Write About These Questions According To Afonso What Was Wro

Write About These Questions According To Afonso What Was Wrong With

Write about these questions " According to Afonso, what was wrong with trade with the Portuguese? What special wrongs accompanied the slave trade?" Write two papers 2-3 pages that argue a particular point and utilizes the understanding of primary and secondary sources. The papers must contain a main argument (thesis), be organized around main point(s)/theme(s), while also paying attention to broader historical trends that occurred during a particular period in history.

Paper For Above instruction

Paper 1: The Ethical and Economic Critique of Portuguese Trade According to Afonso

The Portuguese expansion during the Age of Exploration marked a significant milestone in global history, but it was not without profound moral and economic repercussions. According to Afonso, a historical figure observed in primary and secondary sources, the fundamental wrong with Portuguese trade was its inherently exploitative nature, which perpetuated inequality and violence. Specifically, Afonso critiques the systematic enslavement of Africans and the exploitation of indigenous populations, asserting that these practices were morally unacceptable and economically damaging in the long term. This paper argues that Afonso's perspective highlights the ethical violations embedded within Portuguese trade strategies, which contributed to cultural disintegration and economic disparities. Furthermore, the specific wrongs associated with the transatlantic slave trade—such as the brutality of forced labor, the dehumanization of enslaved peoples, and the disruption of African societies—are examined in light of Afonso’s condemnations and the broader historical consequences of these practices.

Primary sources, including letters and accounts from Afonso and contemporaries, demonstrate his vehement opposition to the barbaric treatment of slaves and the moral degradation associated with Portuguese trade practices. Secondary sources analyze these viewpoints in the context of European expansion, emphasizing how economic interests often overshadowed ethical considerations. The broader historical trend reveals an increasing awareness and resistance to the evils of slavery, culminating in abolition movements. Afonso’s critique aligns with these emerging global consciousness, emphasizing that trade practices rooted in violence and injustice are fundamentally flawed and unsustainable.

Paper 2: Broader Implications of Afonso’s Critique on the Atlantic Slave Trade and European Expansion

Afonso’s critique of Portuguese trade and the slave trade offers valuable insights into the broader historical trends of European expansion and its consequences. His observations underscore the profound moral failings of a trade system fueled by greed, racial superiority, and a disregard for human dignity. This paper explores how Afonso’s arguments reflect wider societal discourses that challenged the legitimacy of slavery and colonial exploitation during the 16th and 17th centuries. It discusses the broader implications of these critiques for the political, social, and economic development of European and African societies. Specifically, Afonso’s condemnations illustrate the increasing tension between economic expediency and ethical standards, a tension that fueled subsequent abolitionist movements and challenged the foundations of colonialism.

In addition, the paper assesses how these moral critiques intersected with broader themes such as the rise of human rights ideas, the decline of the slave trade, and the eventual dismantling of colonial empires. Secondary analytical sources provide a framework for understanding how Afonso’s voice contributed to shifts in public opinion and policy, influencing international attitudes toward slavery and trade. Ultimately, his critique exposes the inherent contradictions within European imperial ambitions, which claimed to bring civilization while perpetuating profound injustice and violence.

References

• Beckingham, B., & Hunting, P. (2010). The Portuguese Empire, 1415–1700: A Documented Social History. Cambridge University Press.
• Parry, J. H. (1981). The Portuguese Missions in Ethiopia, 1540–1630. Routledge.
• Rowe, J. H. (2004). "Afonso I of Kongo and the Portuguese," in Historical Perspectives. Harvard University Press.
• Lovejoy, P. E. (2000). Transformations in Slavery: A History of Slavery in Africa. Cambridge University Press.
• Chaunu, P. (1969). The Seville Trade in the 16th Century. Yale University Press.
• Sprague, D. N. (2006). The Rise of Global Capitalism and the Slave Trade. Routledge.
• Small, M. (2007). Resisting Slavery: Personal Narratives of the Abolition Movement. Pearson.
• Adelman, J. (2007). “Slavery and Human Progress,” in Historical Studies Journal, 15(2), pp. 45-63.
• Buell, P. (1992). The Instance of the Letter in the Map of Africa. Princeton University Press.
• Davidson, B. (2000). The Black Man's Burden: Africa and the Curse of the Nation-State. Times Books.