Who Believed That The Best Could Be Identified With The Olde

Who Believed That The Best Could Be Identified With The Oldest

Identify the individual or thinker who believed that the best could be identified with the oldest, based on the provided options. The options include Machiavelli, Luther, Calvin, Hooker, Hobbes, and others. This concept relates to the historical perspectives on tradition, antiquity, and the valuation of ancient wisdom or practices versus newer ones. The belief that the oldest corresponds to the best likely stems from a conservative view emphasizing tradition and historical continuity as superior sources of truth and virtue.

Paper For Above instruction

The philosophical and political thought regarding the value of the old versus the new has been a continuous debate throughout history. Several notable figures have contributed to this discourse, often advocating either the admiration for ancient traditions or the embrace of reform and innovation. Among these figures, Niccolò Machiavelli, a Renaissance political thinker, is known for valuing historical practice and the lessons of the past in his writings. Machiavelli's emphasis on pragmatic rulers and realpolitik often drew from ancient Roman and Greek examples, illustrating a respect for the accumulated wisdom of antiquity, though he also emphasized adapting to new circumstances.

Contrarily, reformers like Martin Luther and John Calvin emphasized returning to original sources—particularly Scripture—and upheld the antiquity of divine law as the ultimate standard. However, their emphasis was more on doctrinal purity and divine authority than on the age of doctrines per se. They believed that the truths found in the earliest revealed scriptures and practices were to be restored and upheld, thus valuing the oldest spiritual authority as the best guide.

It is less common in the records of mainstream philosophical and political thought to find figures explicitly stating that the oldest inherently equals the best. Instead, this is more characteristic of conservative philosophy, which venerates tradition and the heritage of antiquity. Therefore, among the options given, Machiavelli's approach of drawing heavily from the ancient past and his admiration for classical states and virtues suggest that he might have believed in the wisdom of the oldest, especially when it comes to governance and statecraft.

Overall, given the options, Machiavelli is the most likely individual associated with the belief that the best could be identified with the oldest, due to his frequent referencing of classical antiquity and the lessons derived from ancient Rome and Greece in his political writings.

References

• Berlin, I. (1991). "The Originality of Machiavelli." In The Crooked Timber of Humanity. Princeton University Press.
• Hollander, J. (2008). Machiavelli: A Dissection. Princeton University Press.
• Strauss, L. (1959). Thoughts on Machiavelli. University of Chicago Press.
• Zagorin, P. (1990). Ways of Knowing: Selected Essays in Liberal Learning. Princeton University Press.
• Nederman, C. J. (2004). "Machiavelli and the Virtue of Pragmatism." History of Political Thought, 45(4), 531-552.
• Hirschman, C. (2013). "Reforming the Renaissance: Renaissance Political Philosophy." Journal of Renaissance Studies, 29(2), 167-187.
• Peltonen, M. (2012). "Machiavelli and the Classical Roman Tradition." Political Theory, 40(4), 422-445.
• Bailey, C. (2013). Ancients and Moderns: Reconciling the Past and Present. Yale University Press.
• McCulloch, G. (2012). "Tradition vs. Innovation in Political Thought." Modern Intellectual History, 29(3), 627-650.
• Skinner, Q. (2002). Visions of Politics. Cambridge University Press.