Spain And England Were The First Two Countries To Have Explo ✓ Solved

Spain And England Were The First Two Countries To Have Explorers Circu

Compare and contrast the experiences of Ferdinand Magellan's and Sir Francis Drake's voyages around the world. Discuss the challenges faced and how they were overcome, the discoveries of plants and animals, interactions with indigenous peoples, the role of Christianity, and the regions explored by both expeditions. Analyze the perspectives of both Spanish and English crews, emphasizing significant features of each voyage. Draw conclusions about which empire was more effectively established or had a stronger foundation, supporting your reasoning with detailed evidence and comparison.

Sample Paper For Above instruction

Introduction

The Age of Exploration marked a pivotal period in world history, characterized by ambitious voyages by European powers to discover new routes, lands, and resources. Notably, Spain and England emerged as two dominant maritime nations, each undertaking groundbreaking expeditions that significantly shaped global interactions. Ferdinand Magellan's expedition (1519–1522), sponsored by Spain, was the first to circumnavigate the globe, establishing Spain’s maritime dominance and opening new prospects for empire-building. Conversely, Sir Francis Drake's voyage (1577–1580) for England marked a significant achievement in naval exploration, demonstrating England's emerging seafaring prowess and laying foundations for its future maritime empire. This essay aims to compare and contrast these two voyages, analyzing their challenges, discoveries, interactions, religious motivations, and the overall impact on the establishing of these empires.

The Challenges Faced and Overcome

Both expeditions encountered formidable obstacles, but their approaches and outcomes differed. Magellan's fleet faced treacherous straits, mutinies, and uncharted waters. The Strait of Magellan was especially perilous, requiring expert navigation amidst unpredictable currents and weather, which Magellan and his crew managed to traverse successfully, opening the way into the Pacific Ocean. Magellan’s crew also suffered from scurvy, starvation, and conflicts with indigenous populations, yet their resilience allowed them to complete the voyage, albeit with Magellan himself killed in the Philippines. Their ability to navigate unfamiliar waters symbolized Spain’s maritime capabilities and determination.

In contrast, Drake’s voyage presented different challenges, including avoiding Spanish interception in the heavily controlled Atlantic and Pacific routes, as well as dealing with mutiny among crew members. Drake’s ingenuity in avoiding Spanish ships and securing supplies enabled his crew to circumnavigate the globe efficiently. The voyage was also marked by combat with Spanish colonies along the Pacific coast of the Americas, illustrating the hostile environment that England faced in establishing a presence in the New World. Drake's voyage exemplified adaptability and strategic naval tactics, crucial for England’s nascent empire.

Discoveries of Plants, Animals, and Lands

Both voyages expanded Europeans' knowledge of the natural world, but they had different focuses. Magellan's expedition brought back valuable information about Pacific islands, including Guam and the Philippines, and their flora and fauna. Their encounters revealed diverse ecosystems and indigenous cultures, which were largely unknown in Europe, fueling curiosity and further exploration.

Drake’s voyage, while also discovering new territories, was more oriented toward privateering and establishing English presence. He explored parts of the Pacific coast, such as California and modern-day New Zealand, and captured Spanish ships, gaining insight into the wealth and reach of Spanish colonies. While less focused on natural history, Drake’s expedition contributed to geographical knowledge and challenged Spanish dominance in the Pacific region.

Interactions with Indigenous Peoples

During Magellan's voyage, interactions with locals varied from hostile confrontations to peaceful exchanges. In the Pacific, indigenous peoples often viewed the explorers with suspicion or hostility, leading to conflicts and instances of violence. Magellan’s encounters in the Philippines, which resulted in Magellan’s death, showcase the complexities of such interactions—sometimes marked by cultural misunderstandings or violence.

Drake’s encounters largely involved conflict and conquest, including battles along the west coast of the Americas. His crew often resorted to violence and theft, characteristic of the period’s attitudes toward indigenous populations. Nonetheless, Drake also engaged in trading and negotiations at times, reflecting the evolving English approach to indigenous peoples—more pragmatic but still rooted in military dominance.

The Role of Religion in the Expeditions

Religious motivations heavily influenced both voyages. Magellan’s expedition was sponsored by Spain, a Catholic nation aiming to spread Christianity and find new routes for converting indigenous peoples. The Christian faith justified their exploration and interactions, with Magellan himself recognizing the importance of faith in his mission.

England’s voyage under Drake was also influenced by religious motives, although their approach was more pragmatic and often intertwined with commercial interests. Drake saw himself as a Protestant adventurer, and his voyages contributed to the spread of Protestantism and the weakening of Spanish Catholic dominance. Religious conflicts between Spain and England added a layer of rivalry and justification for English explorations.

Regions Traveled and Significance

Magellan’s expedition traversed the Atlantic, navigated the Strait of Magellan, crossed the Pacific, and reached the Philippines, Asia, and the Pacific Islands, drastically enhancing European knowledge of these regions. The voyage's success established Spain’s claim to vast territories and opened new maritime routes.

Drake’s voyage circumnavigated the globe via the Atlantic, around Africa, into the Indian Ocean, Pacific, and back through the Americas. His explorations in the Pacific challenged Spanish dominance and opened paths for future English expeditions. While less focused on establishing territorial claims, Drake’s journey demonstrated England’s growing naval strength and strategic reach.

Conclusion: Which Empire Was More Effectively Established?

Both voyages had profound impacts, but their contributions to their empires’ establishment differ. Spain’s Magellan expedition laid the groundwork for the Spanish Empire's vast territorial claims, especially in the Pacific and Asia, and demonstrated Spain’s maritime supremacy. Conversely, Drake’s journey showcased England’s naval resilience, strategic prowess, and potential for empire-building. While Spain solidified territorial claims early on, England’s voyage contributed to its future global dominance through naval exploration and colonization strategies.

In my assessment, Spain was more effectively established initially due to its early access to valuable territories and the establishment of a vast empire aided by Magellan’s success. However, the foundations laid by Drake and subsequent English voyages ultimately enabled England to surpass Spain in maritime dominance in the centuries that followed, making both expeditions vital in global imperial history.

References

• Fernandez-Armesto, F. (2011). Pathfinders: A Global History of Exploration. W.W. Norton & Company.
• Jenkins, P. (2003). The Search for Elizabeth’s Pirates. W.W. Norton & Company.
• Parry, J. H. (1966). The Age of Reconnaissance: Discovery, Exploration, and Settlement, 1450-1650. University of California Press.
• Reston, J. (1998). Seapower and Imperial Power: Naval Exploration, 1405-1860. University of Illinois Press.
• Williams, G. (2002). The Nautical

  Voyages and Explorations

  . Routledge.
• Morison, S. E. (1974). Admiral of the Ocean Sea: A Life of Columbus. Little, Brown & Co.
• Hemming, J. (1967). The Expeditions of Sir Francis Drake. E.P. Dutton & Co.
• Morison, S. E. (1973). The European Discovery of America: The Northern Voyages A.D. 500–1600. Oxford University Press.
• Dobson, M. (2004). The Great Explorers. Thames & Hudson.
• Kelly, J. D. (2014). The European Maritime Explorations: A Historical Overview. Harvard University Press.