Module 02 Case Study: Pay And Gender For This Assignment

Module 02 Case Study Pay And Genderfor This Assignment You

Read the case study of Sarah Green and provide a two-part response to the VP of HR. Part One: Read and analyze the scenario below.

Write a report to the VP of HR summarizing the case and providing a clear argument that an EEOC act was violated. State which act applies to the case. Part Two: Prepare an outline of a training session for hiring managers and for the pay and benefits specialists to prevent a repeat of the situation in the scenario.

Paper For Above instruction

The case of Sarah Green underscores significant issues related to pay discrimination based on gender, highlighting the importance of compliance with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) regulations. As the new Compliance Representative in the HR Department, my task is to analyze Sarah's situation, identify the relevant EEOC violations, and propose solutions to ensure organizational compliance and prevent similar incidents.

Part One: Summary and Analysis of Sarah Green’s Case

Sarah Green, an experienced accountant with a robust professional history, relocated to a new city to care for her ailing mother and secured a position at Parker and Mendez Accounting, LLC. Despite her proven track record, she discovered that her salary was lower than that of her colleagues with comparable or even less experience. Upon inquiry, she learned that the organization's policy on starting pay was based on previous salary history, which perpetuated existing biases, especially since her previous employer had a history of paying women less than men with similar or more credentials.

The issue at hand highlights a violation of the Equal Pay Act (EPA), a federal law under the EEOC that prohibits pay discrimination based on sex when employees perform substantially equal work in the same establishment. The practice of basing starting salaries on prior pay history is a common method that unintentionally propagates gender-based wage disparities when previous employers have engaged in discriminatory pay practices. In Sarah's case, her previous employer’s discriminatory pay practices impacted her current compensation, violating her rights under the EPA.

The organization has a legal obligation to ensure fair pay practices and to provide equal pay for equal work, regardless of gender. Ethically, the company must promote equity and address pay disparities transparently. As a corrective measure, the organization should recognize Sarah's disparity and adjust her salary to align with her qualifications and performance, ensuring she receives equitable compensation.

Furthermore, the organization should revisit its compensation policies to eliminate reliance on prior pay history as a primary determining factor. Instead, starting pay should be based on objective criteria such as experience, skills, and industry standards. Additionally, establishing clear guidelines for pay assessments will help prevent future violations and foster an inclusive and fair work environment.

Part Two: Training Session Outline for Hiring Managers and Benefits/Payroll Specialists

Introduction: The training aims to educate hiring managers and payroll specialists on equitable pay practices that comply with EEOC regulations, emphasizing gender discrimination prevention and promoting fair compensation practices within the organization. The program will equip participants with knowledge and strategies to prevent pay disparities rooted in discriminatory practices.

Scope: The focus is broad, covering legal compliance, ethical standards, and practical application of fair pay practices during hiring, salary determination, and benefits administration. It emphasizes proactive measures to identify and mitigate bias in compensation decisions.

Objectives:

  • To understand the legal framework surrounding equal pay and anti-discrimination laws, specifically the EEOC and the Equal Pay Act.
  • To identify common sources of pay disparity and learn practical methods to assess and rectify potential biases.
  • To develop skills in conducting fair and unbiased salary negotiations and evaluations.
  • To implement organizational policies that promote transparency and fairness in pay and hiring practices.
  • To recognize and prevent unconscious bias affecting compensation decisions.

Training Method: The session will be conducted as a blended learning program, combining synchronous online workshops with asynchronous e-learning modules. Interactive activities, case studies, and role-playing scenarios will be incorporated to enhance engagement and practical understanding. Participants will also complete pre- and post-training assessments to gauge learning outcomes.

Evaluation Using Kirkpatrick’s Levels:

  • Level 1—Reaction: Collect feedback through surveys immediately after training to assess participant engagement and perceived relevance.
  • Level 2—Learning: Use pre- and post-tests to measure knowledge acquisition regarding EEOC laws and fair pay practices.
  • Level 3—Behavior: Monitor implementation of fair pay policies through supervisor observations and payroll audits over subsequent months.
  • Level 4—Results: Evaluate the impact on organizational pay equity, reduced wage disparities, and improved employee satisfaction through periodic audits and surveys.

Conclusion

Implementing comprehensive training for hiring managers and payroll specialists, coupled with policy revisions, will foster a fairer, legally compliant compensation environment. Addressing pay disparities proactively not only mitigates legal risks but also promotes organizational integrity and employee trust. Continuous evaluation and refinement of pay practices are essential for sustaining compliance and ensuring equitable treatment for all employees.

References

  • Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. (2020). Enforcement Guidance on Discrimination Because of Sex. EEOC.
  • U.S. Equal Pay Act of 1963, 29 U.S.C. § 206(d).
  • Corbett, M. (2017). Closing the Pay Gap: Strategies for Equal Pay. Journal of Human Resources, 54(4), 123-135.
  • Smith, J. (2019). Legal and Ethical Perspectives on Pay Equity. Labor Law Journal, 70(2), 58-70.
  • Wright, R. (2021). The Impact of Unconscious Bias on Salary Negotiation. Harvard Business Review.
  • National Women's Law Center. (2018). The State of Pay Equity in America. NWLC Reports.
  • Ferguson, G., & Lee, T. (2020). Fair Pay Policies: Implementation and Outcomes. Human Resource Management Review, 30(3), 100710.
  • Society for Human Resource Management. (2019). Best Practices in Compensation Management. SHRM Resources.
  • U.S. Department of Labor. (2021). Pay Equity and Discrimination. Wage and Hour Division.
  • Cohen, M. (2018). Organizational Strategies for Eliminating Pay Gaps. Administrative Science Quarterly, 63(1), 45-68.

Related Assignments