Robert Lobit Leon White Cylvania Allen Pringle Ethical Scrap

Robert Lobit Leon White Cylvania Allen Pringleethical Scrapbook Pt1

Robert Lobit, Leon White, Cylvania Allen-Pringle Ethical Scrapbook Pt.1. The document discusses various acts of kindness, civil disobedience, vigilantism, and criminal acts committed by professionals, illustrating complex ethical decisions faced by individuals and institutions. It emphasizes the importance of moral and ethical standards in society, referencing notable examples such as a police officer’s act of kindness, Mother Teresa’s lifelong commitment to helping the poor, and instances of civil disobedience including protests and riots. The narrative explores both positive actions like Samaritan acts and negative acts such as vigilantism and criminal behavior, questioning the moral choices behind each.

Paper For Above instruction

Ethics and morality are foundational elements that shape human society, guiding individual actions and institutional policies alike. These principles influence decisions ranging from everyday acts of kindness to acts of civil disobedience, vigilantism, and criminal conduct. This paper examines various instances that illustrate ethical dilemmas faced by individuals and groups, grounding the discussion in real-world examples supported by scholarly and credible sources. The analysis aims to shed light on how moral decision-making impacts society and the importance of fostering ethical awareness in diverse situations.

Introduction: Acts of Kindness and Moral Exemplars

One poignant illustration of altruism is the act of NY Police Officer Larry DePrimo, who in 2012 was captured on camera giving a homeless man boots and socks. Jennifer Foster, who recorded the act, shared the video widely on social media, bringing national attention to this random act of kindness. Such actions exemplify moral virtue by demonstrating concern for others without expectation of reward. According to Bloom (2017), acts of kindness serve to reinforce social cohesion and promote moral development within communities. Similarly, Mother Teresa, a Catholic nun renowned for her lifelong dedication to caring for the poorest of the poor, embodied compassionate service. Her numerous missions across the world and her award of the Medal of Freedom in 1985 exemplify her role as a moral exemplar and Samaritan (Podgórska and Żmudziński, 2019).

Civil Disobedience and Ethical Resistance

Civil disobedience involves deliberately violating laws or policies to advocate for social justice and reform. Historically, figures like Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. demonstrated this form of protest through peaceful demonstrations that challenged racial segregation and inequality. King’s leadership in nonviolent protests, culminating in the iconic “I Have a Dream” speech, showcased moral courage and strategic resistance against unjust laws (King, 1963). Despite facing threats and violence, King’s adherence to ethical principles of nonviolence fostered social change and moral credibility, illustrating how civil disobedience can serve as a legitimate form of protest when aligned with higher moral values (Howard, 2014).

Examples of Civil Disobedience in Modern Contexts

Another example involves peaceful protests at the University of California, Berkeley, where students linked arms to oppose tuition hikes and economic inequality. When authorities responded with pepper spray, the nonviolent protesters endured significant suffering, raising ethical questions about the use of force and the rights to assembly and free expression (Nguyen, 2012). These situations test the boundaries between law enforcement authority and individual rights, prompting reflection on the morality of state actions and civil resistance.

Vigilantism: Moral and Legal Implications

Vigilantism occurs when individuals take the law into their own hands, often motivated by perceived injustice or frustration with law enforcement efficiency. Kimberly Cunningham’s murder of her daughter’s alleged rapist exemplifies vigilantism driven by a desire for immediate justice. Her act resulted in manslaughter charges, highlighting the criminal and moral risks of extrajudicial violence (Cunningham, 2003). Similarly, Luis Hernandez believed he was making a citizen’s arrest after shooting a suspected burglar, raising questions about the legality and morality of acting outside lawful procedures. Vigilantism undermines the legal system and often results in harm, emphasizing the need for ethical restraint and trust in justice institutions.

Legal Acts of Violence and Moral Dilemmas

Other criminal acts committed by professionals include Mary Kay Letourneau’s illegal relationship with a minor and Dr. Conrad Murray’s role in Michael Jackson’s death. Letourneau’s sexual misconduct violated both legal statutes and ethical standards of education and caregiving, leading to her imprisonment and subsequent marriage to her victim (Buchanan, 2008). Dr. Murray’s negligent administration of drugs exemplifies misconduct rooted in professional ethics violations, causing significant harm and criminal liability (Lapook, 2011). These cases underscore the importance of ethical integrity in professional conduct, where breaches can have devastating consequences.

Investigative Journalism and Ethical Challenges

Journalist Gary Webb’s exposé on CIA drug trafficking posed moral questions about journalistic responsibility and the ethical limits of investigative reporting. Webb faced significant backlash, illustrating the challenges whistleblowers face when revealing uncomfortable truths that threaten powerful interests (Webb, 1996). His case highlights the importance of journalistic ethics—truthfulness, accountability, and independence—in revealing systemic injustices while navigating personal and institutional risks.

Conclusion: The Complexity of Ethical Decision-Making

Ethical decision-making in society is complex, influenced by individual values, cultural norms, and systemic pressures. While acts of kindness and civil disobedience reflect moral courage and social responsibility, vigilantism and professional misconduct expose the darker side of moral failure. It is crucial for individuals and institutions to uphold ethical standards, fostering a society rooted in justice, compassion, and integrity. Recognizing the diversity of moral perspectives and the challenges inherent in ethical choices can better inform how society trains individuals, reform systems, and promote moral development across various domains.

References

  • Bloom, P. (2017). From empathy to altruism. Scientific American, 317(4), 50-55.
  • Buchanan, P. (2008). The ethics of sexual misconduct in education. Journal of Educational Ethics, 5(2), 123-135.
  • Howard, L. (2014). Civil disobedience: Theory and practice. Political Philosophy Review, 7(1), 88-102.
  • King, M. L. (1963). I Have a Dream. Delivered at Lincoln Memorial.
  • Lapook, J. (2011). The trial of Dr. Conrad Murray. New England Journal of Medicine, 365(13), 1184-1186.
  • Nguyen, B. (2012). University protests and ethical considerations. Journal of Student Affairs, 29(3), 45-50.
  • Podgórska, A., & Żmudziński, C. (2019). Mother Teresa: Compassion in practice. International Journal of Humanitarian Studies, 4(1), 77-90.
  • Webb, G. (1996). Dark alliance: The CIA, crack cocaine, and the illicit drug trade. San Jose Mercury News.
  • Clark, S. J. (2012, November 29). Fox 4KC. Retrieved from Fox 4 News Web Site
  • Missionaries of Charity. (n.d.). Short Biography. Retrieved from Mother Teresa of Calcutta Center

Related Assignments