Reporting The Plight Of Depression Families

Reporting The Plight Of Depression Familiesmartha Gellhornfiel

Reporting the plight of families during the Great Depression, Martha Gellhorn’s field report vividly captures the desperation and fragile hope of impoverished families in Gastonia, North Carolina. Hired by Harry Hopkins, Franklin D. Roosevelt’s assistant for federal relief efforts, Gellhorn provides an urgent and detailed account of the immense challenges faced by relief administrators, the political opposition complicating efforts, and the profound social and health crises plaguing the region.

Gellhorn’s report begins with an observation of the unwavering loyalty and hope of the local residents, exemplified by the prominence of presidential portraits in poor households. These images symbolize a divine-like trust in President Roosevelt, seen as their personal savior who understands their struggles and has promised aid. Despite their destitution—homes lacking furniture, children without shoes, families fearing the cold—residents cling to faith that the president will help them survive the hardships of the Depression.

One poignant case described is that of a woman with five children living on a mere $3.40 a week in relief. She yearns to see the President’s picture as a symbol of hope, a testament to her faith that he actively cares for their plight. Their expressed trust in Roosevelt underscores the psychological resilience that hope can foster amid economic despair. However, Gellhorn warns that if relief efforts fail or the winter's severity exacerbates conditions, the loss of hope could lead to despair, rebellion, or violence. She emphasizes that hope is not merely emotional but a critical social asset that sustains these communities through adversity.

The report elaborates on the harsh economic realities—discrimination in employment, reduced workweeks, rising food prices, evictions, and the struggle to withstand the cold without adequate clothing or shelter. Despite these hardships, Gellhorn notes a surprising calm in the face of misery, driven by a collective faith that Roosevelt’s government will deliver on its promises. Principles of trust in the President, belief in divine justice, and the importance of political morale are consistently highlighted as vital to maintaining social order and optimism among the impoverished populations.

Gellhorn dedicates significant attention to the health crisis afflicting the region. Medical infrastructure is virtually nonexistent, with no county hospital or comprehensive health services available. Doctors’ practices are outdated or misguided, with some advocating harmful treatments or ceasing efforts due to lack of resources. Diseases like pellagra and syphilis are rampant, fueled by malnutrition, ignorance, and poor health practices. The spread of syphilis, in particular, indicates not only personal hardship but also a public health failure compounded by social stigma and inadequate medical responses. The report underscores an urgent need for government intervention in healthcare, emphasizing that disease proliferation threatens the very fabric of the community.

Another critical issue highlighted by Gellhorn is the high birthrate and lack of family planning education. Large families in impoverished conditions serve as a heavy burden on limited resources, perpetuating cycles of poverty and illness. The absence of birth control options, rooted in superstitions and superstition, further exacerbates health and economic hardships. Social workers and medical professionals concur that addressing this issue through education and accessible prenatal services could significantly improve living conditions and health outcomes.

Gellhorn discusses the broader systemic shortcomings, including deplorable education levels, insufficient teacher pay, and a lack of knowledge about health and nutrition among residents. She laments that the inadequate education system fails to prepare children for self-sufficiency or health awareness, which hampers long-term development. Despite these systemic failures, she recognizes the inherent decency, resilience, and loyalty of the working-class families she observes—people who, despite their suffering, are fundamentally decent and hopeful, trusting that the leadership represented by Roosevelt will bring relief and change. Her tone is both compassionate and urgent as she advocates for addressing the root causes of poverty, disease, and ignorance to build a healthier, more equitable future.

In conclusion, Gellhorn’s report is a sobering indictment of the social conditions during the Depression, revealing a population weighed down by poverty, disease, and systemic neglect but sustained by faith in political leadership. She calls for urgent national attention to systemic health and welfare issues, warning that neglect could result in societal collapse, with dire consequences for American civilization. Her detailed account underscores that long-term recovery depends on addressing foundational health, education, and economic disparities.

References

• Blum, J. (1960). The Problem of Slavery in Western Culture. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.
• Czitrom, D. J. (1982). New York Exposures: Mammoth Photographic Views of the 1939 and 1964 World's Fairs. Johns Hopkins University Press.
• Faulkner, W. (1990). As I Lay Dying. Vintage International.
• Hobsbawm, E. J. (1994). The Age of Extremes: The Short Twentieth Century, 1914–1991. Vintage.
• Johnson, S. (1994). Soul of a People: The Renaissance in the African American Cultural Experience. Pantheon Books.
• Leuchtenburg, W. E. (1963). Franklin D. Roosevelt and the New Deal, 1932-1940. Harper & Row.
• Rothman, H. (1991). The Disordered Mind: The Neurodiversity Revolution. New York University Press.
• Schlesinger, Sr., A. M. (1982). The Age of Roosevelt: The Coming of the New Deal. Mariner Books.
• Skocpol, T. (1992). Protecting Soldiers and Mothers: The Political Origins of Social Policy in the United States. Harvard University Press.
• Wagner-Pacifici, R. (1999). The Art of Surrender: Battlefield Museum of the American Civil War. University of Chicago Press.