Complete And Submit Your Graphic Organizer On Marriages
Complete And Submit Yourgraphic Organizeron Marriagesto Complete Th
Complete and submit your graphic organizer on marriages. To complete this assignment, review the Graphic Organizer on Marriages Guidelines and Rubric document. SCS 100 Theme 2: Marriage Graphic Organizer Using the three different representations of marriage presented in the learning block (polyandry, arranged marriages, and walking marriages), fill in the graphic organizer below. In Part A, you will have to first identify the biases you have regarding marriage and their influence on your perspective of marriage. In Part B, you will then take an objective stance and discuss the advantages and disadvantages of these types of marriage. In Part C, you will create a question a social scientist might ask to further the investigation of marriage. · In this first step, do your best to identify three of your biases on marriage due to your culture and religion. The American culture and legal system generally allow only one type of marriage. What type of bias does this embed in us? The religions that people belong to and practice can also impact their biases toward marriage, depending on how their chosen religion defines marriage. How does this influence your perspective of marriage in general? How does this bias influence your perspective on these specific types of marriage? Biases Bias 1: Bias 2: Bias 3: Influence of the Biases · While it is impossible to “check our culture and biases at the door”—and become totally objective, we can identify our biases (as you have already done above) and try to ignore them in order to consider other points of view. In this next step, take a culturally relativistic standpoint (in other words, try to overcome your biases) and consider the tenets of each type of marriage. Why might these other forms of marriage be more successful or advantageous in certain contexts than the Western concept of marriage (based on love and monogamy)? Then, from that same culturally relativistic standpoint, also consider some possible drawbacks to these forms of marriage. Type of Marriage Advantages Drawbacks Polyandry Arranged Marriages Walking Marriages · Create a question: In this learning block, you were given a lot of information about marriage and what marriage means in different cultures. You were also asked to think about what marriage means to you. The next step is to take the information you have been given and create a question a social scientist might ask to further the investigation of marriage. For example, after reading about arranged marriages, you might ask: Are rates of depression higher in women in arranged marriages? Social scientists use existing information to come up with new questions. This is the iterative process of social science research. SCS 100 Learning Block 3-4 Marriage Graphic Organizer Rubric Prompt: Complete and submit your Marriage Graphic Organizer. Instructor Feedback: This activity uses an integrated rubric in Blackboard. Students can view instructor feedback in the Grade Center. For more information, review these instructions. Critical Elements Proficient (100%) Needs Improvement (85%) Not Evident (0%) Value Engagement of Response Provides a response to parts a, b, and c in the graphic organizer Provides a response to parts a, b, or c but not to all three Does not provide a response to any parts of the organizer 30 Topical Response Provides responses that relate to personal biases, advantages and drawbacks of the three types of marriages presented Responses are only partially related to personal biases, advantages, and drawbacks of the three types of marriages presented Responses are not provided 30 Question Develops a question that social scientists might ask to further the investigation of marriage Develops a question, but the question is not relevant to content provided A question is not provided 30 Communicates Clearly Clearly communicates ideas and thoughts in graphic organizer Responses in graphic organizer needs clarification in order to support ideas presented Responses in graphic organizer are not legible and key ideas are not understandable 10 Total 100%
Sample Paper For Above instruction
Introduction
Marriage, an institution deeply embedded in cultural, religious, and societal norms, varies significantly across different societies. Understanding these variations requires an examination beyond Western notions of love and monogamy, exploring diverse forms such as polyandry, arranged marriages, and walking marriages. This paper aims to analyze personal biases about marriage, explore the advantages and disadvantages of these diverse marriage types from a culturally relativistic perspective, and formulate a research question that can further social scientific understanding of marriage practices.
Part A: Personal Biases and their Influence
My cultural background as an American, with its legal system supporting monogamous marriage based on love, has ingrained certain biases. For instance, I perceive monogamy as the ideal form of marriage, associating it with stability and emotional fulfillment. Religiously, Christianity emphasizes monogamy and often links marriage with spiritual sanctity, reinforcing my bias that marriage should be between two individuals based on mutual affection. These biases influence my perspective, potentially undervaluing other forms of marriage that are prevalent and accepted in different cultures.
Regarding specific types of marriage, my bias leads me to view arranged marriages skeptically, considering them less emotionally driven and more utilitarian. Conversely, walking marriages, common among the Mosuo people in China, challenge my bias with their emphasis on matrilineal relationships and consensual cohabitation without formal marriage bonds.
Part B: Cultural Relativistic Analysis of Marriage Types
Polyandry
- Advantages: Polyandry helps conserve family resources in regions with scarce land, reduces population pressure, and promotes economic stability among siblings sharing a wife.
- Drawbacks: It can limit individual autonomy, create complex familial relationships, and lead to social tension or jealousy among spouses.
Arranged Marriages
- Advantages: They often ensure social stability, align family interests, and can be tailored to preserve cultural or economic ties.
- Drawbacks: They may limit personal choice, emotional connection, and could lead to dissatisfaction or higher rates of mental health issues.
Walking Marriages
- Advantages: Promote gender equality, personal freedom, and flexible relationships that adapt to individual needs.
- Drawbacks: Can lack formal security, social legitimacy, and may cause uncertainty about long-term commitments.
Part C: Research Question
A relevant research question a social scientist might explore is: "How do different cultural views on marriage influence individual well-being and relationship satisfaction?" This question aims to investigate the impact of marriage practices on psychological health across cultures, providing insights into the effects of various matrimonial norms.
Conclusion
Understanding marriage through the lens of cultural relativism allows us to appreciate the diversity of marital practices worldwide. Recognizing our biases helps foster open-mindedness and enriches our comprehension of why different societies adopt particular matrimonial arrangements. Formulating research questions based on these diverse practices can contribute significantly to social science research, ultimately promoting a more inclusive understanding of human relationships.
References
- Baden, S. (2005). Marriage in cross-cultural perspective. Routledge.
- Goldstein, J. (2004). The evolution of marriage systems. Journal of Anthropological Research, 60(2), 20-35.
- Hershberger, K. (2004). Marriage practices and cultural values. Cultural Anthropology, 19(3), 45-59.
- McKinnon, C. (2013). Marriage and globalization. Global Perspectives in Sociology, 8(1), 89-105.
- Moore, H. L. (2011). Law and marriage in different societies. Anthropological Quarterly, 84(4), 913-935.
- Skolnik, M. (2010). Marriage in Africa: dynamics and diversity. African Studies Review, 53(2), 53-70.
- Tsang, S. (2017). Marriage, kinship, and social change. Cambridge University Press.
- Yoon, E. (2016). Marriage dynamics among the Mosuo people. Cultural Sociology, 10(2), 215-230.
- Zhou, M. (2014). Cultural influences on marriage practices in East Asia. Asian Anthropology, 13(4), 389-404.
- Smith, J. (2020). Secularization and marriage in the United States. Sociological Perspectives, 63(1), 45-67.