Identify At Least Three Risks Auditors Should Consider

Identify At Least Three Risks That Auditors Need To Consider For Compa

Identify at least three risks that auditors need to consider for companies that process web-based sales transactions, including credit card payments. For each risk identified, develop a mitigation risk strategy. Provide specific examples. Identify specific controls and tests of controls related to IT governance, including: Organizing the IT function, controlling computer center operations, and designing an adequate disaster recovery plan.

Paper For Above instruction

In the digital age, companies that conduct web-based sales transactions face distinctive risks that auditors must carefully evaluate to ensure financial statement accuracy and operational integrity. The increasing reliance on online platforms and electronic payment systems introduces specific vulnerabilities, particularly in areas related to transaction occurrence, completeness, and security. This paper explores three critical risks that auditors should consider when auditing such companies, proposes mitigation strategies for each, and discusses relevant IT controls and tests aligned with effective IT governance.

1. Risk of Transaction Fraud and Unauthorized Transactions

The foremost concern in web-based transactions is the potential for fraudulent activities or unauthorized transactions. Malicious actors may attempt to manipulate the system to generate false sales, manipulate pricing, or execute unauthorized purchases. This risk is heightened by the interconnected nature of third-party payment processors, web hosting platforms, and banking systems, creating multiple points of vulnerability.

Mitigation Strategy: Implement strict access controls and authentication protocols for all personnel involved in the transaction process. Use multi-factor authentication for administrative access to the web platform and payment systems. Regularly monitor transaction logs for suspicious activity and discrepancies. Additionally, employ fraud detection software that analyzes transaction patterns for anomalies that may indicate fraudulent activity.

Examples of Controls and Tests: Controls include role-based access restrictions, transaction approval procedures, and real-time fraud detection algorithms. Testing involves reviewing access logs, verifying transaction records against payment processor statements, and inspecting the configuration and effectiveness of fraud detection tools.

2. Risk of Data Breach and Payment Card Fraud

Companies handling credit card payments are at high risk of data breaches that could expose sensitive customer payment information. Such breaches not only lead to financial losses and reputational damage but may also result in non-compliance with PCI DSS (Payment Card Industry Data Security Standards). Data breaches can occur due to inadequate security controls, vulnerabilities in server systems, or malicious attacks such as phishing or malware.

Mitigation Strategy: Enforce stringent cybersecurity protocols, including encryption of data in transit and at rest, regular vulnerability assessments, and timely patch management. Conduct employee training on data security best practices and implement intrusion detection and prevention systems. Ensuring compliance with PCI DSS requirements is essential for safeguarding customer data.

Examples of Controls and Tests: Controls include encryption policies, network segmentation, and intrusion detection systems. Tests involve vulnerability scans, penetration testing, and review of security compliance documentation. Regular audits of security policies and incident response procedures are also vital.

3. Risk of Data Integrity and Completeness in Transaction Records

The accuracy and completeness of transaction data are vital for financial reporting. The use of automated online systems reduces manual errors but introduces risks associated with system failures, hacking, or data corruption. If not properly controlled, transactions might be omitted or incorrectly recorded, leading to misstatement of revenues and expenses.

Mitigation Strategy: Establish comprehensive controls over data entry, processing, and reconciliation. Implement automated validation checks for data completeness and accuracy, including cross-verification with shipping, payment, and inventory systems. Regularly back up transaction data and maintain audit trails that record all changes.

Examples of Controls and Tests: Controls include automated reconciliation routines, limited access to transaction records, and audit trail logging. Testing involves inspecting reconciliation reports, verifying sample transactions against source documentation, and reviewing system change logs for unauthorized modifications.

IT Governance Controls: Organizing the IT Function, Controlling Operations, and Disaster Recovery

Effective IT governance underpins the robust control environment necessary for managing web-based sales systems. Organizing the IT function involves establishing clear roles, responsibilities, and accountability structures. Segregation of duties is essential to prevent conflicts of interest and errors.

Controlling computer center operations includes implementing physical and logical access controls, environmental safeguards, and monitoring systems to detect and prevent unauthorized access or disruptions. Regular audit logs and real-time monitoring are critical to maintaining operational integrity and security.

Designing an adequate disaster recovery plan (DRP) ensures resilience against system failures, cyber-attacks, or natural disasters. A comprehensive DRP includes data backup procedures, off-site storage, and clearly defined recovery procedures to restore essential systems promptly.

Controls for these areas include documented IT policies, periodic security assessments, and disaster recovery testing. Regular validation of backup and recovery procedures ensures the business can resume operations with minimal disruption.

Conclusion

As companies increasingly rely on web-based transactions, auditors must vigilantly consider risks related to fraud, data breaches, and data integrity. Implementing robust controls—both technological and procedural—is essential to mitigate these risks. Additionally, sound IT governance practices, including well-organized IT functions, controlled operations, and comprehensive disaster recovery plans, are critical to maintaining security, compliance, and operational continuity. A layered approach to risk management will enhance the reliability of financial reporting and protect the organization’s reputation in the digital marketplace.

References

• AlHogail, A. (2015). Designing information technology governance frameworks for organizations. Journal of Management and Engineering Informatics, 2(4), 35–44.
• COSO. (2013). Enterprise risk management—integrating with strategy and performance. Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission.
• ISO/IEC 27001. (2013). Information technology — Security techniques — Information security management systems — Requirements.
• PCI Security Standards Council. (2018). Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS) v3.2.1.
• Reza, S. (2019). Cybersecurity risk management and mitigation strategies for online businesses. Journal of Information Security, 10(3), 125–134.
• Siklós, S., & Győrffy, Z. (2016). IT governance and controls: An overview of methodologies and frameworks. Computer Standards & Interfaces, 48, 45–51.
• Stair, R., & Reynolds, G. (2019). Principles of Information Systems. Cengage Learning.
• Weill, P., & Ross, J. W. (2004). IT governance: How top performers manage IT decision rights for superior results. Harvard Business Review Press.
• Whitman, M. E., & Mattord, H. J. (2022). Principles of Information Security. Cengage Learning.
• ISO/IEC 27002. (2022). Code of practice for information security controls.