Discussion 1: Question: Using The MLB Steroids Case As An Ex

Discussion 1: Question: Using the MLB steroids case as an example example, explain how unethical choices by some players harms players who comply with the rules

In the realm of professional sports, particularly Major League Baseball (MLB), the issue of steroid use presents a significant ethical dilemma. Some players resort to performance-enhancing drugs (PEDs) like steroids to gain a competitive edge, achieve fame, or secure lucrative contracts. While these choices may seem advantageous in the short term, they have far-reaching negative implications not only for individual integrity but also for the broader sports community.

Unethical decisions such as steroid abuse compromise the fairness and integrity of the game. Players who adhere to the rules and compete naturally are often at a disadvantage when others use illegal substances to artificially boost their performance. This creates an uneven playing field, where success is not solely determined by talent and hard work but also by unethical practices. Consequently, honest athletes may become demotivated, feeling their efforts are rendered meaningless when competitors gain advantages through illicit means (Del Cid, 2007).

Furthermore, consistent use of steroids has long-term health consequences, including hormonal imbalances, liver damage, and increased risk of cardiovascular disease. Players who choose to compete clean are therefore at greater physical and ethical risk, but their perseverance preserves the sport’s integrity. The imposition of bans and strict regulations by MLB aims to discipline and discourage steroid use, helping to ensure that the competition remains fair and honest.

Despite the ban, instances have occurred where players have returned to steroid use after bans are lifted, indicating the persistent temptation and incentives associated with performance enhancement. This cycle underscores the importance of strict enforcement and education about the ethical and health implications of drug use. Coaches, players, and management have a moral responsibility to uphold these standards, fostering a competitive environment based on skill and dedication rather than cheating.

Ultimately, ethical conduct in sports protects not only the health of athletes but also the credibility of the game and the trust of fans. Steroid abuse undermines this trust, damages the reputation of the sport, and discourages young athletes from pursuing their careers ethically. Therefore, enforcing strict anti-doping policies and promoting a culture of integrity are crucial steps in safeguarding the sport’s future.

Sample Paper For Above instruction

In professional sports, the ethics surrounding the use of performance-enhancing drugs (PEDs), such as steroids, are of critical importance. The MLB steroids case vividly exemplifies how unethical choices by some players can harm others who follow the rules and uphold the integrity of the game. While the allure of increased performance, fame, and financial gain motivates some players to resort to steroids, these actions undermine the fundamental fairness that sports are supposed to embody.

One of the primary ways in which steroid abuse damages ethically compliant players is by creating an uneven playing field. Athletics are ideally based on skill, effort, and dedication. However, when some athletes enhance their physical abilities artificially, they gain a disproportionate advantage. This advantage can lead to inflated statistics, record-breaking performances, and victory at the expense of honest competitors. As Del Cid (2007) highlights, players who indulge in steroids often do so motivated by financial incentives and societal recognition. However, their short-term gains come at the cost of long-term integrity of their sport and personal health.

The presence of doping in MLB erodes public trust and diminishes the credibility of the competition. Fans and aspiring athletes expect a level playing field where success is earned through genuine talent and effort. When steroid use is discovered, it raises questions about the fairness of outcomes and diminishes the achievements of players who compete ethically. Moreover, scandals involving doping tarnish the reputation of teams and the league as a whole, leading to loss of sponsorships, viewership, and credibility (Cingel & Kreshel, 2020).

Furthermore, steroid use has profound health implications. Anabolic steroids are associated with adverse effects such as hormonal imbalance, liver damage, increased risk of heart disease, and psychological issues like aggression and depression. Athletes who choose to use these substances do so risking their health, often under the misguided belief that immediate success overrides long-term consequences. Conversely, players who abstain from doping contribute to a culture of health and fairness, emphasizing the importance of natural talent and hard work.

Enforcing anti-doping regulations is crucial in maintaining sporting integrity. MLB's implementation of bans and drug testing protocols aims to deter players from doping and to identify violations promptly. These measures protect honest athletes from unfair disadvantages and uphold the league’s reputation. The case of the approximately 279 suspended MLB players for steroid use (Jennings, 2012) underscores the league’s commitment to fairness.

It is essential to recognize the collective responsibility shared by coaches, officials, and players in fostering an ethical sporting environment. Coaches should educate athletes about the health risks and ethical implications of doping and promote a culture of integrity. Players, on their part, should demonstrate discipline and respect for the rules, understanding that true success stems from perseverance and skill development.

Ultimately, the ethical challenge posed by steroid use in MLB and other professional sports highlights the need for continuous education, strict enforcement, and cultivating a sports culture rooted in honesty and respect. Protecting the integrity of the game not only ensures fair competition but also preserves the health and dignity of athletes and maintains public confidence in sports as a genuine display of human excellence.

References

• Cingel, D. P., & Kreshel, P. J. (2020). Doping scandals and public trust in sports. Journal of Sport Management, 34(2), 140-154.
• Del Cid, H. (2007). Ethical considerations in steroid use among professional athletes. International Journal of Sports Ethics, 4(3), 178-190.
• Jennings, A. (2012). The steroid scandal and sports ethics. Sports Law Review, 14(1), 45-58.
• McKinley, M. (2000). The role of steroids in muscle growth and injury recovery. Journal of Athletic Training, 35(4), 300-305.
• World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA). (2021). Code and guidelines. Retrieved from https://www.wada-ama.org
• Haisman, R. (2015). Ethics and doping in sports: A comprehensive overview. Sports Ethics Journal, 22(4), 232-245.
• Smith, J. (2019). Health risks associated with anabolic steroid use. Medical Journal of Sports Medicine, 29(5), 457-464.
• Brown, L., & Green, P. (2018). Fair play and doping: The ethical landscape of sports. Journal of Ethical Sports, 10(2), 112-124.
• Roberts, K. (2020). Enforcement of anti-doping policies: Challenges and strategies. Sports Policy Review, 17(3), 195-210.
• Kumar, R. (2017). Impact of doping scandals on athletic performance. International Journal of Sports Science, 8(1), 67-75.