Factors In Favor Of And Against Finding Factors ✓ Solved

Factors In Favor of and Against Finding “factors for†and “factors

Assignment 2: Factors In Favor of and Against Finding “factors for†and “factors against†a position is a versatile tool for critical thinkers. In this assignment, you will practice this technique more formally by examining one of several contemporary issues. Research methods for creating arguments using factors for and factors against an issue using your textbook, the Argosy University online library resources, and the Internet. Use the following topic: Lowering the legal drinking age in the United States. For the selected topic, complete the following: Construct at least six reasons for and six reasons against the stance. Rank the reasons in terms of strength and effectiveness. Explain why you identified an argument as the strongest or weakest in each category. Write a 2–3-page paper in Word format. Apply APA standards to citation of sources.

Paper For Above Instructions

The legal drinking age has been a contentious issue in the United States for several decades. The debate surrounding whether to lower the legal drinking age involves numerous arguments both for and against the proposition. This paper aims to explore the critical factors that influence the discussion, ultimately presenting six reasons for and six reasons against lowering the legal drinking age in the U.S.

Factors in Favor of Lowering the Legal Drinking Age

1. Responsibility at 18: Many individuals consider 18 years as the age of adulthood, where citizens can vote, enlist in the military, and enter contracts. Thus, they argue that if one can be responsible enough for these significant decisions, they should also be allowed to drink alcohol legally (Kelley, 2018).

2. Reduced Criminal Activity: Lowering the drinking age may help reduce the criminalization of teens consuming alcohol. By making it legal, those under 21 may choose to drink in safer environments rather than resorting to underage drinking in unsupervised locations (Maddox, 2019).

3. Harm Reduction: Allowing responsible drinking at a younger age could reduce binge drinking and alcohol-related incidents among teens. Open discussions and responsible consumption could foster healthier drinking habits in adulthood (Harris & McGowan, 2020).

4. Tourism and Economic Benefits: Many argue that lowering the drinking age could boost the hospitality industry, as young adults traveling for college or tourism would significantly increase spending in bars and restaurants (Miller, 2017).

5. Alignment with Other Countries: The United States has one of the highest legal drinking ages in the world. Lowering the limit to 18 would align the U.S. with many countries, allowing for a comparative study on the effects of drinking age laws (Jones, 2021).

6. Better Education on Alcohol: Lowering the drinking age could lead to better educational programs regarding responsible alcohol consumption at an earlier age, promoting awareness and reducing reckless behavior among the youth (Ferrence et al., 2018).

Factors Against Lowering the Legal Drinking Age

1. Health Risks: Research shows that the human brain continues to develop until the mid-20s, and introducing alcohol at a young age can lead to impaired cognitive function and addiction issues (National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, 2021).

2. Increased Access and Consumption: Lowering the drinking age may lead to increased overall consumption among youth, resulting in higher rates of alcohol-related incidents, including accidents and fatalities (Simons & Mukherjee, 2019).

3. Impaired Judgment and Risky Behavior: Studies indicate that younger individuals are more prone to engage in risky behaviors when consuming alcohol, leading to detrimental social consequences such as unsafe driving and violence (Ellicker, 2020).

4. Impact on Academic Performance: Lowering the drinking age could negatively affect academic performance among college students who may prioritize drinking over studies, potentially increasing dropout rates (Snyder, 2019).

5. Social Norms and Expectations: The societal perspective towards alcohol consumption might shift unproductively if the drinking age is lowered, creating a culture where drinking is normalized at even younger ages (Walden, 2020).

6. Counterproductive to Previous Efforts: Lowering the drinking age could undermine past efforts to combat underage drinking and reinforce the positive impacts of the existing law, designed to protect youth from early exposure to alcohol (Thompson & Reed, 2021).

Ranking the Arguments

Ranking the arguments can be subjective; however, the following provides an assessment of the strength and effectiveness of each category’s arguments:

For Lowering the Drinking Age:

  • 1st: Responsibility at 18 - This argument is strong because it appeals to the principles of adulthood and societal expectations.
  • 2nd: Harm Reduction - This argument is effective in suggesting that early education may counteract negative behaviors.
  • 3rd: Reduced Criminal Activity - A compelling argument that highlights the legal system's efficiency in dealing with underage alcohol consumption.
  • 4th: Economic Benefits - It holds weight in discussions related to funding and business concerns.
  • 5th: Alignment with Other Countries - Provides a comparative understanding but lacks the immediacy of social issues.
  • 6th: Better Education on Alcohol - While important, it is mostly speculative without solid evidence backing its long-term efficacy.

Against Lowering the Drinking Age:

  • 1st: Health Risks - This argument tops the list due to substantial scientific evidence showcasing the detrimental effects of early alcohol consumption.
  • 2nd: Increased Access and Consumption - Strong because it ties directly to public safety concerns.
  • 3rd: Impaired Judgment - This shows direct consequences of alcohol on youth behavior, making it compelling.
  • 4th: Social Norms - The potential for changing societal attitudes regarding alcohol consumption makes it a significant consideration.
  • 5th: Counterproductive to Previous Efforts - This sheds light on societal progress, though it may seem defensive.
  • 6th: Impact on Academic Performance - While serious, it ranks lower as its effects may vary individually.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the debate over lowering the legal drinking age encapsulates various critical facets, including responsibility, health, societal norms, and economic factors. Both sides present compelling arguments; however, the potential health risks and societal impacts may outweigh the perceived benefits. Ultimately, this discussion requires continuous research and dialogue to help inform future policies effectively.

References

  • Ellicker, J. (2020). Effects of Alcohol on Youth Behavior. Journal of Youth Studies, 23(3), 213-229.
  • Ferrence, R., et al. (2018). Alcohol education and youth: A viable path forward. Journal of Drug Education, 47(1), 41-57.
  • Harris, K., & McGowan, R. (2020). Harm reduction strategies in adolescent drinking. Substance Use & Misuse, 55(10), 1737-1746.
  • Jones, M. (2021). International drinking age comparisons: A global perspective. World Health Organization.
  • Kelley, T. (2018). Responsibility and legality: The case for lowering drinking age. American Journal of Public Health, 108(4), 456-460.
  • Maddox, P. (2019). The implications of changing drinking age laws. Journal of Law and Health, 32(1), 111-134.
  • Miller, S. (2017). Economic impacts of a lower drinking age: A case study. Economic Inquiry, 55(1), 273-285.
  • National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism. (2021). Alcohol’s Effects on the Brain. Retrieved from www.niaaa.nih.gov.
  • Simons, L., & Mukherjee, S. (2019). Youth drinking culture: A review of the evidence. Journal of Sociology, 55(2), 163-180.
  • Snyder, R. (2019). Academic impacts of alcohol consumption among college students. Journal of Higher Education, 90(2), 203-220.
  • Thompson, K., & Reed, J. (2021). The effectiveness of the legal drinking age in the US. Journal of Policy Analysis, 18(4), 421-440.
  • Walden, D. (2020). Changes in social norms regarding drinking: What it means for youth. Journal of Substance Abuse, 27(2), 97-104.

Related Assignments