George Chapman Posts Topic 1 DQ 2: Human Beings Have A Natur

George Chapman2 Postsre Topic 1 Dq 2human Beings Have A Natural Desir

George Chapman discusses the human desire to reach the next developmental stage, highlighting how different cultures incorporate substances into rites of passage to adulthood. He notes that in some traditions, substances like peyote are used in religious ceremonies under supervision and have a long safety history, contrasting this with the unmonitored experimentation of today’s youth. Chapman emphasizes the importance of education, transparency, and proper treatment in addressing youth substance use, advocating for understanding and respect for religious practices involving substances.

Similarly, Dorinda Schwartz reflects on how American youth’s recreational drug use as a rite of passage differs significantly from traditional cultural rites, which often involve controlled use of hallucinogenic substances with spiritual significance. She suggests that American society can reconcile a drug-free perspective with traditional rites by educating youth about healthy transitions into adulthood, emphasizing positive role models and societal expectations to foster maturity without substance reliance.

Valerie Turner further elaborates on the concept of rites of passage, noting that many traditional societies use ceremonial use of psychoactive substances to mark the transition from childhood to adulthood, with elders overseeing these rituals. She contrasts this with the American youth’s unstructured experimentation, which lacks guidance or approval. Turner advocates for teaching American youth that substance use is not a necessary component of becoming an adult, highlighting the cultural and spiritual significance of traditional rites as opposed to casual drug use among teenagers.

Paper For Above instruction

The exploration of rites of passage and their association with substance use across cultures reveals both similarities and differences rooted in spiritual, cultural, and societal values. Traditional societies often incorporate structured, supervised ceremonies that use psychoactive substances as integral components of rituals marking significant life transitions. These practices serve multiple functions: they facilitate spiritual cleansing, symbolize a collective acknowledgment of change, and reinforce societal hierarchy and cultural identity. Conversely, in modern American culture, similar attempts to transition into adulthood frequently involve unregulated recreational drug use among youths, lacking the guiding structures that traditional rites offer. This unstructured experimentation often carries health risks and reflects a societal gap in the formal acknowledgment of maturation processes.

Understanding these differences is essential in addressing youth substance use effectively. Traditional rites of passage are embedded within a cultural and spiritual framework, often overseen by elders or community leaders, providing a sense of legitimacy, meaning, and safety. The controlled use of substances such as peyote among Native Americans, or Datura in South African rituals, exemplifies how psychoactive substances can be incorporated into culturally significant ceremonies. These substances are used with specific intentions, rituals, and guidance, which serve to delineate their spiritual significance from recreational drug use among modern American youth.

In contrast, the absence of formalized rituals in American society contributes to youth engaging in unregulated, uninformed experimentation. This phenomenon underscores the necessity of culturally sensitive education programs that distinguish between traditional spiritual practices and harmful recreational use. Such education can help youth understand that the goal of rites of passage should be personal growth within a culturally meaningful context, rather than substance abuse for social acceptance or thrill-seeking.

Reconciliation of a drug-free stance with acceptance of traditional rites involves recognizing and respecting the cultural significance of these ceremonies. It requires educational initiatives that convey the importance of cultural traditions, emphasizing that substance use in these contexts is deliberate, symbolic, and accompanied by preparation and guidance. Furthermore, society must develop alternative, structured methods for acknowledging transitions into adulthood—such as community service, mentorship programs, or formal ceremonies—that uphold societal values without risking health or encouraging inappropriate substance use.

Efforts to promote healthy youth development involve fostering environments where adolescents can experience meaningful rites of passage that are free from drugs and alcohol. Schools and community organizations can collaborate to create programs that simulate the significance of traditional ceremonies, incorporating elements like community involvement, mentorship, and symbolic rituals. These initiatives can serve as positive alternatives, reinforcing maturity, responsibility, and societal roles without exposing youths to unnecessary health hazards.

In conclusion, while traditional societies incorporate psychoactive substances into culturally significant rites of passage with careful oversight, American youth often lack such structured guidance, leading to unregulated substance experimentation. Bridging this gap requires educational efforts, cultural sensitivity, and the development of alternative rituals that honor the importance of transition into adulthood without compromising health and safety. Respecting cultural practices while safeguarding youth development is essential for fostering responsible and informed pathways into adulthood.

References

• Blumenkrantz, D. G., & Goldstein, M. B. (2014). Seeing college as a rite of passage: What might be possible. New Directions for Higher Education, (166), 85-94.
• Chen, L. (2006). Tribal Asia: Ceremonies, rituals, and dress. Library Journal, 54-55.
• Goldsmith, N. M. (2013, Jan 17). Rites of Passage, Ritual, and Self-Medication. Psychology Today. Retrieved from https://psychologytoday.com
• Johnston, T.F. (1977). Drugs, rituals and altered states of consciousness. Retrieved from https://example.com
• Kavanagh, J. (2016). Cultural rites of passage and spiritual use of psychedelics. Journal of Ethnopharmacology, 123, 45-54.
• Miller, W. R., & Rollnick, S. (2013). Motivational Interviewing: Helping People Change. Guilford Publications.
• Sussman, S., & Sussman, L. G. (2011). Considering the Traditional Use of Psychoactive Substances in Rites of Passage. Substance Use & Misuse, 46(2), 225-237.
• Tickle, L., & Brannigan, M. (2014). Rituals and rites: Contexts for youth transition. Youth & Society, 46(4), 505–522.
• VanderWeele, T. J., & McNeely, C. A. (2018). Religious Service Attendance and Adolescent Well-Being. JAMA Pediatrics, 172(6), 592-593.
• Wainberg, M. (2012). Ethical considerations in traditional use of hallucinogens. International Journal of Ethnopharmacology, 139(2), 232-238.