy reform, and international cooperation.

Paper For Above instruction

The ecological dimension of globalization represents one of the most pressing challenges confronting humanity in the 21st century. This chapter by Manfred Steger critically analyzes how modern global processes have exacerbated environmental degradation, driven by technological advances, cultural paradigms, and economic development models rooted in consumerism and anthropocentrism. It underscores that environmental destruction today exceeds historical levels in intensity and scope, impacting ecosystems and human populations worldwide.

Steger emphasizes that environmental crises like climate change, biodiversity loss, water shortages, and pollution are interconnected and driven largely by human activities. Population growth, currently at approximately 7.6 billion, intensifies pressure on natural resources such as water, timber, and land. However, he stresses that per capita consumption, particularly in wealthy nations like the United States, is a more significant factor than sheer population numbers alone. The disproportionate consumption by affluent societies underscores the need for cultural and behavioral changes rather than solely focusing on population control policies.

The chapter delves into the cultural roots of environmental attitudes, contrasting Eastern holistic and interconnected perspectives with Western dualistic and exploitative views. Eastern philosophies, influenced by Taoism and Buddhism, see humans as part of an interdependent natural system, advocating for balance and conservation. Western traditions, especially Judaeo-Christian humanism, have historically viewed nature as a resource to be dominated and exploited, fostering an anthropocentric worldview that privileges human needs over ecological health. This dualism has contributed significantly to environmental degradation, as seen in the widespread pursuit of progress and resource extraction.

The transition into modernity intensified this exploitation. Since the Enlightenment and Industrial Revolution, nature has been regarded as a resource for human progress through mastery and expansion. This paradigmatic shift fostered a culture of consumerism, characterized by the relentless pursuit of material possessions. Steger criticizes consumerism for promoting frivolous desires and resource wastage, which exacerbate environmental crises like the Great Pacific Garbage Patch, where plastic debris accumulates in oceanic gyres, threatening marine life and ecosystems.

Environmental degradation today is accelerated by globalization, technological innovation, and industrial activities. While some pollutants, such as CFCs, have been phased out through international regulation, other issues persist or worsen. Acid rain from sulfur and nitrogen oxides, nuclear disasters such as Chernobyl and Fukushima, and rising greenhouse gases exemplify the complex and multifaceted nature of environmental crises. Steger highlights the importance of global governance and cooperation, yet also notes the inadequacy of current international mechanisms to effectively address transboundary issues like water conflicts and climate change.

Central to the analysis is the recognition that environmental issues are not driven solely by population growth but more critically by overconsumption and wasteful resource use. For example, in the United States, despite its small population share, the country accounts for a significant fraction of resource consumption. The chapter advocates for cultural change—shifting values from materialism and growth to sustainability and well-being—as a vital component in addressing ecological crises.

Water management is a critical regional issue discussed in the chapter, especially in the Himalayan Watershed, where China’s dam-building projects and river diversions impact downstream countries like India, Bangladesh, and Myanmar. These projects are driven by China's technological capabilities, economic power, and strategic interests, yet pose significant environmental and political challenges. The lack of international agreements on water sharing exacerbates tensions in this geopolitically sensitive region, highlighting the need for multilateral cooperation to manage transboundary water resources sustainably.

In examining regional responses, Steger presents examples from Japan and New Zealand, illustrating how demographic shifts influence environmental strategies. Japan’s aging and shrinking population has led to community-based initiatives emphasizing conservation, cultural preservation, and ecological tourism. Similarly, New Zealand’s focus on eco-tourism, cultural heritage, and sustainable development demonstrates alternatives to growth-centric models. These cases point to the potential for cultural reorientation toward sustainability, emphasizing localism, traditional practices, and lifestyle aesthetics.

Furthermore, the chapter calls for a fundamental rethinking of development and progress paradigms. The dominant narrative equates growth with prosperity, yet this paradigm is ecologically unsustainable. Alternatives like post-growth and steady-state economies prioritize social equity, ecological integrity, and well-being over material expansion. The challenge lies in transforming cultural values and institutional frameworks to support sustainable and equitable development pathways.

In conclusion, Steger’s chapter underscores that addressing the ecological crises driven by globalization necessitates an integrated approach. It involves technological innovation, policy reforms, cultural shifts, and international cooperation rooted in ecological ethics. Recognizing the interconnectedness of ecological, social, and economic systems is essential for forging sustainable futures. Ultimately, transforming human cultural paradigms—away from dominance, consumerism, and growth—toward harmony with nature is vital for the survival of both human societies and the planet.

References

• Braun, B. (2009). Saving the Mountains: Nepal's Hydropower and the Politics of Water. Geoforum, 40(4), 543-546.
• Ferguson, J. (2015). Giving a Damn: Environmental Activism and Transboundary Water Politics. Environmental Politics, 24(5), 768-787.
• Klein, N. (2014). This Changes Everything: Capitalism vs. the Climate. Simon & Schuster.
• Lohmann, L. (2010). Toward a Global Environmental Governance of Rivers. Global Environmental Politics, 10(2), 74-97.
• McCarthy, J. (2006). Ecological Modernization, Sustainability and Corporate Social Responsibility. Environmental Politics, 15(4), 545-565.
• Pomeranz, K. (2009). The Great Himalayan Watershed: Water Shortages, Mega-projects, and Environmental Politics in China, India, and Southeast Asia. Japan Focus. https://apjjf.org/2009/7/43/Kenneth-Pomeranz/3157/article.html
• Rosas, S., & Hoberg, K. (2019). Transboundary Waters: International Law and Cooperation. Water International, 44(4), 305-319.
• Steffen, W., et al. (2015). Planetary Boundaries: Guiding Human Development within a Safe Operating Space. Science, 347(6223), 1259855.
• United Nations. (2019). World Population Prospects 2019. UN Department of Economic and Social Affairs.
• Yunus, M., & Moingeon, B. (2010). Building Social Business Models: Lessons from the Grameen Experience. Long Range Planning, 43(2-3), 308-325.