Ethical Research In Criminal Justice: Much Of What Is Done I

Ethical Research In Criminal Justicemuch Of What Is Done In The Field

Ethical Research in Criminal Justice Much of what is done in the field of criminal justice, whether knowingly or unknowingly, is impacted by some form of research. Conducting research in the field of criminal justice is important because it can help to inform best practices and serve as a form of checks and balances across various aspects of the criminal justice system. While research can be beneficial to the field of criminal justice, if the proper research methodologies and guidelines are not followed research can be harmful to participants and to the operational components in the field of criminal justice. In order to ensure the production of the least amount of harm associated with a research study, ethical guidelines have been established by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS). Many agencies, including criminal justice related agencies such as the U.S. Department of Justice, use the DHHS model policy on human research subjects to create their own human subjects policies. For this assignment, complete the following: 1) explore empirical research in the field of criminal justice, 2) evaluate the importance of empirical research to the field justice, and 3) identify ethical considerations associated with conducting empirical research in the field of criminal justice. To accomplish this task, imagine yourself as one of the following: 1) superior court judge 2) commander of the patrol division of a police department 3) chief juvenile probation officer, or 4) deputy warden of treatment in a prison. Also, imagine that you live and work in “Normal City.†This city has all the amenities that one could desire in a large city and all of the peace and quiet that one could desire in a small town. The beach, countryside, and local attractions are all within a reasonable driving distance. All the schools range in various levels of specialization, accreditation, and extracurricular activities. Housing and property values fall within the average range of any city anywhere else. Crime rates are comparable to those found in any other city that would have similar amenities, attractions, and opportunities. Using the role that you have chosen and the background information about Normal City, complete the following tasks in each section: Section 1: Conducting Empirical Research in Criminal Justice 1) Identify the role you have chosen. 2) Identify a topic that empirical research could be used to explore in your chosen role. 3) Based on the topic you selected, develop a research question and/or hypothesis you want to empirically explore. 4) Identify whether your research focus will be pure research or applied research. 5) Identify whether your research design will be qualitative research or quantitative research. Section 2: Importance of Empirical Research in Criminal Justice 1) Discuss why conducting empirical research on the research question you developed is important to the field of criminal justice. Section 3: Ethics& Empirical Research 1) For the topic that you selected, explore the related ethical issues by addressing the following questions: a) What procedures need to be avoided to reduce the amount of harm (i.e., conducting unethical research) experienced by respondents during this research? How would you honor the commitments made to respondents and respect reciprocity? b) What steps would you need to take to ensure that you were objective and professional in conducting the research and reporting research results? c) What measures would you need to take to ensure that the respondents’ confidentiality and privacy were protected? 2) Further explore ethical considerations related to conducting empirical research in the field of criminal justice by responding to the following tasks: a) Discuss how a research study related to your chosen topic could involve the collaboration of a local college or university and/or a local community organization. b) Discuss the role of the institutional review board regarding evaluating whether or not your study protects human subjects. Section 4: Conclusion 1) Based on your discussions about empirical research in the field of criminal justice, the importance of empirical research to the field of criminal justice, and ethical considerations related to conducting empirical research in the field of criminal justice, what guidance would you give your agency to ensure that the research study was ethically conducted from start to finish?

Paper For Above instruction

As a chief juvenile probation officer in the tranquil yet vibrant city of Normal City, my focus on juvenile behavior and rehabilitation provides an essential lens into the importance of empirical research in criminal justice. This role involves working directly with juvenile offenders to facilitate their integration into society while minimizing recidivism. To explore a pertinent issue within this role, I would focus on the effectiveness of diversion programs aimed at reducing juvenile reoffending rates. Specifically, a research question I might pose is: “Does participation in diversion programs significantly reduce recidivism among juvenile offenders in Normal City?” My hypothesis would be that juveniles involved in diversion programs exhibit lower re-offense rates compared to those who undergo traditional judicial proceedings. This research focus would be categorized as applied research, aiming to inform and improve existing juvenile justice practices in our city. The research design I would employ would be quantitative, utilizing statistical analysis of recidivism rates among program participants versus non-participants.

The importance of this empirical research lies in its potential to provide concrete data to support policy decisions. By understanding whether diversion programs effectively reduce juvenile re-offending, my agency can allocate resources more efficiently and develop targeted interventions. Empirical evidence can help justify the expansion of successful programs or, conversely, highlight areas needing modification. In a broader context, such research contributes to the field by advancing evidence-based practices, ultimately improving outcomes for juvenile offenders and enhancing community safety.

However, conducting research involving juvenile offenders necessitates rigorous ethical considerations. To mitigate harm, procedures such as obtaining informed consent, ensuring voluntary participation, and clarifying the non-coercive nature of participation are essential. Researchers must avoid tactics that could compel participation or cause emotional distress, such as coercive incentives or deceptive practices. Respecting reciprocity involves maintaining transparency about research aims and outcomes, and offering participants access to resources or information that could benefit them. Ensuring objectivity entails adhering to standardized data collection and analysis protocols, avoiding bias, and accurately reporting results regardless of whether they support initial hypotheses.

Protection of confidentiality and privacy is paramount, especially considering the vulnerability of juvenile participants. Data must be stored securely, with identifiers removed or coded, and access limited to authorized personnel. Additionally, all research procedures should comply with legal protections afforded to minors, such as parental consent and juvenile privacy laws.

The ethical conduct of research also benefits from collaboration with academic institutions. For instance, partnering with a nearby university’s criminal justice department could enhance methodological rigor and provide educational opportunities for students. Community organizations could assist with outreach and ensure that research benefits the local population. The institutional review board (IRB) plays a critical role in evaluating whether the study design is ethically sound, focusing on risks to participants versus potential benefits, and ensuring compliance with federal regulations concerning human subjects. The IRB’s assessment safeguards participants’ rights and welfare, emphasizing informed consent, confidentiality, and minimal harm.

In conclusion, empirical research plays an indispensable role in shaping effective and ethical criminal justice policies. For my agency, a guiding principle for ethical research would be a commitment to transparency, respect for participants, and adherence to legal standards. Ensuring that research is ethically conducted from inception to dissemination not only protects individuals’ rights but also bolsters public trust and the integrity of criminal justice practices. By cultivating strong partnerships with academic institutions and diligently complying with IRB protocols, my agency can contribute valuable, ethically sound insights that advance both practice and policy in the realm of juvenile justice.

References

• Adu, M., & Rolle, J. (2013). Empirical Research and the Criminal Justice System. Journal of Criminal Justice Studies, 29(4), 337-351.
• Babbie, E. (2015). The Basics of Social Research. Cengage Learning.
• Gerrig, R. J., & Zimbardo, P. G. (2018). Psychology and Life. Pearson.
• Hagan, J., & Palloni, A. (2002). Crime, Family, and Social Control. Journal of Social Issues, 58(2), 255-274.
• Policy and Procedures for Research with Minors. National Institutes of Health (NIH). (2020). https://www.nih.gov
• Resnik, D. B. (2018). The Ethics of Research with Human Subjects. Routledge.
• Shadish, W. R., Cook, T. D., & Campbell, D. T. (2002). Experimental and Quasi-Experimental Designs for Generalized Causal Inference. Houghton Mifflin.
• Siegel, L. J. (2017). Criminology: The Core. Nelson Education.
• U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2018). Federal Policy for the Protection of Human Subjects ('Common Rule'). https://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/regulations-and-policy/regulations/common-rule/index.html
• Wilson, J. Q., & Kelling, G. L. (1982). Broken Windows. Atlantic Monthly, 249(3), 29-38.