Private I. History

PRIVATE I. HISTORY

Walter Simmons founded the company in 1948, initially focusing on custom-designed signs, especially neon signs for drive-in theaters during the late 1940s and early 1950s. The company also produced electronic circuits for telephone manufacturers and expanded into grocery chains with weekly specials and coupons in the 1970s and 1980s. In recent years, sales have declined, indicating financial difficulties.

Paper For Above instruction

Walter Simmons established a sign-making company in 1948 that specialized in custom-designed neon signs, which gained popularity among drive-in theaters. During the 1950s, the company diversified into producing electronic circuits for telephone equipment manufacturers, expanding its technological capabilities. From the mid-1970s to mid-1980s, Simmons' business ventured into the grocery sector, offering weekly specials and two-for-one coupons to attract customers, capitalizing on the rising trend of mass-marketing in retail. Despite these successes, the company's recent financial performance has been marked by declining sales over the past three years, signaling a potential downturn or need for strategic reevaluation.

Industry Analysis

Using Porter’s Five-Force Model, the sign and promotional product industry exhibits significant competitive pressures and moderate threats from substitutes. The risk of new entrants remains high due to relatively low barriers to entry facilitated by technological advancements, allowing smaller competitors to enter specific segments of the industry. However, established competitors like Simmons' business and others benefit from cumulative experience and brand recognition, intensifying rivalry. Supplier power is comparatively low since raw materials such as paper and ink are widely available from numerous suppliers, giving buyers and companies leverage. The bargaining power of customers, especially institutional buyers such as advertising agencies and large corporations, is significant due to their ability to demand discounts or tailored services. Substitutes for traditional sign products, such as digital displays or online advertising, present a moderate threat, driven by evolving technology and changing marketing paradigms.

Corporate-Level Strategy

The company's overarching strategy is diversified within the signage and promotional products industry, offering a broad range of products including banners, silk-screened posters, painted plywood signs, vinyl-letter signs, vehicle lettering, design assistance, and custom-design signs, as well as one-of-a-kind items like books and plaques. The company emphasizes a focus on custom design and personalized services, aiming to differentiate itself through craftsmanship and creative expertise. It also leverages multiple product lines to appeal to different customer segments, including local businesses, institutions, and individuals.

Business-Level Strategy

At the operational level, the company employs a focused differentiation strategy centered on custom-designed signage and personalized service. It emphasizes creative design, quality craftsmanship, and tailored solutions to meet distinct customer needs, particularly in complex sign design. The firm leverages its skilled employees and design assistance to distinguish itself from competitors. While it offers a full range of sign services, the emphasis on personalized, high-quality products aims to create a niche market, reducing direct price competition and fostering customer loyalty. The company's strategic positioning relies heavily on its unique expertise and reputation for custom work rather than competing solely on cost.

Structure and Control Systems

The company adopts a centralized authority structure, with Wilma managing finances, project scheduling, purchasing, and bid writing, alongside client engagement and some hands-on sign painting and design. Jim Davis handles most commercial and banner work, while Hank Richards manages vehicle lettering and customer designs, and Saundra Cox, a part-time worker, operates the computer system and performs miscellaneous tasks. Compensation is based on hourly rates, reflecting a traditional pay structure. All purchases are made on a cash-on-delivery basis, minimizing credit risk. The firm maintains control through direct supervision, a close-knit team, and cost management practices, but faces challenges with delegation and modern technology adoption.

Internal Environment

The firm's strengths include its ability to create custom signage, its skilled employees with graphic design expertise, excellent location near a university and statehouse, and a strong reputation built over the years. It offers design assistance, delivery services, and benefits from being debt-free, providing financial flexibility. Additionally, its long-standing presence and memberships in local organizations support community ties. Conversely, weaknesses include limited marketing efforts, outdated technology, underdeveloped management delegation, declining sales, and financial struggles exemplified by asset reduction and owner pay cuts. Price competitiveness is a concern due to higher costs relative to rivals, and its store layout hampers efficient operations and customer experience.

External Environment

Opportunities for the company involve exploiting a niche in complex sign design, which faces little competition and can serve as a focus strategy. Further, expanding marketing efforts to raise awareness and attract new customers, especially from the university and government sectors, can foster ongoing relationships. The evolving technological landscape offers avenues for innovation, allowing the firm to incorporate new sign-making technologies and digital platforms. There is also potential for growth by targeting larger markets, including neighboring suburbs and retail complexes, especially in the context of low competition in custom sign markets. Threats include technological advancements that lower barriers to entry, escalating industry competition, and new competitors utilizing up-to-date equipment and cheaper labor, such as high school students operating computerized sign machines. Increasing competition from franchise and suburban businesses, as well as the risk of rental and lease complications, complicate expansion plans. Rapid technological changes may diminish traditional sign-making skills, and fluctuating economic conditions can further threaten revenues.

Recommendations and Evaluation

To capitalize on existing opportunities, the company should focus on specializing exclusively in custom-designed signage, which is the most profitable segment and leverages its core competencies in craftsmanship and design. This focus will allow the firm to differentiate itself from competitors and command premium pricing. Maintaining a full-service sign shop remains vital to cater to diverse customer needs; however, significant investments in updating computer systems and technology are necessary to stay competitive.

Enhancing marketing strategies is critical; employing personalized selling through Wilma, Hank, and Jim can strengthen customer relationships. Developing a client loyalty program, such as discounts for repeat customers, and emphasizing design assistance can attract and retain clients. The company should define a clear target market, such as local businesses or governmental agencies, then tailor messaging accordingly. Implementing a commission-based compensation plan can motivate employees and foster entrepreneurial attitudes among staff, though it may increase labor costs.

Delegating authority from Wilma to competent staff will enable her to concentrate on strategic sales and business development. This shift requires building management capacity and trust. Securing new capital to upgrade technology and increase marketing budgets can generate additional growth and repeat business, despite upfront expenses. To enhance operational efficiency and visibility, redesigning the shop layout to showcase ongoing work can enhance customer engagement, though it may temporarily slow operations. Cost control remains essential; the company must balance investments with current financial constraints and be cautious of overextending.

In conclusion, the company should leverage its strengths in craftsmanship, customer service, and community presence while addressing weaknesses in technology and management. Focused differentiation and targeted marketing, coupled with technological upgrades and strategic delegation, will position the firm to overcome industry threats and capitalize on growth opportunities, ensuring sustainability and profitability in an increasingly competitive market.

References

  • Porter, M. E. (1980). Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analyzing Industries and Competitors. The Free Press.
  • Hitt, M. A., Ireland, R. D., & Hoskisson, R. E. (2020). Strategic Management: Concepts and Cases. Cengage Learning.
  • Grant, R. M. (2019). Contemporary Strategy Analysis and Practice. Wiley.
  • Barney, J. B., & Hesterly, W. S. (2019). Strategic Management and Competitive Advantage: Concepts and Cases. Pearson.
  • Chandler, A. D. (1962). Strategy and Structure: Chapters in the History of the American Industrial Enterprise. MIT Press.
  • Prahalad, C. K., & Hamel, G. (1990). The Core Competence of the Corporation. Harvard Business Review, 68(3), 79-91.
  • Arthur D. Little, Inc. (2013). Industry Trends and Future Outlook for Custom Signage. Industry Report.
  • McKinsey & Company. (2018). Digital Transformation in Small and Medium Business Signage Markets.
  • Investopedia. (2020). Porter’s Five Forces Analysis. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/porter.asp
  • Forbes. (2021). How Small Businesses Can Thrive Amid Industry Disruptions. https://www.forbes.com

Related Assignments