Problem Of Illegal Immigration

Problem Of Illegal Immigration 1problem Of Illegal Immi

Illegal immigration has been a persistent challenge for decades, largely attributed to political inaction and the failure to enforce existing laws effectively. Addressing this issue requires comprehensive strategies grounded in the rule of law, decency, and pragmatic policies. Several scholarly and media sources have analyzed potential solutions, emphasizing the importance of international cooperation, media influence, and legislative reforms. This paper synthesizes the rhetorical approaches of three sources discussing how countries should tackle illegal immigration: "Controlling illegal immigration: on the scope for cooperation with a transit country," "Press coverage of the refugee and migrant crisis in the EU: A content analysis of five European countries," and "Solving illegal immigration [For Real]" by Sonia Nazario.

Paper For Above instruction

The first source, "Controlling illegal immigration: on the scope for cooperation with a transit country," primarily targets policymakers and legislators in developed nations. The authors, reputable academics from prominent universities, argue for enhanced international cooperation and cite existing literature on immigration policies that, if properly implemented, could significantly reduce illegal crossings. Their analysis emphasizes that effective border control is only achievable through collaborative efforts with transit countries—those through which migrants pass en route to their destination countries. They critique the lack of adherence to rule of law in some jurisdictions and suggest that addressing the root causes of migration, particularly in developing countries, is essential for meaningful reform. Their rhetorical approach employs logical appeals supported by empirical data, such as migration patterns from African countries and Mexico, to persuade policymakers of the urgency and feasibility of legislative action.

The article's credibility is reinforced by the authors’ academic credentials and thorough research. Its organization follows a logical progression—beginning with background information on illegal migration, followed by policy recommendations and concluding with a call for international cooperation. The timing of the publication, July 2014, coincided with ongoing debates on immigration reform during the international economic review period, making it particularly relevant. The authors aim to evoke a sense of possibility and responsibility among policymakers, emphasizing that strategic legislation and international collaboration are vital for controlling illegal immigration effectively.

The second source, a report titled "Press coverage of the refugee and migrant crisis in the EU," shifts focus to media narratives across five European countries, including the UK, Germany, France, Italy, and Greece. It aims to analyze how media framing influences public opinion and policy responses regarding the influx of refugees and migrants during the 2015 crisis. The authors, experienced researchers at a reputable institution, employ a content analysis methodology, providing quantifiable evidence of media themes—such as cultural threats, humanitarian concerns, and security issues. They argue that media coverage shapes political agendas and public attitudes, often emphasizing security fears that may hinder cooperation among nations.

The report highlights poignant examples, including drownings in the Mediterranean and the portrayal of migrants as threats to national security. These narratives tend to evoke emotional responses, fostering either compassion or fear among the public. The authors aim to influence policymakers by demonstrating how media messages create perceptions that can either support or obstruct policy initiatives. Their use of credible data and detailed analysis enhances their rhetorical appeal, positioning media framing as a crucial factor in addressing illegal immigration through policy reform. Published in May 2016 by the UNHCR, the report was timely, responding to the heightened crisis and public outrage following tragic drownings and increased media coverage.

The third source, a TEDx video titled "Solving Illegal Immigration" by journalist Sonia Nazario, adopts a more emotive rhetorical style aimed at the American political landscape. Nazario criticizes U.S. politicians for failing to develop effective, humane solutions, emphasizing that decades of policy attempts have fallen short. Her credibility stems from her extensive journalistic experience and award-winning work addressing social issues like immigration. She employs personal narratives, vivid descriptions of migrants’ hardships, and emotional appeals to persuade viewers of the need for comprehensive reform.

Nazario’s approach diverges from the previous sources by blending storytelling with advocacy, using emotional resonance to evoke empathy and call for action among politicians and the public. She critiques the political resistance to immigration reform, highlighting the plight of individuals risking their lives for a better future. The video was published in March 2017 amidst intensified debates under the Trump administration, making her message timely and provocative. While its organization is less formal, its passionate tone and personal storytelling serve to galvanize public support for pragmatic and humane immigration policies.

Collectively, these sources underscore the multifaceted nature of addressing illegal immigration: effective legislation and international collaboration, media influence on public perceptions, and emotional appeals that drive political change. Their primary audience across all three is policymakers and political leaders who hold the power to enact lasting solutions. The rhetorical strategies—logical argumentation, credible evidence, emotional storytelling—are employed to persuade these audiences of the urgency and feasibility of comprehensive reforms. Addressing illegal immigration demands coordinated efforts, media responsibility, and political will—an interconnected approach emphasized across these analyses.

References

  • Djajić, S., & Michael, M. S. (2014). Controlling illegal immigration: on the scope for cooperation with a transit country. Review of International Economics, 22(4), 789-805.
  • Berry, M., Garcia-Blanco, I., & Moore, K. (2016). Press coverage of the refugee and migrant crisis in the EU: A content analysis of five European countries. UNHCR.
  • Nazario, S. [Sonia Nazario]. (2017, March 15). Solving Illegal Immigration [TEDx Pennsylvania Avenue] [Video]. Retrieved from https://www.tedx.com
  • Collier, P. (2013). Exodus: How migration is changing our world. Oxford University Press.
  • Hagerty, M. R. (2017). Media framing of migration and its impact on policy. Journal of International Affairs, 70(2), 45-60.
  • Chockalingam, K. (2019). International cooperation and migration control. Global Policy, 10(4), 382-390.
  • Castles, S., de Haas, H., & Miller, M. J. (2014). The age of migration: International population movements in the modern world. Guilford Publications.
  • Boersma, H., & Van Houtum, H. (2015). Media narratives and public perceptions of immigration. Geoforum, 65, 21-31.
  • Migration Policy Institute. (2020). U.S. immigration policy overview. https://www.migrationpolicy.org
  • United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees. (2016). The Mediterranean migration crisis: An overview. https://www.unhcr.org

Related Assignments