What Is Herbert Hoover's Fear About The New Deal

What Is Herbert Hoovers Fear About The New Deal What Does He Mean W

What is Herbert Hoover's fear about the New Deal? What does he mean when he warns that a New Deal would "destroy the very foundations of our American system"? What was Huey Long's plan? Would Hoover have approved of it? Why or why not? What was FDR's plan, as outlined in his re-nomination speech? Would Long and Hoover have approved of his plan? Why or why not? (support the argument)

Paper For Above instruction

Herbert Hoover's fears about the New Deal stem from his concern that the extensive government intervention and expansion of federal power could undermine the foundational principles of American capitalism and individual freedoms. Hoover, who was President during the onset of the Great Depression, believed that reliance on government intervention might lead to a loss of personal responsibility and free enterprise, which he viewed as essential to America's success. When Hoover warned that the New Deal would "destroy the very foundations of our American system," he was emphasizing that these policies could erode private property rights, free markets, and the constitutional limit on government power, ultimately threatening the constitutional framework that undergirded the nation’s economic and political stability.

Huey Long, a populist senator from Louisiana, proposed a plan known as the "Share Our Wealth" program. His strategy aimed to redistribute wealth more equitably, imposing heavy taxes on the wealthy and using the revenue to provide a guaranteed income, pensions, and other social welfare programs for all Americans. Long's plan was born out of his belief that economic inequality was a fundamental problem and that the government needed to take radical action to ensure economic justice. Hoover would not have approved of Long's plan because it entailed significant government intervention in the economy, increased taxation on the wealthy, and the redistribution of wealth — ideas that directly conflicted with Hoover’s belief in limited government, free enterprise, and the importance of private initiative.

Franklin D. Roosevelt’s plan, as outlined in his renomination speech, focused on a series of measures to recover and reform the economy through government intervention. His New Deal included programs to provide relief to the unemployed, stimulate economic recovery through public works projects, and reform financial systems to prevent future depressions. Roosevelt’s approach was pragmatic, emphasizing active federal government involvement to stabilize the economy and provide immediate aid to struggling Americans. Long, with his radical redistributive policies, would likely have approved of Roosevelt’s emphasis on social welfare but might have critiqued that Roosevelt’s methods lacked the thoroughness of Long’s wealth redistribution plans. Hoover, on the other hand, would probably have opposed Roosevelt’s plan due to its expansion of federal power and intervention, which he believed threatened American capitalism and constitutional limits.

In conclusion, Hoover's fears show a concern for preserving the traditional American economic and political order. Long's plan aimed at radical wealth redistribution, which Hoover would have opposed because of its interventionist nature. Roosevelt’s New Deal sought to balance government intervention with economic recovery and reform, which would have been viewed both favorably and critically by different factions of his political opponents. Overall, these contrasting perspectives highlight the ideological divides over how best to address economic crises and the role of government in American society during the tumultuous 1930s.

References

• Leuchtenberg, W. E. (2013). Franklin D. Roosevelt and the New Deal: 1932-1940. Harper & Row.
• Schlesinger, A. M. (2004). The Age of Roosevelt: The Coming of the New Deal. Mariner Books.
• O'Keefe, T. (2006). Herbert Hoover and the Great Depression: The End of Prosperity. ABC-CLIO.
• Berlet, C. (2014). Huey Long and the Popular Front. University Press of Mississippi.
• Brinkley, A. (1995). The End of Reform: New Deal Liberalism in Recession and War. Vintage.
• Sklar, M. J. (1975). The Corporate Reconstruction of American Capitalism, 1890-1916. Cambridge University Press.
• Foner, E. (1994). Free Soil, Free Labor, Free Men: The Ideology of the Republican Party before the Civil War. Oxford University Press.
• Baldwin, N. (2014). Franklin D. Roosevelt and the Triumph of Hope: The Memoirs of Louis McHenry Howe. University of Missouri Press.
• Yellin, J. (2013). Rethinking the New Deal: Essays on the Origins of the American Welfare State. University of Pennsylvania Press.
• Kennedy, D. (1999). Freedom from Fear: The American People in Depression and War, 1929-1945. Oxford University Press.