Q1. When Can You Identify Simon Ortiz's Narrative

Q1. At what point are you able to identify Simon Ortiz's narrator as Native American? How does this identity

Simon Ortiz’s narrator can be identified as Native American based on several key textual clues that point to a connection with Native history and cultural identity. The reference to “Sand Creek” is particularly significant, as it alludes to the Sand Creek Massacre of 1864, where numerous Cheyenne and Arapaho people were killed by U.S. volunteer soldiers. Mentioning “Sand Creek” situates the narrator within a specific Native historical context, emphasizing the collective trauma experienced by Indigenous communities. Additionally, the narrator’s depiction of being caught wandering among “old spoon and knives, sweaters and shoes” can symbolize the displacement and loss of cultural artifacts, resonating with the history of Indigenous dispossession. The line “my life was stolen already” further underscores themes of cultural theft and diminishment of Native identity, which are central to Native American narratives of colonization and resilience. The mention of “Carson” likely refers to John C. Frémont or a similar figure associated with U.S. military actions against Native peoples, framing the narrator’s experience within the broader context of colonization and conflict. This layered historical allusion, combined with themes of dispossession, loss, and cultural survival, distinctly marks the narrator as Native American. Recognizing this identity deepens the poem’s significance by highlighting ongoing struggles for sovereignty, cultural preservation, and the painful history embedded in Indigenous experiences.

Paper For Above instruction

Simon Ortiz’s poem poignantly reveals the Native American identity of its narrator through both explicit references and thematic undercurrents rooted in Indigenous history. The most overt indication of the narrator’s Native identity is the mention of “Sand Creek,” which refers to the infamous massacre where U.S. forces attacked a peaceful Cheyenne and Arapaho village in 1864. This historical allusion immediately situates the narrator’s perspective within a collective Indigenous trauma, symbolizing a history of violence, dispossession, and resilience (Thompson, 2017). By invoking Sand Creek, Ortiz’s narrator aligns their personal suffering with the broader narrative of Native suffering, emphasizing their rootedness in Native history and identity.

Furthermore, the imagery of wandering “among old spoon and knives, sweaters and shoes,” suggests encounters with remnants of colonialism and cultural erasure. The “old spoons and knives” can symbolize tools of everyday life that carry cultural significance, perhaps also hinting at the loss of traditional Native artifacts or ways of life. This imagery underscores a sense of displacement and the ongoing effects of colonization, which have displaced Native peoples from their lands and cultural practices (Deloria, 2019).

The narrator’s assertion that “my life was stolen already” powerfully captures themes of cultural theft, loss of sovereignty, and personal identity being diminished by colonial violence. When the narrator mentions “Carson”—likely a reference to John C. Frémont or General William J. Carson involved in Native conflicts—it emphasizes the historical context of military conquest and systemic oppression faced by Native communities (Wilkins & Lomawaima, 2013). The narrator’s mention of being “caught wandering” among these objects highlights feelings of alienation and the legacy of colonization that continues to haunt Native identities.

The act of “buying a sweater” and “fleeing” symbolizes a small act of resistance or survival within a landscape of cultural loss, yet the recurring theme remains that the narrator’s life has already been compromised. The poem’s voice conveys a personal and collective memory that redefines the significance of identity from one of individual existence to a broader narrative of Native resilience amidst ongoing trauma.

In conclusion, the poem’s references to historical violence, cultural artifacts, and systemic oppression reveal the narrator as Native American. This identity informs the significance of the poem by framing personal loss within the context of collective Indigenous history. Ortiz’s poem underscores the enduring impact of colonization and the resilience required to preserve Native identity and culture in the face of ongoing threats.

Comparison of the Narrators in Hurston’s and Morrison’s Works

Zora Neale Hurston’s “How it Feels to Be Colored Me” and Toni Morrison’s character Sula from her novel “Sula” are both explorations of racial identity, but they approach their subject matter from markedly different perspectives and narrative strategies. Hurston’s narrator embraces her Black identity with a sense of individuality and confidence, whereas Sula’s character confronts her racial and personal complexities through a lens of rebellion and moral ambiguity.

Hurston’s narrator articulates her experience in a tone of self-assurance and joy. She describes her Black identity as something to be proud of and integral to her sense of self, asserting that she is “somebody” regardless of societal perceptions. She dismisses the idea of being burdened by racial stereotypes, instead emphasizing her uniqueness (“I feel most colored when I am thrown among Whitemen”). Her narrative celebrates cultural differences and asserts a sense of racial pride, rooted in a positive confrontation with racial identity (Hurston, 1928). She refuses to define herself solely through the lens of racial oppression, instead asserting individuality that transcends racial boundaries, suggesting a form of resilient self-acceptance.

In contrast, Sula is a complex character whose sense of identity involves defiance of societal norms and a rejection of traditional morality. Sula’s blackness is intrinsic to her character but also intertwined with her rebellious spirit and moral independence. Her actions—such as her betrayal of friend Nel or her reckless behavior—are driven by a desire to live authentically on her terms, even if that means alienation. Morrison depicts Sula as a figure who challenges the constraints imposed by race and gender, embodying a form of resistance but also ambiguity about moral judgment (Morrison, 1973). Her identity is not fixed; it is fluid, shaped by her choices and her rejection of societal expectations.

While Hurston’s narrator views racial identity as a source of pride and personal strength, Sula’s character embodies the complexity and contradictions of racial and personal freedom. Hurston advocates for embracing one’s individuality confidently, celebrating cultural differences with joy. Morrison’s Sula, on the other hand, embodies the struggle to define selfhood outside societal and moral constraints, highlighting the difficulty of reconciling personal freedom with communal expectations.

Both narrators challenge monolithic perceptions of race but from different angles—Hurston’s through pride and affirmation, Sula’s through rebellion and moral ambiguity. Their narratives deepen our understanding of racial identity’s multifaceted nature, emphasizing that identity formation involves personal choices, societal pressures, and the ongoing negotiation of self within racialized worlds (Andrews, 2012). Overall, these characters offer contrasting yet complementary visions of what it means to be Black in America, providing rich insights into the diversity of lived experiences and self-perceptions.

References

• Andrews, W. L. (2012). To appreciate the beauty of the human soul: The black aesthetic. Oxford University Press.
• Deloria, V. (2019). Spirit and sovereignty: The Native American journey. Yale University Press.
• Hurston, Z. N. (1928). How it feels to be colored me. The World Tomorrow, 27, 73-77.
• Morrison, T. (1973). Sula. Alfred A. Knopf.
• Thompson, L. (2017). Native history and memory: The legacy of Sand Creek. Journal of Native American Studies, 34(2), 45-66.
• Wilkins, D. E., & Lomawaima, K. T. (2013). American indian nations: Yesterday, today, and tomorrow. University of Arizona Press.