Using The MLB Steroids Case As An Example Explain How Ethics

Using The Mlb Steroids Case As An Example Explain How Unethical Choic

Using the MLB steroids case as an example, explain how unethical choices by some players harms players who comply with the rules. This paper discusses the ethical implications of steroid use in Major League Baseball (MLB) and how such actions damage the integrity of the sport, undermine fair competition, and negatively affect those who abide by the rules. The use of performance-enhancing drugs (PEDs) such as steroids has long been a controversial issue in professional sports, particularly in baseball, where statistics and player achievements are central to a player’s reputation and career.

Unethical choices by individual players, such as using steroids to enhance performance, create a cascade of negative consequences for others within the sport. First and foremost, these choices undermine the fairness of competition. Players who choose to use steroids gain an unnatural edge over those who choose to compete ethically and remain drug-free. As noted by Bryant (2019), steroid use artificially inflates players' abilities, allowing them to break records and perform at levels that may not be attainable naturally. Consequently, honest players who compete without doping are unfairly disadvantaged, which diminishes their achievements and the integrity of the game.

Moreover, unethical behavior by some players damages the reputation of the sport and erodes public trust. When a significant number of players are found to be using steroids, it casts doubt on the validity of statistics, awards, and records. For example, the so-called "Steroid Era" of baseball (roughly from the late 1980s to the early 2000s) was marked by numerous allegations and admissions of drug use by prominent players, leading to widespread skepticism about the legitimacy of performance records (Nightenagle, 2019). This skepticism affects fan engagement, decreases viewership, and casts a shadow over the accomplishments of clean players, many of whom are unfairly scrutinized or overlooked for awards due to suspected doping.

Furthermore, unethical choices by some players harm their teammates and the organization as a whole. When players violate ethical standards, it can create a toxic team environment where trust is compromised. Teammates may feel betrayed or demotivated, especially if they have maintained integrity and avoided doping. This can lead to fractured team dynamics, decreased morale, and an overall decline in team cohesion (Junger & Garcia, 2019). Additionally, organizations may face sanctions, legal issues, and damage to their reputation, which can influence sponsorships and financial stability.

Another adverse effect of unethical steroid use is the health and wellbeing of the athletes themselves. Steroids and other PEDs can have severe long-term health consequences, including hormonal imbalances, liver damage, and psychological effects. Players who indulge in such substances may prioritize short-term gains over their health, a choice that is ethically questionable and morally irresponsible. The ethical dilemma revolves around the pursuit of success at the expense of personal health, which can set a harmful precedent for aspiring athletes and youth spectators (Pantuosco, 2011).

The Major League Baseball’s response, including drug testing protocols and sanctions, illustrates efforts to uphold ethical standards and deter doping. Yet, instances of cheating reveal loopholes and enforcement challenges. The case of Jose Canseco, who publicly admitted to steroid use, highlights the prevalence of unethical practices and the impact on the sport's credibility (Nightenagle, 2019). It also underscores the importance of fostering a culture of integrity and promoting anti-doping initiatives that emphasize fairness, health, and ethical behavior.

In conclusion, unethical choices such as steroid use in MLB compromise the fairness of competition, damage the sport's reputation, harm team cohesion, and pose serious health risks to athletes. While some players may gain short-term advantages, their actions ultimately undermine the fundamental principles of sportsmanship and integrity. Therefore, it is essential to reinforce ethical standards, implement comprehensive drug testing, and cultivate a culture that values fair play and respect for rules. Only then can professionals and the public trust the spirit of sport, and the achievements within it be genuinely celebrated.

Paper For Above instruction

The issue of steroid use in Major League Baseball (MLB) serves as a compelling example of how unethical choices made by individual athletes can have widespread repercussions on the sport, its players, and its integrity. The use of performance-enhancing drugs (PEDs) such as steroids is not merely a breach of rules but a violation of the ethical principles that underpin fair competition and sportsmanship. This essay explores how these unethical decisions harm compliant players, undermine the credibility of the sport, and threaten the health and morale of athletes.

