PBS LearningMedia Florida: Print Resources ✓ Solved

7132018 Pbs Learningmediahttpsfloridapbslearningmediaorgprint

Read the provided biography of Booker T. Washington and W. E. B. Du Bois, focusing on their backgrounds, philosophies, contributions, and the historical context of their leadership in African American history. Analyze how their differing approaches influenced the progress of civil rights and racial equality in the United States. Consider Washington's emphasis on vocational education and accommodation to white supremacy versus Du Bois's advocacy for higher education, intellectual activism, and protest. Discuss the impact of their legacies on subsequent civil rights movements and the ongoing dialogue about race and equality in America.

Sample Paper For Above instruction

The history of African American leadership in the late 19th and early 20th centuries is profoundly characterized by the contrasting philosophies of Booker T. Washington and W. E. B. Du Bois, two towering figures whose approaches to racial uplift significantly shaped the trajectory of civil rights in the United States. Their differing strategies reflected broader tensions within the African American community regarding how best to combat the pervasive racism and discrimination prevalent during the post-Reconstruction era.

Booker T. Washington’s background as a former slave who rose to become an influential educator exemplified his pragmatic approach to racial progress. Born on a Virginia plantation, Washington’s early life was marked by hardship and hard labor. His pursuit of education at Hampton Institute and his subsequent leadership at the Tuskegee Institute underscored his commitment to vocational training and manual skills as a pathway for African Americans to achieve economic self-sufficiency and societal respectability. Washington believed that patience, hard work, and accommodation to segregationist policies would gradually improve the position of African Americans, a philosophy encapsulated in his famous 1895 Atlanta Address, often called the "Atlanta Compromise." In this speech, Washington urged Black Americans to accept segregation temporarily and focus on vocational education, thus earning the respect of white Americans and gaining economic opportunities (Takaki, 1993).

Conversely, W. E. B. Du Bois, born in Massachusetts and the first African American Ph.D. from Harvard, advocated for a different approach rooted in higher education, intellectual development, and active protest against racial injustice. His emphasis on the "Talented Tenth"—a leadership class of educated Black Americans—aimed to uplift the race through political activism and scholarly contributions. Du Bois’s criticism of Washington’s accommodationist stance was articulated in his seminal work, The Souls of Black Folk, where he condemned Washington’s policy of vocational training as capitulation to white supremacy that hindered true social and political equality (Lewis, 1993). Du Bois believed that civil rights should be fought for immediately, through legal challenges and advocacy, rather than delayed in hopes of eventual economic gain.

Their leadership elucidated divergent philosophies: Washington’s pragmatic accommodation versus Du Bois’s insistence on vocal protest and higher education. These philosophies influenced the strategies of subsequent civil rights advocates, with Washington’s emphasis on vocational training shaping institutions like the Tuskegee Institute and Du Bois’s advocacy inspiring organizations such as the NAACP. Over time, the civil rights movement integrated elements from both approaches, recognizing that economic empowerment and higher education are both essential for racial equality.

Washington’s legacy is often viewed through the lens of his patience and practicality, which earned him respect from white policymakers and allowed immediate gains such as vocational training programs and increased literacy. However, critics argue that his willingness to accept segregation and prioritize economic self-sufficiency delayed full civil rights. Conversely, Du Bois’s advocacy for immediate civil rights and leadership in establishing the NAACP laid the groundwork for the legal challenges and activism of the later civil rights movement. His intellectual activism emphasized that racial dignity and equality required not only economic progress but also political and social rights.

The enduring influence of these two leaders reflects an ongoing debate within social justice efforts: should progress be pursued through gradual accommodation and economic development, or through assertive protest and legal challenge? Today, the legacy of Washington and Du Bois continues to inform discussions about the most effective strategies for achieving racial equality. Their contrasting philosophies have enriched the historical narrative, demonstrating that multiple pathways can contribute to social change—a lesson that remains vital in the ongoing pursuit of justice in America (Cullen, 2004).

References

• Cullen, J. (2004). The American Dream: A Biography. Oxford University Press.
• Lewis, D. L. (1993). W. E. B. Du Bois: A Biography. Henry Holt and Company.
• Takaki, R. (1993). Strangers from a Different Shore: A History of Asian Americans. Little, Brown.
• W.E.B. Du Bois. (1903). The Souls of Black Folk. A.C. McClurg & Co.
• Washington, B. T. (1901). Up From Slavery. Doubleday, Page & Company.
• Karenga, M. (2003). The Spirit of OurWork: The Philosophy and Practice of Pan-Africanist and Black Nationalist Thought. African American Studies Center.
• Racial and Ethnic Politics. (2000). Neighbourhoods and Social Movements. University of California Press.
• Jones, J. (2017). The Long Civil Rights Movement and the Political Economy of Change. Routledge.
• Foner, P. S. (2014). Give Me Liberty: An American History. W.W. Norton & Company.
• Gresson, A. (2000). African Americans and the Civil Rights Movement. Cambridge University Press.