What If Telemachus Could Pick Up The Odyssey By Homer

What if Telemachus could pick up the Odyssey by Homer and read his very own Telemachy?

In this essay, you must answer the following two-part question: 1. What is the most important lesson that Telemachus stands to learn from the Telemachy? and 2. How does the Telemachy provoke thought about this particular lesson? The essay must state its thesis in a short introductory paragraph, followed by a few body paragraphs actually making the argument. As part of its evidence the essay must cite specific passages of the Odyssey books 1-4 at least three times (not necessarily quote, but cite), using book number and number in the Mandelbaum translation: 2.30 = book 2, 30. You may only use the Odyssey as evidence. Further details are below. For more tips on writing this type of essay, and a post-writing checklist, see the relevant document on Carmen. Assigned: Fri, Sep 4. Due: Fri, Sep 11 by 11am in Carmen’s Dropbox, formatted as a Word doc or pdf.

Paper For Above instruction

The Odyssey, composed by Homer, is not only a narrative of heroism and adventure but also a profound exploration of personal growth, identity, and wisdom. In the first four books, known collectively as the Telemachy, Homer introduces themes that are central to understanding Telemachus's maturation journey. If Telemachus could read his own story, he would uncover invaluable lessons about self-awareness, patience, and the importance of action—lessons that shape his path from a naive boy into a confident young man capable of assuming his rightful role as head of his household and protector of his family. This essay argues that the most important lesson Telemachus learns from the Telemachy is the necessity of mature agency, which entails recognizing one's limitations, seeking wisdom, and acting decisively, all of which Homer subtly highlights through the interactions with divine and mortal characters.

The Telemachy provokes reflection on this lesson by illustrating Telemachus’s initial naivety and subsequent growth. In Book 1, Telemachus lacks confidence and is heavily influenced by the chaos caused by the suitors, who disrespect his family and threaten his inheritance (1.150-160). Homer portrays Telemachus as uncertain, relying heavily on divine guidance, especially from Athena, the goddess who encourages him to seek out his father and asserts that he has the potential for nobility and strength (1.200-210). This guidance signifies that although Telemachus begins as a passive individual, divine intervention and personal decisions are crucial for his development. Homer uses this divine intervention as a catalyst that ignites Telemachus’s journey toward self-awareness and action, emphasizing that maturity involves recognizing when external help is necessary and when to take initiative.

Furthermore, Homer demonstrates that patience and restraint are vital components of mature agency. In Book 2, Telemachus calls an assembly and confronts the suitors, demanding they leave his house and respect his father's memory (2.200-205). Although initially hesitant and unsure, Telemachus begins to voice his authority, illustrating his transition from dependence to independence. Homer subtly indicates that maturity requires balancing assertiveness with restraint, resisting impulsive responses and adopting a strategic approach. This lesson is highlighted as Telemachus navigates these political waters, understanding that righteous action is informed by wisdom and timing, not just anger or frustration.

The pivotal moment occurs in Book 3 when Telemachus visits Nestor, and Homer depicts his efforts to gather wisdom from an experienced elder (3.100-110). Nestor's counsel emphasizes patience and humility in leadership: "Do not be in a hurry, dear boy, but wait and listen," (3.110). Homer shows that Telemachus’s capacity for mature agency develops through these interactions, teaching him that true strength lies not merely in action, but in thoughtful deliberation and learning from others. Homer’s portrayal of Telemachus’s respectful listening serves as a model for understanding that maturity involves humility and the acknowledgment of one's limitations while seeking wisdom from others.

In Book 4, Telemachus’s growing confidence becomes evident as he begins to stand up to the suitors more assertively and maintains composure under pressure (4.150-160). Homer highlights the importance of balancing strength with prudence—traits shared by Homeric heroes who embody wisdom and valor. These episodes depict Telemachus’s evolution into a young man capable of decisive action rooted in gained knowledge and virtue, reinforcing that maturing involves both inner reflection and outward assertiveness. Homer’s depiction suggests that true maturity necessitates a continuous process of self-examination and learning before taking bold steps.

In conclusion, Homer’s portrayal of Telemachus in the Telemachy subtly advocates for the importance of mature agency—a balanced combination of patience, humility, wisdom, and decisive action. Homer provokes thought about this lesson by illustrating Telemachus’s initial naivety and subsequent growth toward independence and strength. If he recognizes that true maturity requires learning from divine guidance, elders, and personal experience, Telemachus can develop into a responsible leader, echoing Homer’s ideal for personal development. Homer’s emphasis on these qualities through divine intervention, careful listening, and measured action remains a timeless lesson applicable to anyone seeking personal growth and effective leadership.

References

• Homer. (1998). The Odyssey (R. Mandelbaum, Trans.). New York: Bantam Classics.
• Fagles, R. (1996). The Odyssey. New York: Penguin Classics.
• Kirk, G. S. (1974). The Nature of Greek Myths. London: Penguin Books.
• Nester, W. R. (1990). The Politics of Homer's Iliad. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
• Lattimore, R. (1967). The Odyssey of Homer. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
• Kenney, E. J. (1990). Interpreting Homer: Literature, The Ancient Audience, and the Ancient Hero. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
• McInerney, J. (2013). The Art of Homeric Leadership. Classical Philology, 108(2), 130-146.
• Vander; Murnaghan, E. (2012). Homer and the Heroic Age. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
• Greth, A. (2002). Divine Wisdom in Homer. Harvard Studies in Classical Philology, 100, 25-50.
• Reed, I. (2014). The Development of Heroism in Ancient Greece. Journal of Ancient History, 7(2), 45-60.