Unethical behaviors like steroid abuse create an uneven playing field. Athletes who opt to use steroids artificially boost their performance, enabling them to surpass natural physical limits and achieve extraordinary statistics and records. These enhancements distort the fairness of competition because they give an unfair advantage to doping players over those who choose to compete honestly without artificial aids. Bryant (2019) highlights that steroid use during the "Steroid Era" in baseball led to inflated statistics and record-breaking achievements, many of which are now viewed with skepticism. Such disparities discourage legitimately talented players who adhere to rules from attaining recognition and success, thereby diminishing the sport's integrity.

Furthermore, the widespread doping culture tarnishes the credibility of the sport in the eyes of fans and stakeholders. When key players are caught doping or when admissions of steroid use surface, public trust erodes. The skepticism surrounding historic achievements, like home run records, hampers the legitimacy of the sport's history. Nightenagle (2019) discusses how the steroid scandal damaged MLB’s reputation, leading to calls for reform and stricter enforcement. This loss of credibility can have severe economic impacts, including decreased attendance, viewership, and sponsorship revenue, ultimately undermining the sport's financial stability.

Unethical doping behavior also negatively impacts the moral and psychological environment within teams. When some players cheat, it creates an atmosphere of distrust and resentment among teammates. Ethical players may feel betrayed or demotivated, perceiving that their hard work and integrity are being undermined. Junger and Garcia (2019) emphasize how unethical practices among athletes can spread within teams, leading to a toxic environment where cheating becomes normalized. This erosion of trust can weaken team cohesion, reducing overall performance and morale.

Moreover, the health consequences of steroid abuse are dire, posing long-term risks to athletes’ physical and mental health. Steroids can cause liver damage, hormonal imbalances, cardiovascular issues, and psychological problems such as aggression and depression. Ethical considerations demand that athletes prioritize their health over short-term gains, but the pressure to succeed often drives them to make reckless choices. Pantuosco (2011) argues that these decisions reflect a complex moral dilemma where winning is often valued more than health and integrity.

Despite MLB’s efforts to combat doping—including drug testing protocols and sanctions—there are persistent challenges in enforcement. The case of Jose Canseco, who openly admitted steroid use and became an influential whistleblower, illustrates how entrenched doping culture can be and how difficult it is to root out unethical practices (Nightenagle, 2019). This underscores the need for ongoing education, strict regulations, and a culture that promotes clean sport and ethical conduct.

In essence, the unethical actions of steroid-using players in MLB damages the fabric of competitive sports by creating unfair advantages, eroding public trust, damaging team dynamics, and endangering athlete health. The long-term sustainability and credibility of professional sports depend on fostering a culture of fairness, integrity, and respect for rules. Upholding these values ensures that achievements are genuine and athletes' efforts are rightly recognized, preserving the true spirit of sport for future generations.

References

• Bryant, H. (2019). The steroid era in baseball: The impact on performance and reputation. Journal of Sports Ethics, 15(3), 210-225.
• Junger, J., & Garcia, P. (2019). Juicing with friends: Compliance lessons from baseball’s steroid era. Journal of Health Care Compliance, 21(6), 47–56.
• Nightenagle, B. (2019). Steroids and scandal: The decline and rebirth of baseball’s integrity. Sports Studies Journal, 32(4), 299-317.
• Pantuosco, L. J. (2011). Does it pay to be unethical? The case of performance-enhancing drugs in MLB. American Economist, 56(2), 58-68.
• Mahoney, K. (2009). Learning from the mistakes of others: Changing Major League Baseball’s substance abuse arbitration procedure. Ohio State Journal on Dispute Resolution, 24(3), 613–640.
• Smith, R. E. (2020). Ethical issues in sports doping. International Journal of Sport Policy and Politics, 12(1), 101-115.
• Segrave, K. (2021). Performance enhancement in sports: Ethical dilemmas and health risks. Ethics in Sports Literature Review, 8(2), 147-165.
• Johnson, P. (2022). The impact of doping scandals on fan engagement and sports trust. Journal of Sports Marketing, 36(4), 503-519.
• Martínez, A., & López, M. (2020). Ethical considerations of doping in professional sports. Sports Ethics Quarterly, 12(4), 325-340.
• Snyder, R. (2023). Strategies for anti-doping education and enforcement in professional sports. Journal of Sport Management, 39(2), 221-238.