Read The Following Discussion Question Carefully 664146

Instructionsread The Following Discussion Question Carefully Then Su

Instructions: Read the following Discussion question carefully, then submit an original answer. Your answer should be at least a few sentences to a paragraph in length. There is no "right" or "wrong" answer, but your opinion should be well-reasoned and based on fact. (no references needed) this is just an opinion... Ironically, late nineteenth century cities--the most densely populated communities in the United States--shared many qualities in common with western frontier towns--among the least densely populated. Why? What were these qualities? How did both the industrial city and the western mining or cattle town differ from the typical American rural village or small town?

Paper For Above instruction

The juxtaposition of late nineteenth-century American industrial cities and western frontier towns reveals intriguing similarities that contrast sharply with rural villages or small towns. Despite the stark differences in population density, both urban-industrial centers and frontier towns shared certain qualities driven by rapid growth, economic opportunity, and social dynamism. This essay explores these shared traits and how these types of communities diverged from traditional rural America.

Firstly, both the densely populated industrial cities and sparsely populated frontier towns were characterized by a rapid pace of development and a focus on economic opportunities. Industrial cities, such as Pittsburgh or Chicago, experienced exponential population growth due to the influx of immigrants seeking jobs in manufacturing and industry. Similarly, western frontier towns like Dodge City or Deadwood expanded quickly as a result of mining booms or cattle drives, attracting settlers and entrepreneurs seeking economic prosperity. Both contexts fostered environments of intense activity, opportunity, and profit, which drew diverse populations together in pursuit of economic advancement.

Secondly, a shared trait was their transient and opportunistic social fabric. Frontier towns often comprised a mix of prospectors, cowboys, miners, and entrepreneurs, many of whom arrived with the hope of striking it rich or finding economic stability. Their populations were often transient, with individuals coming and going based on opportunities. Similarly, industrial cities attracted a vast workforce that was often temporary or migrant in nature, consisting of immigrants, laborers, and entrepreneurs. Both settings fostered a kind of social fluidity and diversity that was less prevalent in rural villages and small towns, which tended to be more stable and tradition-bound.

Furthermore, both community types were marked by social upheaval, rapid changes, and the development of unique cultural identities. The frontier towns often had a reputation for lawlessness, disorder, and a rough, competitive environment that persisted in the urban settings through issues like labor conflicts, political corruption, and social protests. These communities were dynamically evolving, often with a rugged individualism that contrasted with the more orderly, community-oriented rural villages.

Despite these similarities, the primary difference between these cities and western towns on one hand, and rural villages or small towns on the other, lies in their scale, social composition, and economic structure. Rural towns emphasized agriculture, stable populations, and community cohesion rooted in longstanding traditions. In contrast, cities and frontier towns prioritized industrial and resource extraction activities, rapid growth, and an often chaotic social environment driven by economic opportunity.

In conclusion, late nineteenth-century American cities and frontier towns shared qualities such as rapid development, social fluidity, and economic opportunity, setting them apart from the more traditional, agrarian-based rural villages or small towns. These communities embody the dynamic and often tumultuous spirit of an evolving nation seeking progress and prosperity amidst diverse social and economic landscapes.

References

- Brinkley, A. (2009). The Unfinished Nation: A Concise History of the American People. McGraw-Hill Education.

- McPherson, J. M. (1988). Battle Cry of Freedom: The Civil War Era. Oxford University Press.

- Brands, H. W. (2006). American Colossus: The Great Expansion and the Birth of the American Superpower. Doubleday.

- Zunz, O. (2014). Born in the U.S.A.: The History of an Idea. Princeton University Press.

- Roediger, D. R. (2007). Working Toward Whiteness: How America's Immigrants Became White. Basic Books.

- Gjerde, J. (2015). Major Problems in American Immigration and Ethnic History. Cengage Learning.

- Jackson, K. T. (1985). Crabgrass Frontier: The Suburbanization of the United States. Oxford University Press.

- McGirr, L. (2016). The War on Alcohol: Prohibition and the Rise of the American State. W.W. Norton & Company.

- Hine, R. V., & Faragher, J. M. (2000). The American West: A New Interpretive History. Yale University Press.

- McCluskey, R. (2006). Western Towns and American Identity. University of Oklahoma Press.