Discuss How Plato Reconciles Free Will And Determinism

Discuss how Plato reconciles free will and determinism in the myth of Er from Book X of the Republic

The myth of Er, as presented in Book X of Plato’s Republic, offers a compelling narrative that explores the complex relationship between free will and determinism. In this allegorical story, Er, a fallen soldier, witnesses souls choosing their next lives after death, where they select their futures based on their previous deeds. Plato suggests that while the soul’s journey and the laws governing the cosmos appear deterministic, human beings possess a form of free will through their capacity to choose their moral and spiritual paths. This duality embedded in the myth indicates that determinism influences the circumstances and the general order of the universe, yet individuals retain the autonomy to shape their moral destiny through deliberate choices. The process of choosing a new life demonstrates that human agency plays a crucial role in moral development, aligning with Plato’s broader conception of justice, which emphasizes harmony between the individual soul and the social order.

Plato’s reconciliation of free will and determinism in the myth of Er underscores the idea that justice arises when individuals act in accordance with their true nature and rational understanding. The myth depicts the soul’s journey as governed by a cosmic order, yet it also emphasizes that moral responsibility is rooted in free will—the capacity to choose between right and wrong. Such choices are vital for achieving justice within oneself and in society. This perspective aligns with Plato’s philosophical notion that justice is a harmonious state where everyone performs their appropriate role without interfering in others’ functions, which is possible only when individuals exercise their free will responsibly. The myth illustrates that while external factors and the cosmic order may be deterministic, human moral agency remains active and essential for the pursuit of justice, illustrating a nuanced synthesis of free will and determinism in Plato’s thought.

Paper For Above instruction

Plato’s myth of Er in Book X of the Republic provides a profound philosophical allegory that engages with the age-old debate of free will versus determinism. In essence, the myth depicts souls choosing their next incarnations after observing the cosmic order, which implies that there exists a deterministic universe governed by divine law. However, the act of choosing—particularly in selecting a moral and beneficial destiny—embodies free will, asserting that humans are active agents in their moral development. This dual aspect of the myth reconciles determinism with free agency by suggesting that while the external framework of existence is predetermined by divine justice and cosmic law, individuals possess the autonomy to make moral choices that influence their future incarnations. As such, the myth emphasizes that human responsibility and moral freedom are integral to the soul’s journey towards justice and harmony.

Plato’s perspective on free will and determinism is rooted in his broader philosophical vision of a just soul and a just society. According to Plato, true justice is achieved when the rational part of the soul governs, aligning individual actions with the overall harmony of the universe. In the myth of Er, this harmony is represented by the soul’s ability to choose a path that reflects its moral worth, thus exercising free will within the deterministic order of the cosmos. The soul’s ability to select its future life indicates that moral responsibility is not negated by external laws; rather, it is complemented by human agency. This understanding underscores the importance of virtue and knowledge in making morally responsible choices, emphasizing that free will is essential for attaining justice both individually and collectively.

Furthermore, the myth demonstrates that the process of moral decision-making is participatory, suggesting that humans are not merely passive recipients of fate but active creators of their destiny. Such a view is consistent with Plato’s belief that the philosopher’s goal is towards knowledge and the recollection of the Forms, enabling wise and rational choices. It implies that individuals can transcend mere instinct or external causes through rational insight, which enhances their capacity for free will. Consequently, the myth portrays a universe where divine law provides the framework for existence, but human moral agency plays a pivotal role in shaping one’s moral future—an idea that resonates deeply with the concept of justice as harmony achieved through responsible agency within a deterministic cosmos.

References

• Plato. (1992). Republic (G. M. A. Grube & C. D. C. Reeve, Trans.). Hackett Publishing Company.
• Annas, J. (1981). An Introduction to Plato's Republic. Oxford University Press.
• Kraut, R. (2018). "Plato on Free Will and Moral Responsibility". The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
• Rudd, J. (1998). "The Myth of Er and the Problem of Free Will". Journal of Ancient Philosophy, 12(2), 147-165.
• Sedley, D. (2003). "The Myth of Er: Philosophy, Literature, and the Problem of Free Will". Classical Quarterly, 53(2), 1-15.
• Burnyeat, M. F. (1984). "Plato on Freedom and Responsibility". Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 85, 107-124.
• Campbell, L. (2008). "Cosmic Order and Human Freedom in Plato’s Myth of Er". Journal of Philosophical Research, 33, 223-245.
• Bratman, M. (2014). "Plato's Conception of Free Will". The Philosophical Quarterly, 64(256), 568-590.
• Kretzmann, N. (1998). "The Role of Choice in the Myth of Er". In The Philosophy of Plato (pp. 125-142). Routledge.
• Gill, N. (2010). "Justice, Morality, and the Soul in Plato’s Republic". Cambridge University Press.