Portrayals Of Criminals In The News And Popular Culture

Portrayals Of Criminals In The News And In Popular Culture May Influen

Portrayals of criminals in the news and in popular culture may influence the way that the public perceives certain types of criminals. The popularity of movies such as The Godfather and Scarface, and television shows such as Breaking Bad and Sons of Anarchy, suggests that viewers often identify positively with certain criminal “heroes.” These characters, despite engaging in brutal and illegal activities, are often portrayed with complexity and charisma, which can elicit admiration or empathy from audiences. Understanding why this occurs requires exploring the psychological appeal of criminal heroes and how media representations shape perceptions of crime.

One reason for the allure of criminal protagonists is the human fascination with antiheroes who possess traits of rebellion, independence, and power. Films like The Godfather and Scarface glamorize the criminal lifestyle by depicting wealth, influence, and authority, often portraying criminals as figures who challenge societal norms and achieve success outside the law. Such portrayals resonate with audiences as they provide an alternative form of heroism that is romanticized, especially when coupled with intricate storytelling, character development, and aesthetic appeal. Television shows like Breaking Bad and Sons of Anarchy further deepen this fascination by presenting morally complex characters who struggle with conscience, loyalty, and identity, making them more relatable and multidimensional.

The glamorization of criminal behavior is also influenced by the narrative techniques employed in media, including the use of sympathetic characters, compelling story arcs, and aesthetic styles such as noir visuals and dramatic music. These tools can elevate the criminal's persona, framing their actions as justified or understandable within a certain context. Consequently, viewers may begin to perceive certain crimes—such as drug trafficking, organized crime, or violence—as less stigmatized, especially when associated with charismatic characters. This can skew public perceptions, making criminal activities seem glamorous or acceptable, especially among impressionable audiences.

Research in criminology offers various explanations for this phenomenon. Social learning theory suggests that media literacy influences criminal behavior by shaping attitudes and perceptions towards crime. When audiences repeatedly see characters who receive admiration or material rewards for their illegal activities, they may internalize these attitudes, potentially leading to imitation (Akers, 1998). Differential association theory further posits that exposure to criminal acceptability in media can reinforce pro-criminal norms. Additionally, cultural criminology emphasizes the role of media in constructing a romanticized narrative around crime, making it a form of rebellion or rebellion against societal constraints.

Notably, the distinction between glamorized crimes and demonized crimes reflects how media selectively portrays illegal activities. Acts like drug use and organized violence are often glamorized when associated with rebellious or affluent characters, while crimes such as child abuse or white-collar fraud tend to be demonized or underrepresented. This differential portrayal influences societal perceptions, potentially leading to a distorted understanding of crime prevalence and severity. The glamorization of certain crimes can lead to increased admiration for criminal figures, whereas demonization may contribute to stigmatization and fear of marginalized groups.

Given the influence of such portrayals, the question arises whether there should be legal restrictions on depicting criminals in popular culture. While freedom of expression is a fundamental right, there is an ethical concern regarding how media may inadvertently promote or normalize criminal behavior. Restrictions could be justified if there is concrete evidence that media portrayals directly contribute to increased criminal activity. However, limiting artistic expression might also hinder creative freedom and the social critique that such portrayals can offer. Therefore, a balanced approach that involves responsible depiction and media literacy education may be more appropriate than outright censorship (Schmid, 1982).

In conclusion, portrayals of criminals in the news and entertainment media influence societal perceptions and can even impact behavior. The appeal of criminal heroes lies in their complexity, charisma, and the narratives that frame their activities as glamorous or rebellious. Theories in criminology, such as social learning and cultural criminology, help explain this phenomenon, emphasizing the importance of media literacy in mitigating potential negative effects. While regulating media portrayals raises complex legal and ethical questions, promoting responsible content and critical viewing may provide a more effective solution than restrictive legal measures.

References

• Akers, R. L. (1998). Social Learning and Social Structure: A General Theory of Crime and Deviance. Boston: Northeastern University Press.
• Buntin, J. (2014). The Appeal of the Antihero: Why We Love Criminals on TV. Journal of Popular Culture, 47(3), 563-578.
• Chandler, D. (2010). Media and Crime: An Introduction. SAGE Publications.
• Cohen, S. (1972). Folk Devils and Moral Panics. Routledge.
• Ferrell, J., & Hayward, K. (2012). Cultural Criminology. Sage Publications.
• Gerbner, G., & Gross, L. (1976). Living with Television: The Violence Profile. Journal of Communication, 26(2), 173-199.
• Schmid, G. (1982). The Impact of Media on Crime and Justice. Crime & Delinquency, 28(2), 166-183.
• Surette, R. (2015). Media, Crime, and Criminal Justice: Images, Realities, and Policies. Cengage Learning.
• Wilkins, C. (2010). Media Violence and Crime: An Overview. Journal of Crime & Justice, 33(2), 195-210.
• Williams, P. (2007). Crime Crime and Popular Culture. McGraw-Hill Education.