Executive Summary: This Paper Addresses Issues And Decisions

Executive Summarythis Paper Address Issues And Decisions Need To Be Ma

Executive Summarythis Paper Address Issues And Decisions Need To Be Ma

Executive Summary: This paper addresses issues and decisions that need to be made by Clique Pens to meet its short-term objectives of increasing profit margin, working with retailers, and raising customer awareness. The main decision revolves around whether Clique Pens should increase prices and reallocate funds from discounts, allowances, and off-invoice deals to a more profitable Market Development Funds (MDF) program. Additionally, the company must determine how to manage conflicting needs between sales and marketing departments regarding MDF usage and bridge the gap between these units.

Objectives & Goals: The core problem facing Clique Pens is a 6% decrease in gross profits over the past two years. The objective is to develop a strategic plan within 48 hours that can help increase gross profits, enhance collaboration with retailers, and boost brand awareness and customer loyalty.

Analysis: An industry assessment through Porter’s Five Forces reveals that Clique Pens operates in a highly competitive environment with significant pressures from various angles. The bargaining power of end consumers is high, especially with the rise of e-commerce, which accounts for a 37% growth in online sales and indicates changing consumer behaviors. Consumers, especially in the high-end segment, possess brand awareness but limited brand loyalty, making them sensitive to price and display factors. Retailers hold substantial power, often requiring high trade discounts to secure shelf space. Online retailers, although currently less influential than brick-and-mortar retailers, are rapidly growing and should be considered as potential partners.

The competitive rivalry within the industry is intense, with over 50 brands vying for market share in a market valued at approximately $12 billion nationally, with writing implements accounting for $2.4 billion. Clique’s core competency lies in its unique ink formula, providing an advantage amidst low product differentiation. Supplier power is low due to abundant raw materials and flexible sourcing options, allowing Clique to negotiate favorable prices globally. However, threats from substitutes arise as electronic communication continues to reduce demand for handwritten notes and pens, potentially affecting the industry’s future. Barriers to entry are high due to the need for substantial marketing investment to establish a foothold against established competitors.

Assumptions: It is assumed that competitors will maintain similar budget allocations; that industry growth will persist over the next five to ten years, and that digital trends will continue influencing consumer habits.

Alternatives and Strategic Decisions

Given the need to shift away from discount-heavy tactics, Clique Pens faces a pivotal decision: whether to prioritize a customer-oriented MDF, a retail-oriented MDF, or a hybrid approach. Several options are considered:

Customer-Oriented MDF:

This approach involves reducing trade discounts and increasing investments in advertising and direct consumer promotions. The potential benefit includes a projected 5% increase in retail sales and a rise in profit margin from 36% to 38%. It also enhances brand visibility and consumer engagement, potentially capturing greater market share. However, this strategy carries risks; retailers may resist price increases, which could lead to loss of shelf space and sales to competitors. Furthermore, McMillan, vice president of sales, anticipates over a 9% sales decline if discounts are reduced prematurely.

Retail-Oriented MDF:

This approach emphasizes providing incentives directly to retailers, focusing less on consumer advertising. The proposed benefits include expanded shelf space and a modest margin increase of about 3.5%, with potential market share growth of 0.4%. Nonetheless, reducing consumer-oriented marketing could diminish brand awareness, impacting long-term sales and customer loyalty. Retailers may also prioritize discounts over MDF funds, which might not effectively address the company's broader strategic aims.

Hybrid Strategy:

The most balanced approach involves integrating both strategies—encouraging cooperation between marketing and sales teams through a hybrid MDF plan. This comprehensive tactic would foster long-term brand growth, reinforce relationships with retailers, and ensure consumer engagement. The inclusion of online retail channels should be considered, aligning with current industry trends toward digital expansion. This hybrid model aims to optimally allocate resources, increase profitability, and maintain competitive advantage in a challenging industry environment.

Action Plan

Clique Pens should pursue a hybrid MDF strategy that balances both customer and retailer needs while emphasizing long-term brand development. This involves reallocating funds to support targeted advertising campaigns, digital marketing efforts, and selective retailer incentives. Strengthening digital presence through e-commerce partnerships and online advertising would be vital as industry dynamics shift increasingly online. Additionally, fostering closer collaboration between sales and marketing divisions will help align objectives, optimize MDF utilization, and improve overall effectiveness.

Implementing this integrated approach will require close monitoring and data-driven adjustments. Regular evaluation of sales performance, customer feedback, and retailer satisfaction will be critical to refining MDF allocations. Moreover, engaging with key stakeholders and ensuring transparent communication will facilitate smoother implementation and buy-in across departments. Ultimately, this strategic pivot aims to increase gross profits, expand market share, and sustain long-term growth amidst intensifying competition and technological change.

References

• Porter, M. E. (2008). Competitive strategy: Techniques for analyzing industries and competitors. Free Press.
• Kotler, P., & Keller, K. L. (2016). Marketing management (15th ed.). Pearson Education.
• Schmidt, R. (2019). Industry analysis and competitive strategies in writing instruments. Journal of Business Research, 102, 245-257.
• MarketLine. (2023). Writing implements industry profile. MarketLine Industry Profiles.
• NPD Group. (2015). U.S. writing instruments industry sales analysis. NPD Reports.
• Gale, B. T. (2011). Creating competitive advantage. Business Expert Press.
• Kim, W. C., & Mauborgne, R. (2004). Blue ocean strategy. Harvard Business Review, 82(10), 76-84.
• Christopher, M. (2016). Logistics & supply chain management (5th ed.). Pearson UK.
• Chaffey, D., & Ellis-Chadwick, F. (2019). Digital marketing. Pearson.
• Hitt, M. A., Ireland, R. D., & Hoskisson, R. E. (2017). Strategic management: Concepts and cases: Competitiveness and globalization. Cengage Learning.