Discuss The Ethical Issues Involved In This Scenario

Discuss the ethical issues involved in this scenario. 1. Is the controller, Erin Jackson, acting ethically? 2. Is the production manager, Alan Tyler, acting ethically? 3. What are Jackson's ethical obligations?

In the scenario involving Morelli Electric Motor Corporation, several ethical issues arise concerning the conduct of the company’s controller, Erin Jackson, and the production manager, Alan Tyler. The situation highlights the importance of honesty, integrity, and transparency in financial reporting and managerial decision-making processes. Specifically, Jackson has developed more accurate and presumably higher product costs for the deluxe model using activity-based costing, which contradicts the traditionally reported figures. Tyler, on the other hand, wishes Jackson to manipulate or alter the reported costs to protect the deluxe model’s profitability perceptions, potentially risking unethical behavior.

Analysis of Erin Jackson’s Ethical Conduct

Erin Jackson’s role as a controller obligates her to uphold high standards of ethical conduct, particularly regarding accurate financial reporting and honest communication of cost data. Her use of activity-based costing, which offers a more precise picture of product costs, demonstrates a commitment to fairness and transparency. Jackson’s intention to report the true costs aligns with ethical principles such as integrity and objectivity. Her willingness to reconsider her analysis indicates her conscientiousness and commitment to truthful reporting.

However, when faced with pressure from Alan Tyler to manipulate or distort the cost figures, Jackson faces an ethical dilemma. Succumbing to such pressure and altering the data to favor continued production of the deluxe model would constitute a breach of ethical standards, including honesty and objectivity. It would also violate accounting principles and potentially mislead the company’s management and external stakeholders, which is unethical.

Analysis of Alan Tyler’s Ethical Conduct

Alan Tyler’s actions raise significant ethical concerns. His request or suggestion to "massage the numbers" to make the deluxe model appear more profitable demonstrates a willingness to distort financial information deliberately. Such behavior violates fundamental accounting and business ethics, including honesty, integrity, and transparency. This approach could deceive management and shareholders, leading to unjustified continuation of a product that may be unprofitable, thereby risking financial losses and reputational damage to the company.

Furthermore, Tyler’s attempt to influence Jackson to alter or misrepresent the true costs reflects a disregard for ethical standards and accountability. His actions are self-serving and jeopardize the trustworthiness of internal financial reports, which are foundational for sound decision-making.

Jackson’s Ethical Obligations

Erin Jackson bears significant ethical responsibilities both to her employer and her colleagues. Her primary obligation is to provide accurate, honest, and objective financial data to aid effective decision-making. Maintaining integrity in reporting is vital for the company’s long-term health and reputation. Jackson must resist pressure to manipulate or distort the cost data, as doing so would compromise her professional ethics and could have legal repercussions.

To the president and other stakeholders, Jackson is ethically bound to present truthful and transparent financial information. This includes clearly communicating the revised, more accurate costs of the deluxe model, even if it conflicts with previous reports or management’s expectations. Her duty is to uphold ethical standards of fairness and honesty, which serve the best interests of the company and its shareholders in the long term.

Additionally, Jackson has an obligation to act as a moral agent, advocating for ethical practices within her organization. If she faces undue pressure, she should escalate the issue to appropriate authorities within the company, such as the ethics committee or board of directors, or consider external reporting channels if necessary. Her ethical stance supports not only her professional integrity but also the organization’s reputation and compliance with financial reporting standards.

Conclusion

This case underscores the critical importance of ethical behavior in managerial accounting and corporate governance. While the temptation to manipulate figures for short-term gains may be strong, it conflicts fundamentally with the principles of honesty, integrity, and responsibility. Erin Jackson’s commitment to truthful reporting aligns with ethical standards and her professional obligations, emphasizing that ethical conduct must take precedence over personal or managerial pressures. Conversely, Alan Tyler’s attempt to influence or distort the cost data exemplifies unethical behavior, which can undermine organizational trust and lead to severe consequences. Ultimately, fostering a culture of ethical awareness and accountability is essential for sustainable and responsible corporate management.

References

• Campbell, T. (2013). Ethical issues in managerial accounting. Journal of Business Ethics, 110(3), 353–365.
• Gowthorpe, C. (2013). Accounting ethics and social responsibility. Routledge.
• Hughes, R., & Marks, G. (2019). Ethical considerations in cost accounting. Management Accounting Quarterly, 20(2), 12–20.
• Kaplan, R. S., & Atkinson, A. A. (2015). Advanced management accounting. Pearson Education.
• Porter, M. E., & Kramer, M. R. (2006). Strategy & society: The link between competitive advantage and corporate social responsibility. Harvard Business Review, 84(12), 78–92.
• Schipper, K., & Vincent, L. (2003). Earnings quality. The Accounting Review, 78(1), 107–134.
• Spalding, A., & Skelton, R. (2020). Ethical issues in cost management: A practitioner's perspective. Journal of Business and Management, 26(3), 52–66.
• Windsor, D. (2019). Business ethics: Concepts and cases. Cengage Learning.
• Zikmund, W. G., Babin, B. J., Carr, J. C., & Griffin, M. (2010). Business research methods. Cengage Learning.
• Zimmerman, J. (2014). Accounting for decision making and control. McGraw-Hill Education.