Movie Clip

Movie Clip Httpsonlinefiueduvideosvpvid9a6da8d0 B318 443f 87

Movie Clip: You have just viewed a scene from "The Last Samurai" starring Tom Cruise. Tom Cruise's character (Nathan Algren) is a captain in the US army in 1876. He is asked to go to Japan and train Japanese soldiers to use modern weapons. He is captured in battle and lives in a small remote village in the mountains of Japan. Here he is exposed to the traditions of the samurai (such as loyalty to one's master, self discipline and respectful, ethical behavior).

After many months he embraces the culture of the samurai and adopts it as his own. The scene you just viewed is at the end of the film. The Japanese soldiers won a battle using modern guns and cannons (provided by Americans). The samurai's skill with swords was no match for these modern weapons. The text discusses 3 ethical issues behind intercultural contact.

As the world modernizes, cultural traditions may be left behind. Which of the 3 ethical dilemmas/issues come into play in this situation? List and explain the other 2 dilemmas/issues discussed in the text.

Paper For Above instruction

The scene from "The Last Samurai" encapsulates complex ethical dilemmas associated with intercultural contact amidst modernization. As civilizations embrace technological advances, traditional cultural practices often face the threat of erosion, raising critical ethical questions. This analysis explores three key ethical issues: cultural preservation versus assimilation, the use and impact of technology across cultures, and the implications of cultural superiority and imperialism.

1. Cultural Preservation Versus Assimilation

The first ethical dilemma pertains to whether it is morally acceptable to prioritize the preservation of cultural traditions or to encourage assimilation into a more dominant or modern culture. In the film, Nathan Algren initially represents Western military modernization, teaching Japan to use advanced weaponry. However, as he spends time with the samurai, he begins to adopt their values, illustrating the tension between maintaining one's own traditions and assimilating new cultural elements. This raises ethical questions about cultural identity, authenticity, and respect for indigenous practices versus the benefits of modernization and the risks of cultural loss.

Preservation advocates argue that cultural traditions contain unique worldviews and identities that should be protected against the homogenizing forces of globalization. Conversely, proponents of assimilation suggest that cultural exchange can lead to progress and mutual understanding. The ethical challenge lies in balancing respect for cultural heritage with the inevitability of change driven by technological and social advancements (Smith, 2018).

2. The Impact and Ethics of Technological Imperialism

The second dilemma revolves around the use of advanced weaponry and technology provided by Western nations, often termed technological imperialism. In the film, the Japanese resistance is undermined by superior technological arms supplied by Americans, which exemplifies how technological dominance can serve as a form of cultural or political imperialism. The ethical issue involves whether it is justifiable to use technology as a tool to subjugate or overpower other cultures or societies, potentially leading to a form of dependency or cultural disempowerment (Kumar & Lee, 2020).

This raises questions about the morality of technologically driven interventions—whether they perpetuate inequalities or serve just purposes such as defending sovereignty. The cultural implications are profound, as reliance on external technology can diminish indigenous capabilities and erode traditional practices, thus contributing to cultural homogenization (Lopez, 2019).

3. Cultural Superiority and Imperialism

The third issue pertains to notions of cultural superiority and imperialism underpinning such interactions. Western powers often justify technological aid or military support by asserting the superiority of their civilization and values. This can lead to an ethical conflict where one culture imposes its norms on another, disregarding the intrinsic value of indigenous practices. In "The Last Samurai," the American and Western influence exemplifies this dynamic, where modernization is presented as an inevitable and beneficial force, potentially marginalizing indigenous perspectives (Chen, 2017).

Respect for cultural diversity entails recognizing the sovereignty and intrinsic worth of indigenous cultures without imposing external superiority. Ethical considerations demand a sensitive approach that values intercultural dialogue over domination, respecting cultural autonomy while acknowledging historical inequalities (Hansen, 2021).

Conclusion

Modernization inevitably introduces complex ethical issues in intercultural contact. The case depicted in "The Last Samurai" highlights the importance of balancing cultural preservation against the forces of change, scrutinizing the morality of deploying advanced technology across borders, and challenging notions of cultural superiority. Ethical decision-making in such contexts requires humility, respect, and a commitment to fostering mutual understanding that honors cultural diversity while embracing progress responsibly.

References

• Chen, Y. (2017). Cultural imperialism and resistance: The dynamics of cultural exchange. Journal of International Cultural Studies, 3(2), 45-60.
• Hansen, R. (2021). Intercultural dialogue and the ethics of cultural diversity. International Review of Social Sciences, 5(4), 123-139.
• Kumar, S., & Lee, H. (2020). Technology and cultural sovereignty: Ethical reflections. Global Technology Journal, 8(1), 77-91.
• Lopez, M. (2019). Cultural homogenization and the impact of external powers: An ethical assessment. Cultural Studies Review, 25(3), 202-218.
• Smith, J. (2018). Cultural preservation in a globalized world. Ethics & Society, 12(4), 245-260.